• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison between Trotsky's and Lenin's role in the establishment of the USSR

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

With reference to the view of at least 2 historians, compare and contrast the contributions of Lenin and Trotsky to the establishment and consolidation of a communist state in Russia between 1917 and 1924 Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov contemplated Lenin and Lev Davidovich Bronstein contemplated Leon Trotsky were two "professional" revolutionaries and the main figures of the Bolshevik revolution in 1917. While Lenin was the public face of the revolution, Trotsky was the person to set up the overthrow of the provisional government. But their role is not limited to the 1917 revolution. Both of them also contributed greatly after the successful overthrow and the problems that were to face the new government. Lenin, in his position as leader of the Communist Party introduced a couple of major policies, greatly helping the new government to stay in power. Leon Trotsky had a more executive role in the Bolshevik Party. His main role was being People's Commissar for Army and Navy Affairs. In this position he contributed greatly to the survival of the Bolshevik rule, facing the danger of civil war. In the following their roles in establishing a communist state will be compared and contrasted in three distinct time periods: The 1917 revolution and its aftermath, the Russian civil war and the post civil war period. ...read more.

Middle

Trotsky's role during the civil war was a vital contribution to the establishment of a communist state in Russia. He saved Bolshevik rule not only through setting up an enormous army to defend it but also took personally charge in critical battles, for example when Red Army units were facing advancing Czechs and Whites at Sviyazhsk. During most of the Civil War, Trotsky was travelling all through Russia, from front to front in his own train, carrying not only him but also supplies. Terry Brotherstone summarises Trotsky's importance during this period by saying:" In the subsequent two years of Civil War, Trotsky, as the strongest member of the Party leadership alongside Lenin, was placed at the head of the new Red Army then being created. He played an extremely important part in ensuring its military preparedness and, in the long run, in ensuring its victory in the war."4 D. Thatcher, however says that this should not be exaggerated. "Such praise does not, however, justify turning Trotsky into the main actor of the Civil War era. There were instances in which his forecasts were mistaken and his strategic advice misplaced. In the spring of 1919, for instance, Trotsky underestimated the threat the White forces led by Denikin posed in the south. Nor was Trotsky always the chief tactician. ...read more.

Conclusion

Hereby they took different roles though. Lenin was more of the public face of the revolution, an inspiring speaker that could fascinate the masses and a philosopher. George Vernadsky underlines this, saying that:" there can be no denial of the fact that his personality exerted tremendous influence on the course of political development in Russia".6 Trotsky's accomplishments, although he wasn't playing an as important role on the surface or in the public picture, were mutually important than Lenin's achievements. However when looking at the term communist state in the sense that originated in the West during the cold war, used to describe a form of government in which the state operates under a one-party system and declares allegiance to Marxism-Leninism or a derivative thereof, thinks look slightly different, as it was Lenin who contributed most to creating a suppressive single party system. It was Lenin, who dissolved all other parties through the use of force in the night of the 25/26 of October 1917. And it was Lenin who organised the secret police, called Cheka and invented the first concentration camps for political opponents. 1 Brotherstone, Terry. The Trotsky Reapprisal. Edinburgh University Press: 1992. Pg 42 2 Christian, David. Power Privilege. Longman: 1994. Pg 196 3 Christian, David. Power Privilege. Longman: 1994. Pg 201 4 Brotherstone, Terry. The Trotsky Reapprisal. Edinburgh University Press: 1992. Pg 43 5 Thatcher, D. Trotsky. Routledge, 2002. Pg 101 6 Vernadsky, George. Lenin: Red Dictator. Malcolm Waters Davis; Yale University Press, 1931. Pg. 312 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. Compare and contrast the contributions of Lenin and Trotsky to the establishment and consolidation ...

    Lenin soon proceeded to become the head of the Soviet Government. As always he kept dealing with social problems such as disease and starvation. This soon led to the policy of "War Communism". The concept of War Communism was established after the victory in the Civil War as an attempt

  2. Lenin's Role in Creation of USSR

    Hence for the population that wanted the war to end, the Bolsheviks became more and more attractive. But, because Lenin was exiled again, this time to Finland because he had released the April Thesis, his role in the immediate planning of the revolution and its execution was very limited.

  1. It was the weakness of the provisional government that brought about the october revolution ...

    This led to that many of the members felt that they could not make lasting decisions for Russia, as this was to be the job of democratically elected Constituent Assembly. The divisions between Liberals and Socialists in the Provisional Government often caused splits between the members, leading to a lack

  2. To what extent is it fair to say that with the impact of the ...

    22 The troops of the newly formed Cheka23 confiscated all kinds of grocery products, which led to bloody revolts and people being even more hungry.24 By 1918 the Ckeka had assassinated more than 10 000 "counterrevolutionaries".25 It also organized public hangings.26 Labour- and concentration camps were established.27 Everyone who was

  1. IB History HL, Extended Notes: Russia, the Tsars, the Provisional Govenment and the Revolution.

    Recommended strengthening of police, tighter control over universities and press and extension of Russification. Populists 1. ?To the People? and ?The People?s Will? continued revolutionary activity in the 1970s despite repression. They were a legitimate threat to the regime?s survival.

  2. Notes on the History and Development of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

    many in Israel who totally opposed handing over any of the ancient Israeli land to Palestinians. Israeli extremists became even angrier as Israel handed over some West Bank towns and villages to the Palestinian Authority in October 1995. - One such opponent was a young law student called Yigal Amin,

  1. Peron's Consolidation of Power

    disposal, newspaper size was limited to a certain number of printed pages, and distribution was hindered. At the same time, Perón and his party used the chain of newspapers they owned to disseminate propaganda in quantity. Papers such as La Razón, Critica, El Mundo, and Democracia, as well as various

  2. Why did Stalin rather than Trotsky emerge as the leader of the USSR in ...

    behind his facade of moderateness, which is why he was welcomed alongside Zinoviev and Kamenev in the Triumvirate. Stalin, even as part of the Triumvirate, was far less committed to its polices than Trotsky was to his; rather, the motivation of the Triumvirate came not from political stance by rather from their joint desire to politically isolate Trotsky.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work