Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7

Why the strategy in Kosovo was ineffective.

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Thousands of people continue to be senselessly murdered in our world. Violence is a prevailing theme in the news headlines today and is a continuing way of life for many countries. Good examples of such violence include the Balkan countries along the Adriatic Sea. In the past twenty years, countries such as Bosnia, Serbia, Albania and Kosovo have consistently been places for brutal ethnic killings. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) has attempted to diminish violence in recent years with limited success. One NATO effort to end ethnic driven violence was in Kosovo during Operation Allied Force in 1999. Although the campaign in Kosovo was an overall success, the problem with Operation Allied Force was NATO's strategy. NATO's strategy for Kosovo was not effective for three main reasons: first, there was a failure to leverage more decisive diplomatic efforts to restore peace; second, there were unclear political objectives and unspecific plans to attain them; third and finally, was the decision to not use ground forces. Let's take a closer look at each of these points and the supporting evidence. The first reason the strategy in Kosovo was ineffective was due to indecisive diplomatic and military decisions and resulting actions. Kosovo was the result of policy makers in Washington and elsewhere who proved unwilling or unable to set political objectives and to consider how far they were prepared to go to achieve them militarily (Ugly, p.17).

Middle

The first such evidence occurred early in the campaign when Richard Holbrooke, the Clinton Administration's Balkans envoy, traveled to Belgrade in October 1998 to persuade Milosevic to end his attacks on the Kosovar population. Although an agreement was made between Holbrook and Milosevic, key details for that agreement were poorly defined (Ugly p.23). One key detail, was how to punish Serb non-compliance. Milosevic's violent reputation was well documented and NATO could reasonably assume he would not "make good" on any future agreements or at least sustained compliance. A clear and credible message for a man like Milosevic was essential due to his recently proven violent actions in Bosnia and Kosovo. He disregarded peace agreements on several occasions. Here was a man who was responsible for a decade of violence in Croatia and Bosnia by killing over 100,000 people, and he is at it again in Kosovo. NATO needed to get this man to sign his name agreeing to very specific details of a plan to end his violence and more importantly, have an assured method for dealing with a good chance of noncompliance. Additionally, how and when Milosevic would finally end violent retaliation against the Albanian civilian population and reach an agreement with the KLA were not clearly specified in the Holbrook-Milosevic agreement. Another specific political objective left unanswered concerned the withdrawl of Serb Forces from Kosovo.

Conclusion

Unarmed monitors would therefore be an unwise choice to send into a violent situation with the armed opposition having a distinct advantage. Additionally, there was ambiguity about what the monitors of the agreement were supposed to monitor on the ground and in the air to maintain peace (Ugly, p.50). Secretary of State Albright explained, "I didn't want to see something that was like the UN forces in Bosnia, who didn't have any real authority." While monitors were part of the agreement, their role was never specific and they did not have any real authority in the eyes of the Serbs. While Operation Allied Force was an overall success by restoring Kosovo, the reasons and supporting evidence stated in this document clearly show how NATO's strategy in Kosovo was ineffective for several reasons. Indecisive diplomatic efforts and military action was at the heart of the ineffective strategy in Kosovo since clear political objectives were never really agreed on. This indecisive diplomatic decision making led to indecisive military action. Additionally, the US and NATO showed no decisive strategy throughout the Kosovo campaign. There were only small steps taken with an air campaign and no follow on second, third and fourth order plans. The decision not to use ground forces was especially unwise; many Albanians were killed as a result of it. Hopefully in the future, the US and NATO will apply the lessons learned in Kosovo to save lives during campaigns to achieve lasting peace. WINNING UGLY ESSAY (C200 Studies) Prepared by: LCDR Todd Chipman 21 September, 2004

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related University Degree Engineering

  1. British air power during the First World War

    The emphasis of aerial reconnaissance shifted from discovering the general positions of entire armies to more local intelligence needed at corps level. Squadrons were attached to individual corps so that information which was needed about trench positions, strong points, gun emplacements and build-ups of enemy supplies could be more quickly

  2. Low-cost Information Technology in Developing Countries: Current Opportunities and Emerging Possibilities.

    This challenge is intensified by stricter accounting and corporate governance requirements that are placing increasing pressure on businesses of all sizes for greater transparency, timeliness and accuracy in reporting and managerial control. Small and midsize enterprises are recognizing integrated ERP solutions as essential to keeping up with business counterparts and

  1. Sustainability in Action

    An example of "collaborative efforts" done together with stakeholders, the Coca-Cola system in Japan joined with Lawson, Inc. in 2008 in launching carbon offset products, which come with CO2 emissions credits. This action allowing consumers to contribute to global warming prevention activities just by purchasing the products during routine shopping

  2. Jigsaw redesign. We were assigned the task of evaluating and redesigning a given DIY ...

    Ideally a decent long life high power battery with a high charge cycle time. The cordless option would naturally make the jigsaw easier to store, which is ideal in a domestic home where it may not be frequently used. New lithium Ion Batteries used in the in similar can deliver high power for extended time periods.

  1. NATO's strategy in Kosovo, ineffective?

    While economic sanctions to prevent a war were in place, they did not prevent attacks on the Albanian population in Kosovo because they were untimely and simply not strong enough. Effective economic sanctions would have required earlier intervention. In early 1998 when the violence started, NATO and especially the Clinton

  2. This document explains the significant activities and experiences gained within 32 weeks (8 months) ...

    and my lecturer, Dr. Fawnizu Azmadi Hussin who had put much effort for both industrial visits and given me supportive advice to achieve the internship objectives. TABLE OF CONTENTS INDUSTRIAL INTERNSHIP FINAL REPORT 1 DECLARATION 2 VERIFICATION STATEMENT 3 DEDICATION 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 6 LIST OF FIGURES 9 LIST OF TABLES 9

  1. The Impact of the Strategic Defence Review.

    Has it enhanced the forces ability to perform or has it hampered its might? Can we prepare ourselves for battle more effectively or has the SDR blunted the forces' logistics edge? This is what the author will attempt to answer in the following text, but before continuing it is worthwhile

  2. Prioritization of action to be taken after Sichuan earthquake

    China will also send 20 military planes to transport armed forces and armed police to the quake-hit areas, according to the military emergency response office on 13 May. The soldiers reached Yingxiu Town of Wenchuan on foot on 13 May afternoon because the town was not accessible by vehicles.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.