• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Virtue ethics is of little practical use to someone faced with a moralproblem. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


b) Virtue ethics is of little practical use to someone faced with a moral problem. Discuss. A woman has 4 children. Her house is on fire. She has already saved 3 of the children but there is one child left in the house. Should she go into the burning house and risk losing her life and leaving the other 3 children behind without a mother? Which would be the more moral thing to do? Virtue Ethics would tell the woman to do what a good person would do. Robert Louden writes that 'We ought, of course, to do what the virtuous person would do, but it is not always easy to fathom what the hypothtical moral exemplar would do were hge in our shoes...' ...read more.


It is too hard to be dependant upon virtue ethics when faced with a moral dilema. The mean may be too hard to find, and sometimes there may not even be a mean, for example promise-keeping, compassion and loyalty are inherently good. They don't seem to lie between two extremes. However, some people would argue that virtue ethics would come in very useful when a person is facing a moral dilema. For example, in the case of when a mother is deciding whether or not to have an abortion, she has time to think over her problem and can think of the various outcomes and things she could do. One virtue is compassion, and so if the woman is compassionate about having the abortion, then her decision must be virtuous. ...read more.


It could be better for the woman not to have the baby because the child could be brought into a life where it couldn't be looked after properly. It all depends on the situation. Another example is considering whether the war on Iraq is moral. Is it just to kill 10 000 people in Iraq in order to stop Saddam Husein from ruling? We have to consider the whole situation - we know that Saddam Husein could be in possession of nuclear weapons therefore it would be more moral to try to stop him in whatever way we can. Overall I think that dependant on the situation, virtue ethics would be of some use to someone facing a moral dilema, as they give an all-round view on the situation and make sure that the outcome will be a virtuous one. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ethics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ethics essays

  1. Explain Virtue ethics. Virtue ethics is of little practical use to someone with a ...

    This associates itself with eudaimonia, which is deserving to be happy. Eudaimonia means more than just happiness it is about being worthy of the joy that you as a person are receiving. For Aristotle Eudaimonia is the highest good because it is desired for its own sake, rather than ulterior motives.

  2. Aristotle - Virtue Ethics Essay

    someone else as a means to an end or allow others to use people solely as a means by not lying, this is surely morally objectionable. Hume's criticism was that reason does not motivate moral action. Is reason sufficient to motivate us to do out duty?

  1. Explain how Aristotle and Alasdair Macintyre applied Virtue Theory to moral decision making?

    Rightness or wrongness is determined by the kind of person one is, not simply by the consequences of the acts one commits, which is the essence of virtue theory. Actions may be evidence of virtue, or lack of, but they are not in themselves virtues.

  2. Virtue Ethics is of little practical use to someone faced with a dilemma. Discuss.

    Therefore, if a person has practiced virtues like 'be brave' all their lives, then, when faced with a dilemma, virtues like 'be brave' and 'be courageous' come naturally to them, thus guide them through moral dilemmas. Whether or not virtue theory guides people through a moral dilemma is weighted heavily upon the person.

  1. With reference to abortion, examine and comment on the view that the sanctity of ...

    even if they do not result in bad acts. Once this is recognized, supporters argue that utilitarianism becomes a much more complex, and rich, moral theory, and may align much more closely with our moral intuitions. Some critics reject utilitarianism, both rule and act, on the basis that it is seems to be incompatible with human rights.

  2. Religion and Medical Ethics

    Islamic lawyers have banned all other types of embryo technology (AID and Surrogacy), because they deny the child's right to know its parents. This, in the eyes of Muslims, is equivalent to adoption and adultery (zina) which is strictly banned in Islam.

  1. Virtue Ethics

    Others would argue that people who follow virtue ethics are selfish, as it puts oneself before others. For example if a murder came to your front door and said "I'm going to murder your brother, is he in please?" a person who follows virtue ethics would feel its wrong to lie, would therefore tell the murderer where he was.

  2. Explain Virtue Ethics

    Aristotle says we are most likely to acquire virtues by observing others in our society. If we experience other people being kind to us and see the happiness it creates we are more likely to practice this virtue then if we were just told to practice it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work