• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Crusading Began with religious passion but quickly progressed into cynical self interest." To what extent would you agree that this is a fair assessment of the changing nature and purpose of crusading between 1095 and 1204?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Crusading Began with religious passion but quickly progressed into cynical self interest." To what extent would you agree that this is a fair assessment of the changing nature and purpose of crusading between 1095 and 1204? "For they who are supposed to serve Christ rather than themselves...have bathed swords in the blood of Christians." It would appear, from Pope Innocent III after the shocking events of the fourth crusade, that by 1204, the nature or way in which crusading was carried out, had changed, and that the purpose or motivation for the crusades had also. Does this, however, confirm a progression from initial religious passion, to cynical self interest? Although it is easy to label the atrocities of 1204 as being acts of cynical self-interest, where the individual was motivated by personal, secular goals, it must be determined whether there was once an ecclesiastical motivation, where religious passion was the key motivating factor. The four crusades between 1095 and 1204 show that there were distinct differences in the way in which each these holy wars were carried out and it must, therefore, be determined whether the changing motivation for the crusades was a cause of this, starting with the first crusade, and finishing with the fourth. Certain sources indicate that religious passion was a key factor in the first crusade. The language used in Pope Urban II's call for the crusade show distinct religious passion, but also condemns cynical self-interest, as a motivating factor: "..... ...read more.

Middle

He points out that "although our expedition was not good for the extension of boundaries or for the comfort of our bodies, it was good for the salvation of many souls." This not only indicates that religious passion was an inherent motivating factor, even at the end, but also claims that it was more important than the concept of early foreign expansion, as a motivating factor. The best example of the nature of crusading being unaffected by cynical self-interest is when, on the 17th of June 1147, Louis VII of France would not use his crusader army to attack the Christian city of Constantinople, in order to free it. This shows a marked difference between the attitudes of the second and fourth crusades, as in 1204, Constantinople was sacked by a crusader army. It has therefore been shown that, like the first crusade, religious passion was mixed with other motivating factors, including cynical self-interest, but that it was often the overriding motivating factor for the second crusade. Despite the presence of cynical self-interest, it was, at this time, not the key motivation for the crusaders. The call for the third crusade was came after the fall of Jerusalem to Saladin. Again, it would appear that the focus of the crusade lay in religious goals, as Jerusalem had little secular value, but was still of key importance in religious circles. This is exemplified by the call of Pope Gregory VIII, for the crusade, where he desires that the crusaders do not go for "profit or earthly glory," in much the same way as Urban II, in the first crusade. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Venitians, who were to transport the armies to the Holy Land by ship insisted that the Christian City of Zara be attacked, evidently to me their own needs. The nature of crusading, by this point has certainly changed, as the crusaders were to attack a Christian city, and this shows that all values of Religious passion had been cast aside in favour of cynical self-interest. The plea by Guy of Vaux-de-Cernay shows how the crusaders had completely forgotten the concept of religious passion, and that cynical self-interest had taken over as the overriding motivation: "I forbid you, on behalf of the Pope of Rome, to attack this city, for those are Christians and you are crusaders!" However, this was not the end of the change from religious passion, to cynical self-interest. On April 12th 1204, Constantinople was attacked by a crusader army. It seems that the crusaders had easily forgotten the events in the city of Zara, which had made the crusade an excomunicate, and after attaining the forgiveness of the Pope, the sacking of Constantinople occured. The nature of crusading had degenerated, by this stage to the extent that "they have not spared religion, nor age, nor sex and have committed fornication and adultery in public." There can be no doubt, then, that the fourth crusade marks the point where cynical self-interest overtook Religious passion, as the key motivating factor for the crusades. the crusaders did not care about reclaiming Jerusalem, as it never even reached the city. Furthermore, the willingness to attack fellow Christians for secular rewards shows the polar opposite of religious passion, in cynical self-interest. Peter Mitchell D13 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Religion in the Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Religion in the Media essays

  1. "Modern Britain is now a Secular Society." To what extent do Sociological arguments and ...

    In the Roman Catholic Church the number of congregation might be underestimated so that more of the Capitation can be kept for the Parish. It is also possible that more people may 'worship' as individuals or may not be able to attend church, surely this doesn't mean that they

  2. Discuss the merits of theories of secularisation with regard to religion in modern Britain

    Thus, there is no particular inconsistency in believing that it is morally wrong to kill, steal or commit adultery and atheism. However, in terms of the secularisation debate it is important to separate these types of moral guide-lines from the overtly "supernatural" content of religions (a belief in "god" / "gods", the after-life and so forth).

  1. Are Near Death Experience's a valid form of Religious Experience

    causing the individual to have visual hallucination, a panoramic recall of their life and intense feelings of both loneliness and joy. "Believers" counteract these arguments saying "but that individual wasn't......" The individual wasn't on drugs or without oxygen. Drugs don't cause moral and social changes.

  2. "Assess the view that religious language is meaningless."

    A lunatic is paranoid that all his university professors want to kill him, and even when shown the nicest of profs he still irrationally believes that they wish death on him. Despite all evidence, religious believers still have an irrefutable belief in God.

  1. 'Modern Britain is now a Secular Society.' To what extent do Sociological arguments and ...

    That is not to say that supporters of the secularisation thesis necessarily believe that religion will disappear completely. Instead they argue that in some sense religion will decline in significance. For example, Bryan Wilson defines secularisation as 'the process whereby religious thinking, practise and institutions lose social significance' (Wilson, 1966).

  2. Desiderius Erasmus and Christian Humanism.

    To the Popes, Cardinals, and Bishops, Erasmus questions why they feel that they have the knowledge to answer any and all existential questions concerning human origin and human destiny. How is it that to err is human nature, but the Pope can lead a life without trespass or blame?

  1. Religious Orders

    Apostolic orders are the first type of religious orders. They live a life of voluntary community work. They tend the sick and old and care for the homeless.

  2. Memoirs of our journey to acquire Religious freedom

    Each settler who paid �100 would receive 300 acres of land and those who came, as servants would receive 25 acres. I felt that these rules were superior for this time however they were not carried out they way they should have been.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work