• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Present the strengths and weaknesses of Augustine's and Ireneaus' theodicy

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Present the strengths and weaknesses of Augustine's and Ireneaus' theodicy 'Evil did not come from God, since God's creation was faultless and perfect' (St Augustine) St Augustine was a man wrote a theodicy about the problem of evil and suffering based on the Creation and Fall of Genesis in the bible, he believed that evil was caused by something that was outside the omnipotence of God. God himself is all powerful but after creating the world, he Himself would not be able to control the actions that human beings create in changing it. When God created the world, with absolutely no evil and suffering, he saw what he had done and saw it was all good. God did not deprivate the world from having evil and suffering and he has no reason to have any blame for it as God created the world with nothing bad inside it. Evil is not a substance that could have been created by God, therefore he cannot be responsible for it. I think that this was a weak point in Augustine's theodicy because he cannot truthfully call evil a substance as humans do not know how much more God could have done to create the world. ...read more.

Middle

He created both the humans and the angels, which later turned to evil and suffering because of jealousy and greed. If God made the earth, if he made it as perfect and wholly as Augustine argued, then it should have been able to be protected from the evil and suffering. Even if it was created by the humans and angels. How would evil and suffering be known to have happened from humans and angels if it had not have happened before in the past, in other words. God would have had to created evil to know what it actually was. Therefore the humans and angels disobeyed God, only from the creation of evil before them. Augustine believes that humans and angels have made a mockery out of the earth and it's creation. But he is mocking the scientific theory that evolution of man had played a big part in this. Relying on the design argument for the universe and God helped Augustine have a stronger point saying that by evolution happening and the number of humans increasing he is assuming that this scientific theory is the answer to the evil and suffering. ...read more.

Conclusion

If humans are left to have the choice in turning to evil and suffering or good and are still rewarded by going to heaven, according to Irenaeus, then why does there have to be such deaths such as the Holocaust where 6 million Jews were killed. Suffering cannot be an act of God, even if God did make the world imperfectly he would not approve of millions of people dying for the greed and jealousy of other humans. Love from God cannot be expressed by the death of people, that is not right. People dying of natural diseases that cannot be helped and going to heaven is not as sinful as people dying for no apparent reason and going to heaven. 'Gods gift of free will is in no way an excuse for the existence of evil' If God knows the consequences of the humans that he had created then why give them the choice of free will. Humans are like robots, their actions can already be concluded before even having chosen them yet. Therefore God would have known what the consequences of evil and suffering could be. For example; wars, dying, the Holocaust and less economically developed countries. An omnipotent God would not have made humans suffer from evil for any purpose. By Emma Milligan ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Cosmological Argument

    Both supporters of the cosmological argument and those who deny it use the Big Bang theory as a proof for or against the existnece of God. Scientific observation has confirmed that there was a beginning to the universe and has provided further evidence that the universe developed a structure very early in its history.

  2. Persuasive Writing on the Holocaust

    Emil Fackenheim was a Canadian rabbi and philosopher. His work mainly dealt with the problem of revelation in Israel. He studied the academic of Jewish studies. Sadly he passed away last year (2003) He was a real believer and would not let Hitler celebrate his victory.

  1. Show how the theodicies of Irenaeus and Augustine account for natural evil.

    This process is referred to s 'soul-making'. From this point of view, evil is a means to an end. The world of good and evil is essential for us to move towards perfection so that we can fulfill God's purpose. (b) 'The existence of natural evil destroys any argument that God is good' Discuss.

  2. Outline the Contribution that Process Theology Makes to Solving the Problem of Evil & ...

    Given the extent of evil in the world, perhaps no world at all, with no evil and no suffering, is more attractive than a world in which the Holocaust in justified. In addition to these criticisms, a God that is not omnipotent, that suffers with people, that is contingent upon

  1. Good and Evil

    when there is an absence of human wish, which leads to an immoral action; this means it can be a type of evil that humans implement unwillingly. Thomas Aquinas stated that because God is 'infinitely good' to allow evil there must be no god, so his point was that evil is not real and it only exists in our minds.

  2. Explain how the theodicy of Irenaeus differs from that of Augustine.

    Therefore evil is not only a result of our free will, it is necessary in order for us to achieve true perfection in the image of God and has a purpose in life. Augustine's theodicy contradicts Irenaeus' in that it suggests that evil is not an integral part of God's plan, but arose from flawed beings- i.e.

  1. Research on St Augustine Theodicy.

    All evil must have at least some good in it. So according to Augustine, to exist is to partake of goodness (Being) and where there is a lack of goodness there is also a lack of being. Yet it seems that in saying this he is blurring a distinction between being (in the sense of qualitative degrees of existence)

  2. Outline the key strengths and weaknesses of the teleological argument.

    Therefore, a designer did not create the universe, rather, it is the result of natural forces bringing random particles together through time. However, there are many criticisms of the teleological argument. One of these is that not everything has a purpose - the appendix in a human serves no purpose.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work