Preliminary
We have got relatively good results, for example the potato cores that had 0% concentration of salt around them were meant to get bigger and the potato cores with 100% salt around them were meant to get smaller which did happen. We did encounter some problems with doing this experiment which meant it was not easy to carry out and we found out that getting one core of potato and chopping it into three took up too much space in a potato and was hard to find a potato big enough. , originally we were going to measure volume but our preliminary work showed that it was unreliable. Also with this accuracy is limited as you’re only getting results from one potato, the results would be better to take a repetition from a different potato instead of taking repetitions from the same core which is not really showing anything. So for our actual recording for coursework we took our repetitions from a different potato as there is more variation and ensure accuracy. We did start to use volumes. However results were inconclusive and it deteriorated the reliability as the potato core had got wet and even though we dried it is no 100% that it is completely dry, this could affect osmosis when we place it in the test tube.
Equipment
- 10 test tubes
- spachula
- pipette
- scales
- chopping board
- knife
- potato corer
- potato
We did our preliminary work to try out our initial ideas but after we saw some of the problems that this involved we improved it, we increased accuracy and reliability by using more concentrates. This ensures that if we get different results from different potatoes it will help us come to a conclusion, if we only have results from one potato in effect we are reviewing osmosis in that potato not on more of a general scale. In my experiment I have changed the concentration of the salt, kept the time the same (24 hours), the length of the potato core is consistently the same, although we cannot control the weight. The length is a consistent 2.1 cm, the weight varies from 1.78 to 1.88, and this shows the variation in density among different potatoes, although this is only 0.1 of a gram.
Here we can see how I will present my results, the weight was taken as an average of two but for 11 of the results they were exactly the same both times. The scales measured to two decimal places. I feel this is very accurate and will be good for my results. When I take my results after it will be very important to make sure that the piece of potato core is dry are measuring how osmosis has affected our results, however if they are wet they could alter our results and make our conclusion inaccurate. What we expect to see is a difference in size and weight amongst the potato cores. From our results I hope to be able to estimate the water concentration within a potato core, this will be in the gap between where the % change is positive and negative.
The box plot I have done above shows the range of the percentage change from the before weight and the after weight. The median is 0, which is perfect for our conclusion as it shows that it is increasing in weight at the same rate that it is decreasing in weight when osmosis is occuring. The fact that it is in order for example the first % change is the largest % change in its group and the last in its group is the smallest.
Conclusion
The potato cores have increased in weight when the water concentration in the solution is higher than that in the potato. The weight in the potato core decreases when the water concentration in the solution is lower then that in the potato, this happen as the water molecules diffuse from the potato cells into the solution. On the other hand when the weight increases the water concentration in the solution is higher than that in the potato, so osmosis occurs and the water travels into the cells and makes the cells increase in weight and size. We choose to use weight as the main way to investigate osmosis, this is because in our preliminary the results were better, and also I feel it was more accurate as they were getting measured by scales and to two decimal places. This conclusively would make our percentage change more accurate. From our results we know that the concentration of water in a potato is between 40 and 60% but roughly 45%. We can see that we have a curve that is reliable and accurate.
Evaluation