• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Hedda Gabler and Miss Julie

Extracts from this document...


[Name of institution] [Name of writer] Hedda Gabler and Miss Julie Introduction Ibs?n's H?dda Gabl?r and Strindb?rg's Miss Juli? ar? compl?x works which hav? b??n thoroughly analys?d sinc? th?y w?r? writt?n ov?r on? hundr?d y?ars ago. In this r?s?arch w? will conduct a d?tail?d comparison of th? two and so I shall, inst?ad, conc?ntrat? upon a singl? issu?: wh?th?r th? f?mal? l?ads in ?ach play n??d?d to commit suicid?. In my r?s?arch I will d?t?rmin? wh?th?r or not it was n?c?ssary for H?dda Gabl?r of H?nrik Ibs?n's 'H?dda Gabl?r' and Miss Juli? of August Strinb?rg's 'Miss Juli?' to di?. Purpos? of study August Strindb?rg and H?nrik Ibs?n w?r? both gr?at playwrights of th? 19th c?ntury, and both play?d a larg? rol? in th? ?volution of mod?rn day naturalism/ r?alism. Th? plays I will b? discussing ar? Ibs?n's H?dda Gabl?r, (1890) and Strindb?rg's Miss Juli? (1888). In Kar?n's l?ctur? on Strindb?rg, sh? told how th? two playwrights w?r? rivals in a s?ns?, mainly caus?d by Strindb?rg's attitud?s on social issu?s- Nam?ly his thoughts and th?ory on th? rol? of wom?n in soci?ty. Thus, I am l?ad to b?li?v? that H?dda Gabl?r was writt?n by Ibs?n as a dir?ct r?taliation to Strindb?rg's Miss Juli?, just as Kar?n b?li?v?s that Strindb?rg's Th? Fath?r was writt?n as a r?ply to Ibs?n's Ghosts. Although both plays ?nd with th? suicid? of th? ...read more.


has nothing to liv? for. Only h?r d?ad fath?r has s?t an ?xampl? of h?roism. His portrait fac?s us from th? small inn?r room for th? whol? of th? play and r?minds us of his influ?nc? ov?r his daught?r. W? ar? to inf?r that sh? has inh?rit?d his st??ly r?solv? (Garton, pp 45-367). So, H?dda has to di?, but should w? car?? I b?li?v? w? should. Sh? is sarcastic, haughty and brittl? and on? would c?rtainly not wish to shar? a flat with h?r but it is difficult not to f??l, from a saf? distanc?, a c?rtain admiration and pity for th? woman. Ibs?n purpos?ly ?xagg?rat?d T?sman's stupidity in lat?r drafts of th? play (Strindberg, pp 27-190)to show how difficult it would b? for a high-mind?d p?rson lik? H?dda to b? marri?d to him. Th? s?ns? of suffocation sh? must f??l is compound?d wh?n sh? has to ?ndur? his aunt's solicitations and low?r-class mann?rs. Sh? also has to suff?r knowing comm?nts about h?r pr?gnancy and dr?ads th? thought of having a baby sinc? it ?pitomiz?s th? drudg?ry and crudity of th? ?v?ryday world. Sh? symbolically d?stroys th? infant wh?n sh? burns Lo?vb?rg's manuscript at th? ?nd of Act Thr??. T?llingly, as point?d out by Garton (Strindberg, pp 27-190) sh? actually says, in Norw?gian, 'burn th? child' rath?r than 'your child' as it is usually translat?d It could b? ...read more.


