• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare two stories from Opening Worlds which explore the idea of conflict - 'The Winter Oak' and 'The Red Ball',

Extracts from this document...


9th October 2002 Compare two stories from Opening Worlds which explore the idea of conflict The two short stories, 'The Winter Oak' and 'The Red Ball', are set in completely different cultures. For example, 'The Winter Oak' is set in Communist Russia and 'The Red Ball' is set in Port of Spain, the capital city of Trinidad and Tobago. This is the main difference between the stories. 'The Winter Oak' is set in Russia where the main belief is of equality, while 'The Red Ball' is set in the very relaxed Caribbean country of Trinidad and Tobago. The technique of the authors shows this great contrast in culture. However, although they are both set in different cultures, they are both set at around the same time. They are both set in the mid 20th century, a time of tragedy and war! Both the stories are written about 'outsiders' (people who don't fit into their society). For example, 'The Winter Oak' is written about a young schoolboy who doesn't fit into society, and who lives very much in his own little world. In the classroom, his fellow classmates ridicule the boy, who is called Savushkin, as he is regarded as inferior. He is very caught up in his own world, which seems to revolve around a winter oak tree. 'Savushkin stood up in his desk, and shouted out in a ringing tone: 'Winter oak.' ...read more.


In 'The Winter Oak', the conflicts are between the teacher and the school, (the teacher and the pupil), and between the 'outsider' and the Russian society. In 'The Winter Oak', the teacher realises that the pupil doesn't fit into the society, and she tries to help him. He brings her 'into his own little world' by showing her his beloved winter oak tree, and here he becomes the teacher, as his life seems to revolve around the winter oak. For example, in line 192 it reads, 'No, Anna Vasilevna, I'm swaying this branch, and that's its shadow moving.' Anna Vasilevna bit hr tongue. Clearly here in the forest she had better keep quiet.' These three sentences tell us that in the forest, Savushkin, the little boy, is the teacher, while Anna Vasilevna is the pupil. Nagibin here uses a clever technique in which he reverses the roles of the teacher and the pupil. The relationship between the pupil and the teacher is quite strong, as she feels sorry for him. He also treats her with respect, for after all, he is her teacher. However, the relationship between the boy and society isn't as strong. He doesn't fit into society at all, as he lives very much in his own world. He is an outsider, and the teacher and his classmates know it. He is very much isolated in the story, and the reader can't help but to feel sorry for him. ...read more.


This is not the case with the boy in 'The Winter Oak'. Although they are both 'outsiders', the boy in 'The Red Ball' attempts to fit into society and will soon, in my opinion, be part of it. However, Savushkin, in 'The Winter Oak' isn't a newcomer. He just naturally doesn't fit into society. He is very much stuck up in his own little world, but this is not the case with the boy in 'The Red Ball'. The boy in 'The Red Ball' (although he doesn't show it) desperately wants to fit into society, but Savushkin shows no intention of this. He is content being excluded from society, for all he is bothered about is his winter oak. However, apart from that little factor, the stories are very similar. As a conclusion, I can safely say that the two stories are based about 'outsiders', as this is their main similarity. The main difference between the stories is the cultures in which they are set, but apart from that they are very much similar. Nagibin and Khan both use similar writing techniques, as they both write from the eyes of a narrator. They are both very similar stories. They were both an enjoyable read, but my favourite has got to be 'The Winter Oak'. This is because the author makes us feel sorry for Savushkin. Also, the author is very clever when he reverses the role between the teacher and the pupil. It is a very exciting and interesting read. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. ‘Wandering between two worlds, one dead, The other powerless to be born.’

    where his ideas seem to have been checked by the industrial efficiency and mass uniformity of Victorian Britain. He senses that his is a dying point of view and compares it to the beliefs of the long gone Hellenic civilisation that he idealised in line 81.

  2. Evaluate the idea that class conflict is on the decline in contemporary France, paying ...

    lord and serf, guild-master and journeyman, in a word, oppressor and oppressed, stood in constant opposition to one another, carried on an uninterrupted, now hidden, now open fight, a fight that each time ended, either in a revolutionary reconstitution of society at large, or in the common ruin of the

  1. Do a detailed critical analysis of the opening of Coetzee's Foe, paying particular attention ...

    However my use of the word attacks should not be taken too literally because directly no issues are addressed however it is clear in the subtext what points he wants to throw into debate. The main function of the opening is to throw Defoe's apparent true novel of Crusoe into

  2. All Falls Apart by Chinua Achebe and A Vendetta by Gay De Maupassant both ...

    Okonkwo is kept in stream with the society. He is strongly supported by his clansman not only because he is the leader but also because he is expected to carry out the sacrifice . In fact the society in A Vendetta is also a male dominated as the name 'Paolo Saverini's widow' itself suggests.

  1. From a reading of Hardy's short stories, discuss how Hardy brings out the aspects ...

    From this quote it is quite visible that she hardly interacted with anyone, and she was more of a quite and silent person being a 'lady', and her stepping out of class had caused her be a person who kept contemplating on how her life might have been with Sam Hobson, the man she loved very much.

  2. A Short Time in the Life of a Teacher

    actually people, not just part of the job, even if no one else does. ' And this is for your form Taisie' The deputy head, Sharyn Tinton, shoves a wadge of paper into my hand with rules and regulations plastered all over them - the usual - no jewellery, no body piercing, no blah, blah, blah.

  1. An analysis of three short stories written by Kate Chopin, 1914.

    In 1870, at the age of twenty she married Oscar Chopin, he was the son of a wealthy cotton growing family. Unlike the female characters Chopin writes of, her independence and intelligence was admired by her husband. They lived in New Orleans and had seven children before she was twenty

  2. Tea Master, Samurai and Teacher

    This reminds me that there has to be a reason for your devotion. This Samurai was devoted to her revenge and it makes me wonder what my devotion really is. I am devoted to teaching but why? The only real answer I can think of is anger.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work