• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Outline + Discuss the View That Roles of Men and Women in the Family are Becoming More Equal

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Outline + Discuss the View That Roles of Men and Women in the Family are Becoming More Equal The aim of this essay is to attempt to come to a conclusion as to whether the gender roles within the modern-day family are equal, whether they are becoming more equal, and whether they shall ever be equal. In doing this, we shall have to study the views and opinions of many schools of thought, the results of different studies, and recognise and fully appreciate the arguments of different people and groups. The title question itself raises many debateable points, as it makes assumptions that ignore the diversity of the family. Firstly, and most obviously, the question assumes we shall only deal with heterosexually based families, not same-sex relationships. While same-sex families most definitely exist, they are a minority and do not really come into the issue of gender, therefore I shall ignore them for the course of this essay. Secondly, no two families are exactly the same. Families in different countries will no doubt have different attitudes on the subject of equality, and there will be noticeable differences across race, class and culture divisions, as well as between two different families with (superficially at least) ...read more.

Middle

are much more often 'shared' than the male-dominated ones (Checking Car Oil, Plastering) Burghes (1997) argues against Oakley's dismissal of male childcare, stating that more fathers are taking an active role in the emotional development and support of their children. Marxists argue that the traditional nuclear family was merely a way for the capitalist class to control and exploit the proletariat through ideology. Therefore, Marxist-Feminists believe in a 'patriarchal ideology', in which girls are socialised into a male-led world to accept their role as housewives, and make marriage and family their main goal. In turn, this will benefit the capitalist society by keeping the status quo, and creating a new generation of similarly socialised male workers and female housewives. Marxist-Feminists believe this patriarchy occurs at all levels of society, from making girls wear skirts to advertising dolls on television, and that to truly achieve gender equality we must dispense with socialising our children into gender roles. People often dismiss this view, claiming that gaining equality should not mean compromising identity, and many other feminists believe that retaining their femininity is as important a part of the struggle for equality as gaining equal rights. The New Right believe that the nuclear family is the ideal family structure, and that Britain went through a 'Golden Age' during the 1950s. ...read more.

Conclusion

In truth, it seems to me that the real nature of gender roles within the family is somewhere between all these points of view. I believe that as we currently stand, gender roles are equal, but not egalitarian. More males share more of the housework and childcare than ever, while more females are pursuing careers and learning what were traditionally 'male' skills (eg DIY, repair, vehicle maintenance etc). People tend to still do jobs that were traditionally considered 'right' for their sex, and there are most definitely still differences between the genders, but these boundaries are being pushed every day, and more and more families are sharing more jobs and decisions. I think we must remember that social attitudes take more time to change than social actions, and we must recognise that change is occurring. Since the 1970s, when Ann Oakley wrote her books on housework, we have seen the rise of the 'new man' and 'house-husbands'. Meanwhile, more and more women are proving Fox's and Parsons' theories of biologically determined roles to be wrong. Not all families will follow the statistics; there will always be a few male-dominated households, just as there are now 'role-reversal' families. And families will always differ slightly from each other. But within a few generations, I believe that Willmott and Young's vision of an egalitarian family will become our view of the majority of families, as we're halfway there already. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

5 star(s)

Response to the question

This question has been answered very well for a GCSE candidate. The writer evidently has a sound understanding which is obvious by the multiple references to broad sociological theory, and key sociologists in this particular field of gender roles (Oakley, ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This question has been answered very well for a GCSE candidate. The writer evidently has a sound understanding which is obvious by the multiple references to broad sociological theory, and key sociologists in this particular field of gender roles (Oakley, Parsons). The writer has clearly outlined and discussed familial roles, so the answer does not lack focus whatsoever. The essay is well structured, with a good introduction (“the aim of this essay is…”) and conclusion (“I have attempted to fully understand all these points of view, and come to a fair conclusion”), which makes it clear and easy to read.

