• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How do the writers Thomas Hardy and Alice Walker use their protagonist's Roselily and Phyllis to explore the conflict between social convention and personal desires?

Extracts from this document...


How do the writers Thomas Hardy and Alice Walker use their protagonist's Roselily and Phyllis to explore the conflict between social convention and personal desires? In the Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion, Thomas Hardy chooses to explore the conflict between social convention and personal desires by creating a situation in which his central character, Phyllis, has to choose whether or not to follow her personal desires under the theme of love. Like in Roselily by Alice Walker, the same situation is explored again through love. However the way in which the two different writers choose to explore this theme is somewhat different. Both of the writers are renound for their individual feelings and sensitivity towards the position of women in society, and I feel that this is one of the main reasons for the two writers choosing their protagonist characters to be women and also for them choosing a subject, such as love, which especially women, in the past have found to be very troubling and emotional. The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion is a story of a young woman named Phyllis. Her life, which up until now has been somewhat alone and isolated from not only society but her family also, is interrupted by the marriage, arranged by her father, to Humphrey Gould. This Phyllis is not too keen on but due to the fact that Phyllis gives total respect to her father, as any girl would have done back in the eighteenth century, when the story was written, she decides to go along with the marriage. ...read more.


I would consider the ceremony something society nowadays would see as social convention. As Roselily is a contempory piece of writing we, as readers find it easy to relate to issues raised in the text as they apply to conventions and personal desires of people of today's world. It is much harder, however to relate to issues and standards that were expected of people in the time that The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion was set, as things change. They move on and it is clear through the two piece of writing that conventions and the expectations from society today compared with the society of the eighteen hundreds are different. Another theme that is explored in the two texts in isolation and alienation. Both women are isolated from society. In both texts there are no references to motherly figures, which I feel adds to the fact that the two women are isolated also from sex. Words such as "silently" and "alone" which are common in both texts suggest such ideas. Both women are also stepping into alien culture by following either their personal desires or social convention; both worlds are ones that are un experienced by both protagonist characters. Culture and surrounding environment is another theme that is dwelled upon by the writers. Roselily is very much focused on culture and religion more so than The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion, but home and way of life is mentioned quite frequently in both texts. ...read more.


The Melancholy Hussar of The German Legion begins in 1st person and then moves on to 3rd person removed whereas Roselily is written in 3rd person removed throughout. I feel in Roselily this has some symbolism, the fact that she in herself doesn't really want to be at the marriage ceremony by writing in 3rd person removed, she is allowing herself in effect to be removed from the ceremony herself. The actual realism of this is bought back through the wedding vows read aloud by the preacher. In conclusion, it is clear that both women in both texts are oppressed and dominated by their higher male figures - In The Melancholy Hussar of The German Legion it is her father, which dominates, and in Roselily it is her future husband. Both women end up doing what they believe to be for the best although they both express doubt is doing so, and also both women went against the convention of the society they are surrounded by. The texts have got their similarities and differences but both are extremely effective in conveying the conflict between social convention and personal desires and the problems people have to overcome when deciding which to follow. I think the piece, which appealed to me most, was Roselily; this is because it is contemporary so I found it easier to relate to the moral values of people and the issues of the story and how they were raised. Also the informality of it appealed to me more than Hardy's traditional formal style of writing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. How does Willy Russell use his characters to show social differences?

    Russell's use of sentence structure creates a huge contrast between the boys and emphasizes their upbringing. "Cos me mam says..." "Well my mummy doesn't allow me to play down here actually!" The way in which Edward uses more complex and farfetched sentences shows his successful upbringing compared to Mickey who

  2. Sociology: Arranged Marriage Coursework

    More reasons for why arranged marriages may not be so popular are because, many people, especially women, feel that marriage is no longer as important. They feel this way because before, a woman needed to get married so that she can be financially stable as she would be receiving the money her husband would bring.

  1. As the nineteenth century opened, life presented few opportunities for women to experience personal ...

    Fuller herself was definitely an independent woman and her views influenced many others. Concern over the problem of education for women caused Harriet Beecher Stowe to write about this theme in her book, Oldtown Folks, written in 1869. In this story, she tells of two young men going off to

  2. Comparisions of Emma and Clueless Conventions - Social Contexts

    Sex a matter of choice - Cher and Dionne still virgins Character Representations of Males: Mr. George Knightley - has all the traits admired in a gentleman of the upper class - a superior man. Polite, courteous, sensible and cheerful Chivalric and knightly.

  1. ‘Wandering between two worlds, one dead, The other powerless to be born.’

    and the irrational, uncontrollable world of the senses will impair his inner unity and power of self direction. In this way Marguerite is less a real woman than a symbol of modern love, and indeed the difficulties inherent in any kind of true communication with other individuals 'We mortal millions live alone' (To Marguerite -Continued, line 4).

  2. Compare the lives of the two central characters in 'The Son's Veto' and 'The ...

    The 2 previously used quotes about swearing on a cross and correction of grammar shows just how dominant Randolph is in their relationship. Although he respects her by calling her "mother", she believes she doesn't deserve this role. Mr. Twycott treats Sophy with a cruel intended nature.

  1. Does Boxing have a future?

    Secondly there 'is' evidence as discussed, that boxing can cause chronic and accumulative injuries. Deaths and injuries result from unforeseen circumstances in other sports mentioned. Boxing is actively inflicting damage on an opponent. (which happens to be intentional). There is greater risk of injury in boxing than any other sport,

  2. English Coursework: Thomas Hardy's Short Stories

    He sees his mother as an embarrassment and a setback as he desperately wants to be accepted by the upper class to which his father belonged. If social class did not determine one's intrinsic worth, Randolph perhaps would not feel the need to be ashamed of his mother and he could appreciate her as a person.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work