• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Describe the ways in which judges are selected, appointed and trained.

Extracts from this document...


Describe the ways in which judges are selected, appointed and trained. The ways in which judges are selected and appointed are important and they vary as there are different types of judges with different abilities. The Lord Chancellor is particularly influential in this respect as he has the task of nominating and appointing all the lower ranks of the judiciary. The higher ranks are appointed by the Queen on the advice of the Prime Minister, but the Lord Chancellor still has some influence over these appointments. The Lord Chancellor is, in effect, the selector of the judges, though facilitated by the advice of the judiciary and the wider legal profession. Superior judges The appointment of judges to the House of Lords and Court of Appeal is by way of invitation. Here a candidate may be approached by the Lord Chancellor without having applied. In 1986 Lord Chancellor, Lord Hailsham published a document called 'Judicial Appointments' which gave some explanation of the selection process. It involves the Lord Chancellor's Department keeping files on all possible candidates and collecting confidential information and opinions about those candidates from judges. These files are secret so that the subjects do not know what is in them. The dominance of judges' positions relies mainly on word of mouth and the confidential opinion of existing judges. ...read more.


However, judges can be members of the House of Lords in its legislative function - law lords are life peers and can take part in debates on new laws. There is a convention that the Law Lords will not take part in overtly political debate, but over recent years there have been instances where they have entered into controversial areas of law making. An example of this would be where the Governments policies on sentencing caused Lord Taylor to be highly critical of the 1996 White Paper proposals to bring in minimum sentences. Further, the government cannot dismiss superior judges and in this way they can be said to be independent of the government. They can make decisions which may displease the government without the threat of dismissal. This allows the judges to make decisions for themselves and not be pressurised by anyone else to make a decision which would suit them. However, the appointment of judges is not independent from the executive as the Lord Chancellor, who is a member of the government, is involved in the appointment of judges and the Prime Minister is responsible for the nomination of most senior judges. Thus there is a clear utility in our judges being largely independent of the legislative and executive branches. Other reasons for why independence is important include the fact that any cases involving governmental power should be free of government influence so no bias or wrong-doing can occur. ...read more.


Judges are still predominantly old, white, conservative males drawn from the privileged class and these characteristics can colour their decision-making faculties. With regards to the independence of judges in relation to the other instruments of state, there is a principle of separation of powers which to a large extent is adhered to and preserves the independence of the judiciary. The role of the legislature, Parliament, is to create the laws, the executive puts forward most bills to Parliament and implements the law and the role of the judiciary is to interpret and enforce the law. If one was to see the branches of government this way then there is a separation of powers and the judiciary in effect independent from the government. However, the judiciary has another power that blurs the separation of powers slightly and might undermine their complete independence. As well as possessing the ability to interpret and enforce the laws of the land, judges are in control of the 'common law' which takes them into the law making territory of the legislature. Common law is judge made law that arises out of custom; a decision made by one court of law must be followed by others facing similar situations. Therefore, the question whether judges are truly independent is intrinsically linked to whether there is a strict separation of powers. In conclusion it can be said that for the most part the judiciary can be said to occupy an independent role but there is no strict separation of powers guaranteeing complete independence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree English Legal System section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree English Legal System essays

  1. Produce a report that looks at the functions of each court, with emphasis on ...

    claim transferred to be heard in a County Court which is local to where he lives or works. The concept behind this idea is not to inconvenience the defendant, as it is the claimant bringing the action. The County Courts hears most civil cases on a wide range of disputes,

  2. What role do judges play in the modern United Kingdomconstitution? To what extent will ...

    However the powers of the commission will also disappoint many. It will be a recommending commission, not an appointing commission, at the higher levels. It is hoped that an independent Commission for appointments will increase the legitimacy of judicial power by making selection and appointment procedures fair, equitable and transparent

  1. Do Judges Make New Law in Hard Cases?

    to anticipate all eventualities which of course they can't, the rules of law could be mechanically applied in all cases. Hart calls this 'mechanical jurisprudence'.8 F. Indeterminacy of Aim - The Electric Car. Hart uses his 'banning vehicles in the park' example to illustrate 'relative indeterminacy of aim'.

  2. The government is proposing to create a supreme court and to reform the judicial ...

    Past and Present Status of the House of Lords: The Appellate Jurisdiction Act 1876 confirmed the power, by which the peers should be appointed. At present there exist 2 bodies within the House of Lords, the first of which to mention is the Appellate Committee, known as the "ultimate legal guardian of the constitution"3.

  1. The judicial process: should judges ever make the law?

    Most policies are a mixture of facts and value judgements, if the decision is mainly based on facts, it should be possible to establish the rationality of the policy. But, if the facts are of minor importance when weighed against the element of value judgement in the policy, it would

  2. Describe the ways in which judges are selected, appointed and trained. Explain and comment ...

    The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) sits in London at the Royal Courts of Justice. It deals with appeals from the Crown Court and is presided over by the Lord Chief Justice who is the most senior judge in England and Wales.

  1. Dispute Solving - Solicitors, Barristers, and Legal executives

    Ethnic minorities are over represented by comparison magistrates are much older and from higher social classes. Middle Class Statistics from each bench vary but generally working class magistrates are a small percentage of the total. Employees are required by law to give magistrates time off for their duties, but they are not required to pay the magistrates.

  2. The Judiciary has been described as "overwhelmingly white, male, and from a narrow social ...

    Under the traditional system the Lord Chancellor would advise the Prime Minister, from the information he has collected using the secret collection of information on each possible candidate, the Prime Minister would then advise the Queen. The new system of appointment was introduces under the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, this

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work