• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

International Conflict Analysis

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Teong Yi Heong (Jet) U021202J International Conflict Analysis 5. Timing is very important for mediation to succeed. When should mediation be attempted? At the beginning or at the middle point? Answer with reference to a conflict/conflicts of your choice. The prevalence of conflict at any level of society, be it among individuals, organizations, states et cetera, is unavoidable. As a premise to his argument for the Leviathan, Thomas Hobbes posits that the natural condition of man is "a condition of war of everyone against everyone"1. Extrapolating from his premise, it is arguable that conflict is inherent to man's nature. Given that conflict is inevitable, it is then necessary to manage conflict to ensure survival. According to Jacob Bercowitch et al, conflict can be managed by any of these means: the use of either physical or psychological force; through negotiations; or, the involvement of parties external to the conflict either in the utilization of legal norms or in a non binding manner2. Mediation as a conflict management technique falls in the last category. William Zartman and Saadia Touval suggest the definition of mediation to be "a mode of negotiation in which a third party helps the parties find a solution which they cannot find by themselves."3 The definition is broad and encompasses a wide range of third party involvement. Jacob Bercovitch distinguishes mediation from other forms of third party involvement as follows: 1) Mediation must be invited by the parties in conflict; that is, the parties are not forced to accept mediation 2) Mediation aims to "change, affect or influence their [disputants'] perceptions or behaviour"; that is, mediation do not attempt to enforce a settlement 3) ...read more.

Middle

Conflict fatigue is itself not sufficient condition for "ripeness": a party may persist in conflict despite huge losses so long as the opponent is losing more. Thus, Zartman argues that conditions are ripe for mediation when both parties face a "hurting stalemate" 15, that is, a situation where neither side could meet their aims unilaterally and both were incurring costs without a chance of gain. In this consideration then, mediation is more likely to be successful if it is adopted as a policy of last resort by the disputants, and the mediated outcome is deemed to be more favourable than the continuation of conflict. It is also pertinent to consider the mediator's role. Mediators tend to take interest in a conflict only towards the middle of the conflict, because the implications and repercussions will only be clearer in the later developments. A mediator may become interested only when the conflict threatens regional stability, its own strategic and economic interests, or when the conflict offers a means by which its influence can be extended16. The case of Sudan is interesting in this regard: atrocities within the state have been ongoing for a fairly long period of time, but it has only just captured the interest of the international community particular the hegemonic United States. The high human costs were precisely what necessitated intervention and mediation. In addition, Pricen also argues that the control that a mediator can exercise over the mediator process and on disputants increase as the conflict wears on. He states that With respect to the intermediary-disputant relationship then, the later the intermediary enters, the greater the intermediary's bargaining power, and hence, the greater its procedural power over the disputant. ...read more.

Conclusion

p. 171 6 Marieke Kleiboer, The Multiple Realities of International Mediation. London: Lynne Rienner Publishers: 1998. p. 12 7 Ibid. p. 13 8 Ibid, pp. 19-22. Kleiboer raises four sets of variables: Variables concerning the conflict (conflict ripeness, the level of intensity, the nature of issues), variables concerning the mediator (impartiality, leverage, status) variables concerning the parties and their relationships (cohesiveness, balance of power, relationships between parties, identification of parties, type of regime) and process variables (mediator behaviour.) 9 Chester A. Crocker et al Herding Cats: Multiparty Mediation in a Complex World. Washington D.C.: United States Institute of Peace Press. 1999. p. 21 10 Michael Grieg, "Moments of opportunity. Recognising conditions of ripeness for international mediation between enduring rivals" Journal of Conflict Resolution.Vol 45. No. 6, December 2001. pp. 691-692. 11 Inis L. Claude, Jnr Swords into Plowshares: The Problems and Progress of International Organisation. New York:Random House: 1971. p. 238. Due to source constraints, Frank Edmead's view is reflected in Marieke Kleiboer, The Multiple Realities of International Mediation p19. 12 Ibid. p. 239 13 Thomas Pricen, Intermediaries in International Conflict. New Jersey: Princeton University Press: 1992. pp. 53-54. 14 Ibid; Crocker, Herding Cats. pp. 21-22; 15 Zartman and Touval "Mediation: The role of third-party diplomacy and informal peacemaking" p. 251 16 Ibid. pp. 242-247 17 Pricen, Intermediaries in International Conflict. p. 54 18 Tail Levy. "The 1991 Cambodia settlement agreements" Melanie C. Greenberg et al. Words Over War: Mediation and Arbitration to Prevent Deadly Conflict Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield: 2000. p. 144 19 Richard. H. Solomon, "Bring peace to Cambodia". Chester A Crocket et al. Herding Cats. p. 280 20 Levy. "The 1991 Cambodia settlement agreements" p. 146 21 Ibid. p. 156 ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Family Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Family Law essays

  1. Domestic violence

    22 The failure to respond increases the victim's frustration of having to survive on their own.23 Also, lawyers should learn to avoid using languages that implicitly blame victims for the effects of family violence on their social and psychological functioning, and should instead strive to normalize the emotions and behaviors

  2. Child law

    A child can apply for a s.8 order, under the Children Act, provided the court has granted leave to the child, and that they have sufficient understanding to make the application. Although the test of sufficient understanding is that of the Gillick Competence, only older teenagers are likely to be

  1. Shared parenting after relationship breakdown is not in the best interests of children Discuss. ...

    26, in the child's best interest.27 In Pagden v Pagden 28 Rowland J refused to make orders for shared custody stating that "there remains the deficit in mutual trust, cooperation and good communications which appear to be desirable elements in a shared custody scheme.", with Turkat 29 noting that many

  2. Discuss, with reference to statutory provision and relevant case law, the extent to which, ...

    courts are willing to grant supervised contact unless it not in the child's best interests, similarly the courts are prepared to allow the child indirect contact by phone, email and letters. This is an effective way for the court to grant contact where face to face contact is not appropriate

  1. Family law.

    should be included in a definition of family - thus including a large section of society in any universal conclusion of what a family is. The law itself provides very little statutory guidance on what a family is and up until the House of Lords ruling in Fitzpatrick v Sterling27

  2. What lessons can be learnt from the existing law of divorce which may be ...

    Mutually bad spouses (i.e. spouses who are equally bad in similar respects) can reasonably be expected to live with each other23 An analysis of petitions showed many are inclined to make it look as bad possible, lest the court be tempted to probe more deeply or as little as they

  1. Cohabitation - the need for legal reform

    some of the issues raised on cohabitation cannot be avoided or ignored especially due to the increasing number of cohabiting couples and the breakdowns of them. Therefore, it is necessary for government to look into some of the more pressing issues on cohabitation in order for it to be dealt with accordingly.

  2. Problem Question, Divorce& FInancial Provision

    Currently Sakina suffers nervous breakdown and unable to work, hence her earning capacity is greatly reduced or nil, it means that she needs more financial support in order to continue her life.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work