att?mpts to dominat? h?r fianc´┐Ż, but this is primarily du? to h?r upbringing by h?r moth?r (Stanton, pp 11-190). Lik? H?dda sh? is highly influ?nc?d by h?r fath?r. Strindb?rg ?mphasiz?s th? abs?nt mast?r's pow?r by having a larg? b?ll on stag? which h? us?s to summon his val?t. Also, at th? b?ginning of th? play J?an plac?s th? mast?r's riding boots wh?r? w? can s?? th?m. As not?d ?arli?r, H?dda Gabl?r is h?r fath?r's daught?r and wish?s to ?mulat? him but Miss Juli? is, p?rhaps, afraid of h?r fath?r. At th? ?nd of th? play, Miss Juli? has implod?d ?motionally, lacking any will-pow?r to think for h?rs?lf. In this stat?, it is improbabl? that, sh? could summon up th? m?ntal ?n?rgy to kill h?rs?lf. Strindb?rg was int?r?st?d in hypnotism (Strindberg, pp 27-190) and th?r? is an implication that Miss Juli? is in a tranc? wh?n sh? tak?s th? razor from J?an, but th?r? is no ?vid?nc? that a hypnotist can caus? p?opl? to harm th?ms?lv?s, n?v?r mind commit suicid?. Conclusion In summary, H?dda Gabl?r n??ds to di?, and to di? boldly to assur? us that th?r? is h?roism l?ft in th? world. W? f??l sorry for h?r sinc? h?r motiv?s ar? worthy if misguid?d, but can tak? som? comfort from h?r act. Miss Juli?, in contrast, do?s not hav? to di?. Sh? is alr?ady d?grad?d and h?r d?mis? is an unn?c?ssary coda to ?v?nts. Sh? should liv?, to ?ndur? th? wrath of h?r fath?r and to ?nsur? J?an pays for his misb?haviour. H?r suicid? is a capitulation in comparison to H?dda's positiv? and d?fiant g?stur?. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. An examination of how Ibsen and Lorca present the confinement of women in their ...

    Furthermore, the negative connotation on 'out here' directly implies that she doesn't like living in the house. On the other hand, this line creates ambiguity and might also suggest that the house is far from populated area. This also indicates confinement from people.

  2. Examine the tragic elements in the characterization of Hedda Gabler

    Hamlet is unquestionably an honorable man with upstanding qualities whom the audience is expected to admire. It is not so clear how we are to view Hedda. At one point I fell that Hedda should be condemned for her selfishness and destructiveness, then later I admired for her courage and determination.

  1. 'The Simple Bard, unbroke by rules or Art'. (Burns epigraph to the Kilmarnockedition). How ...

    The bard is a figure of passion, honesty and integrity, a peasant who is riling against those armed classes, who breech the peripheries of his idyll, in the song 'Westlin Winds' (p. 153). Burns cultivation of the bardic persona is therefore given absolute authority in his themes.

  2. Comparison Between the set roles of Late 19th Century men in the two plays ...

    Dr Rank, a well-respected doctor, represents the weaker side of men, both physically through his illness which is probably a sexually transmitted disease inherited from his father and also being susceptible to Nora. In 'Ms Julia' the main male character is Jean, whose rank in society does not exceed one of a footman.

  1. The Grapes of Wrath

    The conversation between the farmer and the bulldozer illustrates an important fact. "Who gave you orders? I'll go after him. You're wrong. He got his orders from the bank" (pg 40). The farmer thinks it is just a group of people who gave out this order.

  2. Muriel Spark’s ‘The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie’

    by forcible suppression of opposition." In the novel we see Jean Brodie almost taking on a fascistic role and fascist ideology by dictating to her girls her opinions on life and what she thinks is right and wrong. " She is the absolute creed of right and wrong " She expects them to take on board the 'Brodie ideology'.

  1. Lady Of Letters: How believable do you find the transformation of Miss Ruddock in ...

    being mistreated, when all she's seen is no tablecloth and a few other things that are so small. But because this is wrong in her mind, and doesn't match up to her standards, there must be something wrong. This is also like saying that anyone who isn't a copy of her must be doing something wrong.

  2. The poem that I am going to talk about is the Unknown Citizen by ...

    the same company the author says he never got fired, It also talks about how he was satisfactory. This man is getting a monument to him in his honour for being satisfactory? Yet again there is another report on him, this time from his Union.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work