• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Rene Descartes' Mind and Body.

Extracts from this document...


Philosophy 1 Jeongmin Kim Rene Descartes' Mind and Body As I live my life, I ask a question about the Mind and Body distinction. Even at this moment while typing an essay paper, I am thinking of Descartes' assertion, I think, therefore, I exist, but does this tell me of the distinction between the body and mind? According to Descartes, I can conceive of myself as existing without the body, but not without the mind, therefore mind and body are distinct. So my writing self is the mind that directs the ambiguous or deceived physical body that types this essay. But the body also can affect the mind, e.g. if one was a mindless figure, he would act totally like an animal. He wouldn't act out of rationality but rather out of instinct. Instinct can mean two things: a repeated action or a mindless reaction to an event. A mindless being doesn't have "conscience", "convictions", or "faith". Throughout this essay, I will support the Cartesian view that the mind and the body are distinct and interact with each other. In Descartes' essay, Mind as Distinct from Body, he argues that the body is always divisible whereas the mind is entirely indivisible. Let us assume that someone saws your leg off, in consequence, you know that a part of your body is being taken away by some force. ...read more.


And interact? Everything is composed of matter and energy and can be explained by physical laws. All human activity can be understood as the natural behavior of matter according to mechanical laws and therefore thinking is merely a complex form of behaving. It looks more logical to see that thalamus in this part of the brain recognizes different colors and report the result of optical transmissions to the headquarters, and consequently, other parts of body move or react according to the headquarters' command. Therefore, the above example of a neurosurgeon cannot be explained by the mind and body distinction but can be clearly explained by the physical laws. Here I would like to analyze the mind and body distinction with a different approach. Mathematicians say that a line exists in the first dimension, a plane in the second dimension, and a three dimensional objects in the third dimension. For example, a movie screen we see at a theater is in the second dimension because it is just a plane, but things that are coming out of the movie screen like a 3-D movie is said to be in the third dimension. Mathematically, bodies reside in the third dimension where objects are seen in every possible angle but constrained to time, whereas minds are in the fourth dimension where objects can be seen in all angles and can freely travel through the time dimension (past, present, and future), but because of time variable is in the fourth dimension, three dimensional observers can't see objects in the fourth dimension. ...read more.


Because of the fact that the machines only function according to the calculated optimum result of the various information that they have received from outside world, machines don't understand the meaning of having a true heart, generous heart, or anything. I had described that the mind and body are totally distinct. I added more explanations to the Descartes' argument: minds are totally distinct from bodies. I used mathematical methods to compare minds and bodies that minds are dimensionally different from bodies. I argued that minds exist in human beings. I showed that humans have minds whereas highly sophisticated computers can imitate human actions and thinking process but don't have conscience. In modern days, people tend to look more for physical explanations rather than mental or spiritual explanations. It is, in my opinion, quite absurd to conclude that everything in this world involves only physical substances because the fact that human beings are simply too complicated to say that we are only physical beings. There is something called "Conscience" besides knowledge in our brain. This conscience pushes us to do the right thing when, in fact, it may not be the wise thing to do in certain situations. This is nothing like any information that is kept in our brain. This is something besides our physical stuff but rather mental or spiritual stuff that employs itself in our decision to act. Therefore, we should believe that the mind and the body exist and are totally distinct but interact with each other instead of believing that everything is physical. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Philosophy and Theology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Philosophy and Theology essays

  1. What is the relationship between mind and body?

    or two parts of people - however, once working these two parts of the brain would create a different person, with their own essence. It is this argument, therefore, which gives weight to the idea that the brain is simply an organ in which the soul functions, but it is not the totality of the soul.

  2. Does the Computational Model of Mind stand up to Scrutiny?

    Another point is how a completely causal process can be called a reasoning process as calling it reasoning implies a series of norms not causes. Fodor claimed that the computational model of mind was really "the only game in town".

  1. Discuss the presentation of the spiritual in Tim Wintons novel Cloudstreet.

    from the house at Cloud Street. His ability to recognize the spiritual discourse associated with the house valorizes his position as a spiritual being. The Blackfella again appears as a hitchhiker who is picked up by Quick during his period of separation from his family at Cloudstreet (208).

  2. The 17th Century Rationalists and how their influence can be seen today This essay ...

    For example a stick looks bent when partly submerged in water when in fact it remains the same. The size of the sun and the moon can be perceived to be much smaller than they are in actual fact. We can also hallucinate and believe that something exists when in fact it doesn't.

  1. How does the sociology of the body overcome the mind/ body dualism?

    They body and minds interact with one another. One cannot exist without the other, hence the two are connected through some system designed to do this. Descartes himself considered that the two entities were connected through the pineal gland, which sent and received messages to and from the body.

  2. The human mind.

    Some libertarians like Kane tried to link the macroscopic psychological descriptions with the microscopic neurobiological explanations.7 Of course whether his view is true is a matter of empirical science. It would be suggested with no present evidence of how quantum uncertainty can transfer to the macroscopic mechanics, his explanation is doubtful.

  1. Consciousness explained?

    This report will reveal that you are access conscious to the processes you are using to solve the puzzle. The second kind of consciousness we will look at is Monitoring Consciousness. This involves being in a conscious state, which is accompanied by a thought to the effect that you are in that state.

  2. What is the mind body problem? Provide details of some responses to it from ...

    However, mental states arise from the activity of the brain (from the material world). The complexities of this stand point are being explained further and further as brain-imaging develops understanding of which particular mental states and cognitive processes (such as memory and emotion)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work