• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

This critique will examine the view that medicine is a form of social control. There are many theorists that have different opinions on this view. This critique will discuss each one and their different views.

Extracts from this document...


This critique will examine the view that medicine is a form of social control. There are many theorists that have different opinions on this view. This critique will discuss each one and their different views. We live in a society where there is a complex division of labour and where enormous varieties of specialist healing roles are recognised. We attribute to our modern healers a great deal of power, and trust that they will use it for our benefits rather than to harm us. Professional codes of ethics are promises that doctors will use their knowledge to benefit patients. The sociologist Talcott Parsons (1951) described what he considered the essential point of this contract. These rights, obligations and privileges are standards of behaviour, which Parsons felt people in American society believed desirable in the 1940s. The sociological term for such a standard of behaviour is a norm. People in modern Britain acts in a certain way that is seen as appropriate for ill people. In the 1950s, Parsons (1951) outlined the norms that govern illness behaviour and professional responses to it, in modern society. He also saw the patient - doctor relationship as a social system, governed by norms about appropriate behaviour. ...read more.


In the USA, it has been claimed that, while the role of medical power is repressive, doctors have little real autonomy. Their position as professionals has been increasingly eroded with the growth of the medical industrial complex. Health has been made into just another product for sale (McKinlay, 1984). Navarro (1979) argued that doctors act as servants of the capitalist state by ensuring that health and illness are conceptualised in individual terms. They emphasis diet, lifestyle and exercise rather than the part played by industrial process and capitalist production. They regulate sickness and contribute towards the productivity of capitalism by treating and returning workers to the workforce. Narvarro (1979) also suggested that the NHS in Britain consolidated medical power in health work, with the result that doctors as a dominant group supported a version of health care which focused on upper class and professional groups at the expense of working class health. The medical model reinforces the notion of health as a commodity and conceptualises illness as an individual responsibility. In Britain the health, work system has expanded in recent years the cost of maintaining it has risen and the numbers taking sick leave or undergoing hospital treatment have grown significantly. ...read more.


also argued that the level of patient medicine consumption and growing preoccupation with healthy lifestyles is evidence of how health is a paramount value and therefore how potentially controlling the medical profession has become. Foucault, in Madness and Civilisation (1965), also studied the way madness was socially constructed and took the notion of medicalisation even further. He showed how punishment had given way to treatment and how that implied the need for constant surveillance and monitoring. This is seen as the basis for new forms of power, which extend throughout the whole of society. He described what he called the clinical gaze as having moved beyond the hospital and the clinic into many and diverse sites such as our schools, workplaces, and homes. For Foucault (1973) the clinical gaze was a facet of a new kind of power, which relied on surveillance and inspection. In conclusion, this critique has critically examined the view that medicine is a form of social control. Discussing the views of theorists such as Talcott Parsons, Ivan Illich, Narvarro, Irving Zola and Foucault. These theorists have views about how dominating medicine can be in society, the power of the professionals and medicalisation how it refers social problems into medical problems. Throughout this critique, it has been made clear that medicine is a form of social control. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sociology essays

  1. Free essay

    Discuss the view that health inequalities can be explained by lifestyle choices made by ...

    However there have been several explanations offered firstly the genetic explanation whereby diseases such as sickle-cell anemia which are only inherited explain a few specific illnesses. The is a cultural perspective that highlights the rickets in Asian families and due to their diet lacking vitamin D but conversely the small intake of smokers amongst Asians.

  2. Gender as a form of Social Stratification.

    She argues that gender roles change from society to society and can even change within a single society over a period of time.

  1. Functionalist views on Religion.

    * Functionalists (At least Durkheim) believe that there is 'something eternal about religion', although it would become less important as society evolved. Neo Marxists While accepting many of the basic Marxists traditions, Neo Marxists have adapted and developed Marxism. One adaptation is that the superstructure can have a degree of independence from the Infrastructure.

  2. What is Social Control? Discuss the Main Agencies of Social Control in British Society ...

    Only those with low self-control commit crime. Informal Control is the next type of control a person has, or has not as I will now discuss. Informal control is when a person is subject to peer pressure. Will the person submit to this pressure or continue with the way they are.

  1. Max Weber: Basic Terms (The Fundamental Concepts of Sociology)

    It is NOT POSSIBLE to establish and to demonstrate as scientifically valid 'a principle' for practical social science from which the norms for the solution of practical problems can be unambiguously derived. While social science needs the discussion of practical problems in terms of fundamental principles, that is, the reduction

  2. This essay proposes to discuss different accounts of the welfare state by both mainstream ...

    state such as Esping-Anderson's offer us little with which to understand both the meaning and principles behind the development of policies around 'paying for care.' (1994: 63) And so the feminist contribution seeks to enlighten us on gendered matters of the welfare state, which mainstream theorists such as Esping-Anderson have not done.

  1. How and why is surveillance used in cities? To what extent is surveillance a ...

    the Manchester Arndale Centre, where there are a large number of overt security guards who are there to monitor the public. Critics of employing the private security firms for surveillance have suggested that, firstly, the companies are a public limited company, therefore, there interests lie in earning profit as opposed to the interest of the public.

  2. Sexism is a form of prejudice.

    The article from 'The Evening Mail' is called 'Healthy Drama over the kitchen sink'. It is about whether women are healthier and fitter because they do more housework, and by doing this they live longer. The people that were asked in the article seemed to disagree with what it was

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work