• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is the Education Reform in Hong Kong Privileging Middle Class Origin Students?

Extracts from this document...


Is the Education Reform in Hong Kong Privileging Middle Class Origin Students? Introduction In recent years, an education reform is carried out by the Hong Kong Government in response to the economic and social structural changes in the local society under the impact of globalization. The education reform aims to promote whole-person development and self-learning by replacing the existing academic intensive curriculum with a more diversified curriculum1 together with the introduction of new modes of learning. The Hong Kong Curriculum Development Council (2000) beliefs that the new diversified curriculum and learning modes enable students to enjoy learning and attain all-round development in areas such as creativity, communication skills and the sense of commitment. (HKSAR, 2000) reference: Curriculum Reform (02): Learning to Learn (Consultation Document), 24November2000 Curriculum Development Council In spite of this belief, some people argue that the new curriculum and learning modes, which put more focus on students' experiences in extra-curricular activities, group discussion and project learning may privilege middle class over working class origin students. In this essay, I am going to first identify the middle class and working class students by defining the term "social class"; secondly, discuss the motives of the changes in education system (the education reform) under the principle of social integration in order to show the relationship between the educational changes and social classes; finally, I will analysis the new curriculum and the new learning modes by comparing the quality in education participation and education results of the two classes. ...read more.


This can be explained by the theories of cultural deprivation between the two classes. Parents from the middle class can always successfully create an atmosphere at home to arise the interest of their children in different cultural and sports activities. They provide their children with a stimulating learning environment at home and act as examples for their children. Since the new curriculum also emphasizes on self-learning which requires students to read a lot of books and seek for information by themselves out of the classroom, I am going to demonstrate an example of cultural deprivation privileging middle class students with the reading habit. Parents who read frequently provide a cultural home environment that has an affinity with and resembles the cultural school climate. The cultural connection makes for the positive impact of having parents who read, so that children who are used to having books and to reading at home are not startled by common reading practices at school. Moreover, those parents have linguistic and cognitive skills that were rewarded in school and can pass these educational skills on to their offspring. More specifically,. In addition, parents who read frequently have more cultural literacy and are probably better informed on how their children's functioning in school can be improved. ...read more.


The new teaching modes such as the group discussions and presentations introduced in the Hong Kong curriculum reform involve a lot of communication skills based on the elaborated code. Students are required to present their ideas in context independent circumstances and this language feature is only present in the elaborated code. This leads to a great disadvantage to the working class students who do not frequently expose to the elaborate language code at home. They may find difficulties in expressing their point of view and be understood by the other students or teachers. When middle class students are dominated in a classroom, the working class students may be underrepresented and will soon lose confidence in speaking or interacting with others. This seriously hinders their learning process and affects their academic achievements. Curriculum under Mechanical Solidarity has definable subjects where subjects under Organic Solidarity are topic-centred; 1 The reformed curriculum aims to provide 5 types of essential learning experiences: moral and civil education, social service, intellectual development, physical development, aesthetic development as well as wok-related experience for students who are required to gain a balance exposure in all the 5 types of experiences. (HKSAR, 2000) 2 According to Karl Marx' definition, under capitalism, the way to pursuit of profit by the owners of the industrial means of production is different from the way by the labors and these create social classes. 3 4 Classification is the degree of boundary maintenance between the subject contents. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. In what ways does education effect social changes between one generation and the next?

    Yet as women have had the same schooling process of males we are seeing women excel in schooling- yet this is not shown in the labour market. Although women are possessing skills that are desirable to future employees that are still not making top jobs- hitting the glass ceiling effects.

  2. Compare and contrast Karl Marx's and Michel Foucault's analysis of the concept power.

    Cited in Marshal,1993.P:585) There is not one person who can be identified as being in charge who can speak the 'truth'. It is the system that is in charge. In the modern age there is a belief that power comes from 'the people.

  1. The Hidden Curriculum; Hegemony and Capitalism.

    The hidden curriculum ultimately assists in the production of the technical administrative knowledge required among other things to expand markets, control production, labour and people and engage in basic and applied research needed by industry. As part of this hidden curriculum is a concept known as streaming, which is the

  2. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    cannot be achieved, or that in its achievement there may be other, undesired consequences which make our end too dangerous to pursue. We may be made to reconsider our ends, means and repercussions, so that they become a new problem for us, or we may discover new axioms which we had not previously taken into consideration).

  1. Free essay

    What were the most important influences affecting middle class housing between 1918 and 1970?

    Stylistically, 'the suburban semi-detached [...] had to express a degree of individuality without being too different from its neighbours'8 so to appeal to buyers, houses were based on 'a variety of texture based on neo-vernacular models from higher up the architectural and social scale'.9 This included half timbering, tile hanging, weather boarding, red herringbone brickwork and pebble dashed walls.

  2. would like to investigate it the achievement of middle class students obtaining their GCSE ...

    Liberal Functionalism believes that achievement is due to meritocracy, which is in turn due to hard work and ability of a child. However they also believe that in Manchester we do not have a meritocracy due to the impact of home factors, which therefore suggests that parental interest is just

  1. Homophobia: a Definition

    even in extreme cases such as convicted murderers who had confessed that their only motive had been to "beat up a queer". More often blindness to homophobia may simply be a refusal to recognize it except in blatant cases. This resistance to recognize the more common milder forms of homophobia

  2. The concept of a social class structure was identified by the famous German theorist Karl ...

    Partly-skilled occupations (hairdressers, shop assistants, cooks) V) Unskilled occupations (long term unemployment or students) Therefore, the above classifications segregate people and give them a sense of belonging within their social network; this provides a framework of class structure for them which are then evident in their attitudes and behaviour.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work