• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain and Evaluate a Utilitarian approach to the issue of abortion

Extracts from this document...


24/11/04 Explain and Evaluate a Utilitarian approach to the issue of abortion The issue of abortion has become more and more prevalent in the last 20 years as science has evolved into what we know today. However, that does not mean that it is now easy for people to realize its effects. When killing a foetus, you are killing a life, the autonomy of a person and any possible future contributions that life could have made. Religious organizations argue that humans don't have authority over life and death- as God is the life-creator and giver. Utilitarianism however, from the views of Bentham and Mill takes an entirely different approach on the topic. We must firstly realize that in Utilitarianism there are no absolute rules that one must follow in a religion such as Christianity or Islam. Christianity has very stringent rules on the issue of 'murder' and abortion. Utilitarianism, however, always looks at the circumstances of an action and in some cases says that actions, even that of murder, can be argued for and justified. Bentham would allow an abortion (murder) to take place if his Hedonic Calculus shows that it would result in more pleasure or pain for the people involved. Mill, on the other hand, would use his concept of higher and lower pleasures in determining whether an action is justified or not. ...read more.


This question in the calculus is not a particularly hard one to answer. The death of your child in the womb is going to be as personal a thing as it is possible to be isn't it? Grievance for something that you have not even had the chance to see and feel with your bare hands is very hard to take. The guilt and sense of not doing your duty to God would be the hardest things to swallow though. We should all respect our duty as humans because we have the ability to take life whenever we want to. Murderers can be put into prison for over 30 years for murder- why should this be any different when we are allowing babies to be killed even though they have brains, bodies, souls and they can feel pain. Questions like this one come into many doctors' minds when talking about the operation that they feel they have a right to give to women. Fecundity and purity give you the possibility of what will result from the action. A lot of pleasure could ensue but pain might also be there to a very real extent. In the case of abortion, we know that a lot of pain is directed to both the baby and the mother so it begs the question 'does the pain outweigh the pleasure in this situation?' ...read more.


It's dilemmas like this that make this topic such a difficult one to give a definitive answer on. There are quite a few problems of relating utilitarianism to abortion. Abortion devalues the human life if you have to say when is a person a person? It's a slippery slope in killing weaker members of society. Bentham however ignores the rights of the minority so you could find his theory as being difficult to apply to abortion seeing as the foetus does not have proper rights until it's born. There are a number of things that are good though about using utilitarianism in this example. Firstly, it's not a religious belief which means it can be used universally without anyone taking offence. Rule utilitarianism gives us a guideline to follow that helps people in dilemmas. It's quite rational to base abortion on pleasure and pain. Any consequentialist approach faces the flaw that it is very difficulty to predict the consequences of abortion. You never know what the foetus will or would have actually achieved in his/her life anyway. The foetus could have grown to be a Mozart that would have given much pleasure to millions of people in the world or, on the other hand, he/she could have developed into a Hitler type figure that sent many innocent Jews to death. We will never actually be able to predict the consequences of our actions so the question is very difficult to answer. However, utilitarianism has many positive features and it provides a logical way to approach an emotive issue. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. The Moral Issue of Abortion

    On the Internet it was hard to find the information that I needed. I found lots of sites with the for or against argument. I had to go on the sites and pick out the relevant information. Abortion is controversial because some people believe in the sanctity of life and

  2. Abortion arguments and powerful images

    serious sin and that everyone, whether Catholic or not, should have a proper respect for human life". Roman Catholics try to encourage women to not have abortions but to have the baby adopted if they really couldn't live with it As this church believes so strongly that abortions are wrong,

  1. Christian approaches to abortion.

    be considered murder, however, there are some "pro-choice" Christian groups that find quotes that they use to prove that abortion is in fact biblical. God speaks about abortion in only two places in the Bible. 1) Accidental Abortion: "If a brawling man happens to strike a pregnant woman and causes

  2. In this essay I will only focus on the religion of Christianity and its ...

    The Roman Catholic Church has the most traditional line on abortion. They believe the baby gains a soul at conception- Ensolement and that abortion is morally evil. They will not allow abortion under any circumstances what so ever, in fact they say, "All people must realise that only God can

  1. The First thought on abortion.

    The women should be experiencing a dreadful amount of pain after this procedure is done. This is a picture of the Dilation and curettage Method, as you can see the baby is being scraped out With a curved instrument. Page 5 Dilation and curettage method can also be used for different procedures; 1.

  2. Abortion, like any other controversial issue, is not a black and white matter.

    Even down to the Middle Ages in Western Europe, abortion seemed to be a common practice. However, public opinion started to change, so much so that in 1869 the Roman Catholic Church even outlawed abortion. In the early 19th century England and the United States passed on strict anti-abortion laws.iii

  1. Abortion…what is it? Abortion is difficult to define because everybody has a different opinion ...

    a representative of God on Earth or part of God, so if you kill a foetus you are wounding God. Another similar reference about the creation of Samson (Judges 13:6-7): ' You shall conceive and give birth to a son...

  2. Not allowing women unobstructed access to abortion, is a social injustice and a violation ...

    (Morgentaler, Ethics of Abortion, 15) It cannot be considered a human being until it has the attributes of a human being, such as a heart, brain, lungs and other internal organs, and these organs should be fully formed before it can be considered a human being.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work