Level of analysis

The writer explains a variety of sociological theories in detail, which shows the great extent of their knowledge. Functionalism, Marxism, Postmodernism, New Right and Marxist and liberal feminist perspectives are all well explained. The fact that they distinguish between different types of feminism is extremely impressive at GCSE level. Marxist and feminist key terms are used well in context, “proletariat” and “patriarchal ideologies”, as well as Functionalist key concepts such as the “instrumental” role and “expressive” role. This clearly shows that they have an impressive knowledge of sociology as a whole – and are able to directly relate these key sociological concepts to the question set.
The writer has made reference to cross-cultural differences, and also differences within western society itself. Although they have chosen not to expand on these ideas further – “this type of diversity would require its own set of studies and essays, and so for the sake of this essay I shall limit my studies to families from this country” - they have successfully demonstrated that they are actually aware of these contemporary issues. This shows they recognise that other societies and cultures have different norms and values to what we do in the UK. Most candidates would dismiss any ideas that they do not need to fully write about, so this candidate should be credited for their acknowledgements. To improve this cross-cultural point, however, I feel the writer could use the terms “norms and values” as this is essentially the reason why we have this idea or construction of gender roles. It would just explicitly show their overall understanding of sociology. In addition, the use of statistical evidence shows that the writer can back up the sociological points they are making more objectively.
The use of not only a bibliography, but also a webliography shows that the writer has thought very carefully about their essay, and has therefore documented where their evidence has come from for future reference (obviously in examination conditions this isn’t necessary). It shows the examiner that they have an awareness of other people’s work – they are not just copying or plagiarising. Instead they are using other people’s work, in their essay, to come to an informed conclusion. Providing these increases the professionalism of the essay.

Quality of writing

The quality of writing is of a fairly high standard. Spelling is mostly accurate, although one mistake is “debateable” as it is spelled “debatable”. The use of varied punctuation is good and also effective in demonstrating that the writer is aware of sociological key terms. This is because the essay uses quotation marks to show that a sociologist has developed a concept, for example “double shift” (Ann Oakley). The use of an asterisk in order to source the table containing gendered domestic divisions of labour is also professional and useful. But the writer does use capital letters where it isn’t necessary, “Tidying up, Cooking, Bathing children”, as it is in the middle of a sentence. Alternatively the writer also dismisses necessary capital letters on occasion – “new right” – as this is a political field of sociology, it does require them.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by cwhite 08/03/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. "Men and women have different roles to play in modern society." Discuss

    There seems to be a general reluctance for both males and females to switch places from their traditional gender roles. In my opinion, the major factor stopping this role-reversal from taking place is the fact that both sexes tend to revert to their traditional gender roles when couples have children.

  2. Should Women have equal rights to Men? Men and women should have equal ...

    They may even be more intelligent than many of the men, but their intelligence is veiled behind the curtains of sexism, so is their talent. In the World War 1 when soldiers from all around Europe had to leave their countries in order to defend their regions, it were women,

  1. Different Sociological Perspectives on Crime

    This study is influenced by a Marxist viewpoint that sees working-class youths subcultures as a response to a predetermined structural condition of class inequality. Cohen also develops on the deviance amplification theory. Cohen pointed out that the increasingly harsh distinction between Mods and Rockers came about due to the way that the media described 2 groups.

  2. Functionalism and The New Right.

    They go against traditional family values, threat to social order = challenges value consensus. > His solution = withdraw benefits - force them to take responsibility. "Starve them into Marriage" Get back to tradition, recreate value consensus. Orphanage system and adoption service set up by the state.

  1. Changing attitudes to marriage

    "Marriage today is more likely to be based on love and companionship rather than the custom and financial necessity of the past." At the same time feminists argue that women being more aware that they are exploited in the nuclear family, and their role in the house is still to

  2. Social structure today has 4 main components: status, roles, groups, and institutions. Each ...

    An example of this type of group is the family, in which people are blood related and function together in unity on a daily basis. Close friends can also be considered a part of this group, even though other people can be in it as well.

  1. In what ways does Eliza Doolittle change in Pygmalion?

    (Page 92) I think it is vital for the reader/audience to remember that Eliza and her own character and personality have achieved her transformation. Although, there is no doubt that Eliza would have remained in the gutter if Higgins had not taken her into his home and changed her speech, dressed her

  2. How the film "Outsourced" shows the effects of culture shock on an American in ...

    Todd comes from America- an individual country where people often respect to individual freedom of others and don?t have habit to ask others about family, age, or job at the first meeting. Whereas, India is a collectivist country, so they consider highly the harmony.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work