• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The clash of conflict between societal morality and individual ethics in A Dolls House and Antigone.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The clash of conflict between societal morality and individual ethics in A Doll's House and Antigone Should one be guided by the man-made laws or the individual laws? This quandary is one of the main aspects of many literary works. In Antigone, written by Jean Anouilh and A Doll House, written by Henrik Ibsen this dilemma is addressed. Should Antigone and Nora follow the rules made by society or should they follow their own edicts? Both the plays have highlighted the conflict between societal morality and individual ethics. The presence of this conflict in one's mind not only shapes the character in both the plays but also the paths that the character chooses by the end of the plays. Therefore by analyzing the presences of the conflict between societal morality and individual ethics, one can gain the insight of what the writer is trying to convey to the audience. This paper will compare the conflict arising between societal morals and individual ethics in both the plays. In Antigone, the female protagonist Antigone believes that individual laws hold a high reverence than the societal laws. ...read more.

Middle

And the laws that do not obey to this are "very bad laws."15 Moreover, during the completion of the play, Nora's ideas of Individual ethics emphasized the most. Nora decides to "leave"16 Torvald because she believes that the "most sacred duties"17 are "duties to her."18 She believes that "first and foremost she is a human being"19 than "a wife and mother."20 And the fact that towards the end she chooses her own rights and forbids the societal law shows that she strongly believes that individual ethics hold a high reverence in Nora's life. On the contrary, Creon in Antigone and Torvald in A Doll House are guided by societal laws. Creon is the male protagonist in Antigone; he is guided by the societal laws as he is the King of Thebes. Creon believes that civil law is above all law. Creon imposed an edict that Polynices should not be given a proper burial because he is considered as a traitor of Thebes. Creon felt that if a person acted against the state he or she loses the right to live. This clearly shows that Creon does not believe in individual ethics. ...read more.

Conclusion

1 Antigone, Antigone. Pg-18 2 Antigone, Antigone. Pg-41 3 Ismene, Antigone. Pg-19 4 Ismene, Antigone. Pg-19 5 Ismene, Antigone. Pg-19 6 Antigone, Antigone. Pg-19 7 Antigone, Antigone. Pg-21 8 Antigone, Antigone. Pg-21 9 A Doll House. Pg-143 10 Act 3, Nora to Torval. A Doll House. Pg-201 11 Act 1, Rank said to Nora. A Doll House. Pg-159 12 Act 1, Stage Narration. A Doll House. Pg-160 13 Act 1, Nora said to Krogstad. A Doll House. Pg-166-167 14 Act 1, Krogstand to Nora. A Doll House. Pg- 166 15 Act 1, Nora to Krogstad. A Doll House. Pg-166 16 Act 3, Nora to Torvald. A Doll House. Pg-202 17 Act 3, Torval to Nora. A Doll House. Pg-203 18 Act 3, Nora to Torvald. A Doll House. Pg-203 19 Act 3,Nora to Torval. A Doll House. Pg-203 20 Act 3,Nora to Torval. A Doll House. Pg-203 21 Creon said to Antigone. Antigone. Pg-61 22 Creon said to Gaurds. Antigone. Pg-60 23 Creon said to Chorus. Antigone. Pg-60 24 Creon said to Haemon. Antigone. Pg-61 25 Act 1, Helmer said to Nora. A Doll house. Pg- 174 26 Act 3, Helmer said to Nora. A Doll House. Pg-198 27 28 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. Money and Happiness:Neither in de Maupassants The Necklace, nor in Ibsens A Dolls House, ...

    the words of Dostoevsky himself as quoted by Joseph Frank in his introduction to A Bantam Classic edition of the novel, "the insoluble problems confront the murderer, unsuspected and unexpected feelings torment his heart" (ix). Brought to the brink of insanity and unable to leave with the crime, Raskolnikov confesses

  2. What is the role and function of the Messenger in Antigone and Medea?

    the pupils of her eyes were twisted out of sight...eating her clear flesh"7 further enriching the striking detail. His diction, particularly at this point in his narrative, illustrates the artistic excellence of Euripides. In Antigone, her attitude towards her father's sin was metaphorically lamented as 'married with death'8 and Creon's

  1. An Examination of the diametric display of pride in Sophocless Antigone

    She, with her own dear brother lying in his blood- she couldn't bear to leave him dead, unburied, food for the wild dogs or wheeling vultures. Death? She deserves a glowing crown of gold!" (Sophocles 777-82) Creon refuses to hear and acknowledge Haimon's plea because it does not fit what he believes to be the truth.

  2. Victims of Circumstances? Antigone , in the play Antigone by Sophocles and Nora ...

    Creon was crueler as he failed to influence Antigone. Also Haemon unsuccessfully endeavored to influence Creon's decision. He supported the decision which was made by Antigone. In the end with the arrival of Teiresias, described as the Old Theban, the atmosphere changed with unusual events taking place.

  1. A comparison of two female heroes: Nora in Ibsens A Dolls House and Antigone ...

    For example, when Torvald and Nora are discussing Nora's spendings, Torvald says, "My little song-bird must never do that again. A song-bird must have a clean beak to chirp with - no false notes."(Ibsen, 26) Torvald's view of Nora is like a doll, except one that also cleans the house and takes care of his kids.

  2. Setting in A Dolls house and Antigone

    The time at which the play is introduced is also mentionable as an axis of the play could be the season, or the unsettling situations which envelope the period portrayed. "A porter who is carrying a Christmas tree" is one of the initial actions of the play, the Christmas tree,

  1. Alienation in The Metamorphosis and A Doll's House

    why but although he played the role of a good son, obeying his father?s wishes in order to take care of the family. His family chooses to block him out of their lives (possibly also another effect of society and it?s oppression towards ?misfits?)

  2. Watership Down. In the novel Watership Down by Richard Adams, the protagonist character ...

    Hazel cannot grasp Blackberry's idea and says, "here, wait a moment, we're just simple rabbits, Bigwig and I. Do you mind explaining" (308). This situation is reminiscent of the rabbits experience in Chapter Eight where Hazel finds himself stupified after Blackberry describes the plan to float Pipkin and Fiver acoss the river on the wood.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work