• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why did the Second Spanish Republic Fail?

Extracts from this document...


History SL Assignment: Essay - Why did the Second Republic Fail? Name: Eva Teng The Second Spanish Republic was established in 1931, and it was the first attempt to establish democracy in Spain after the previous failure in the 19th century. The reason for this great failure takes its root in many different aspects of the Spanish history. But as John Gunther once said in 1937, "Left against right; poor against rich; workers against troops; ... All these confrontations played their part". This illustrates the fact that Spain was historically a very divided country, and by the 1930s many divisions existed, whether between the rich and poor or the different ethnic groups such as the Catalans and the Basques. It is obvious that the Republic entered at a very difficult time, and thus it is probably unfair to call it a complete failure since it did attempt to establish some reforms. But altogether it was these divisions, combined with the Second Republic's extreme policies and inappropriate approach to situations, that led to this government's inevitable downfall. Despite the Republic's eventual failure, it did achieve some successes. First of all it extended and improved the Labour Arbitration Scheme, which increased wages for the underpaid labourers. The extent of its success can be seen by the fact that its membership tripled between 1931~33. It also set out to tackle its military aim of reforming he army to improve its efficiency; this was done by asking 50% of the officers to retire. ...read more.


This extract suggests that the poorly-implemented agrarian reform only served to angry all kinds of farmers - small to large-sized. This also illustrates how the Republic managed to anger most classes in Spain. The military reform was also a failure; although in theory it would make the army more efficient, in practice this did not happen. Moreover the Second Republic gave the retired officers full-pay, so by the end it had little money left for social reforms. This was detrimental to the Republic because its primary goal was social reform: it was voted in by the peasants because it promised the latter (a majority of the population) reforms that would bring more equality between the labourers and the landowners. But without the money to carry out its promises, the Republic lost yet more support, this time from the working class. Another reason for the downfall of the Left Republic (1031~33) was its extreme anticlerical measures. Spain had a very religious population, and by establishing the extreme measures against the Church, the government lost support from a quarter of the Spanish people already. However Azana firmly believed that by separating Church from the government and education he could ameliorate Spain's backwardness, and thus he continued. All these failures were accompanied by further fiascoes under the Right Republic of 1933~36. The Right Republic was voted in precisely because of the Left's previous failures. ...read more.


This gave Mola and the military the perfect excuse to initiate their plan, and eventually the three years of war that followed confirmed the Second Republic's failure. The many mistakes that the Republic had played the role in polarizing Spain. There were numerous mistakes - whether it be the Asturia's uprising (the government's oppressive methods) or the Agrarian Reform Law; by the 1930s all these tension caused by the government had built up, and once the murder in 193 was done, everything escalated. The Second Republic failed largely because it approached many of Spain's problems with impractical solutions. Had it taken more care to displease only one section of the population instead of the whole (it is almost impossible to please all classes because of the angering factions in Spain), it may have been able to maintain its support and avoid failure. However one must not forget that the Second Republic was established under a difficult time; by the 1930s the working class's resentment towards the wealthy had already been built up (especially after the Economic Depression). Spain's conflicting history had already been built up by that time too - for example Catalan's demand for autonomy. The Second Republic did try its best at times in measures such as the labour arbitration scheme and the Catalan Statute. To say that it completely failed is probably unjust, given the conditions and some of its successes at the time. But the built-up of strain and pressure played the main part in covering up the Republic's accomplishments and made its failure inevitable. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. the causes and consequences of the spanish civil war

    Of course this is not in any way a solution or a way out of the mess. If anything, the uprising and its results further divided the government and the people of Spain. Those who supported the Right, which were mainly Army officers, believed that this was the dismemberment of Spain.

  2. Weimar Republic

    in several measures against new cultural forms * Wilhelm Frick became the first Nazi in a state government in 1930 and he ordered modern art removed from museums and restricted jazz performances. * In film, the early expressionism changed in favour of a greater stress on social reality.

  1. Prohibition: an inevitable failure?

    the supporters of the League to push for an amendment [Eighteenth Amendment]... it banned the manufacture, sale, and transportation of intoxicating liquors". Source B - Consequences of Prohibition. Source B states that Prohibition had a noble intention, yet caused prodigous amounts of crime.

  2. Waimar Republic - The first years of rule

    The DNVP was the largest extreme right party and enjoyed 15.1 percent of the votes in the 1920 elections. Cositst of landowners and indsutariles, but also a big number of the middle class. (page 43). Conclusion: How did Weimar deal with the opposition?

  1. Extended Essay - "to what extent was Yellow journalism to blame for instigating the ...

    From this, the research question - To what extent was 'Yellow Journalism' responsible for instigating the Spanish-American War of 1898? , therefore arises. In order to answer this question, the investigation will look at the different causes that sparked the Spanish-American war and analyze their nature to see which cause

  2. Analyse the causes of the Spanish Civil War

    The name is also associated to Stalin because his party was called in the same way. This could mean that this party might have followed Caballero?s suggestions or to show Spain what their mentality was. Azana came back to power, he was liberal and wanted to restore the modern policies and release political prisoners, this angered the right.

  1. Why did Tsarism fail to survive the first world war

    With a firm belief that his power to rule was granted by divine right, the Tsar assumed that the Russian people were devoted to him with unquestioning loyalty, though he was greatly wrong. This ironclad belief rendered the Tsar unwilling to allow the progressive reforms that might have alleviated the suffering of the Russian people.

  2. Causes of the Spanish Civil War

    Spain, as a largely agrarian economy was rife with endemic poverty hindering growth and industrialization. The socio-economic divide between the rich and the poor continued to expand and the poor?s hunger for land continued. Abysmal working conditions, led to the increase of trade unionism as a means to bring about change.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work