• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Technological Determinism.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Coms 101 Short Assignment Topic A: Technological Determinism Name: Tom Langford ID Number: 5805479 Tutorial Time: Monday 12:00 - 12:50 Due Date: 14/5/04 Word Count: 1223 Technology is profoundly human, it is what separates us from our biological fore bearers. As a whole, human society has developed technology and to an extent controlled it. However one question you may ask yourself is do you as an individual control the technology around you or does that technology control you. This idea inspired the concept of technological determinism - the belief that technology acts as an independent force in our lives. Two more concepts that are very much related to this idea are the cultural lag concept and the convergence theory. Rudi Volti, an American sociologist is a scholar of these theories and his written the book Society and Technological Change. This book serves as a critical analysis of these theories. Technological determinism is the idea that technology is an autonomous force within our lives. If this concept is accurate then we are presented with the somewhat matrix-like proposition of humans being the servants technology rather technology serving us. This is not necessarily designed to be taken literally; it is not implying that we will all soon be at the mercy of some robotic task master. ...read more.

Middle

Closely linked to technological determinism is the theory of cultural lag. In layman's terms cultural lag is the concept that changes in society lag behind changes in technology. For example Volti gives us the example of medical technology decreasing the rate of infant mortality3. Prior to this, families were forced to have a large number of children to ensure they would have some surviving offspring. However after technology drastically improved an infant's chance of survival, it still took several generations before society adjusted and birth rates dropped. As a result there was a major population explosion. Cultural lag is closely related to technological determinism, cultural lag requires technology to be seen as independent. Therefore cultural lag is totally reliant on the concept of determinism. Volti states that this concept has three major flaws. He states that the theory does not take into account the fact that technology is also influenced by social change and that inventions are not just carried forward by their own logic. He believes it is therefore a mistake to believe technology is an independent source of social change. He also feels the theory is flawed through the fact that not all changes in society can be gauged. For example how can you measure changes in sexual morality? ...read more.

Conclusion

Volti uses the example of gunpowder being used for fireworks in china as opposed to weaponry in the west to illustrate this point. All of these concepts are very much related to each other. To be most effective they should probably be viewed as one set of theories that act as to model to predict technologies impact on society. However each one of these theories is also flawed. Technological Determinism is in essence the concept that all technology is independent. And unfortunately what it fails to take into account is that almost nothing in this world, let alone society, is independent. There can be little doubt that technology has some seemingly autonomous characteristics however it is certainly affected by some external factors. The concepts of cultural lag and the convergence theory are also reliant on the independent nature of technology and are thus somewhat flawed. Perhaps if these theories recognised the mutual relationship between society and technology, in that they both influence each other, then these theories would be more pertinent and effective. 1 http://www.scit.wlv.ac.uk/~c9814405/cp2014/howwastheinternetinvented.htm How was the Internet invented? Accessed 12/5/04. 2 Volti, Rudi. Society and Technological change. New York: St Martin's Press, 1988. 3 Volti, Rudi. Society and Technological change. New York: St Martin's Press, 1988. 4 Volti, Rudi. Society and Technological change. New York: St Martin's Press, 1988. 5 http://www.compsoc.net/~gemini/simons/historyweb/meiji-resto.html Meiji restoration, History web accessed 12/5/04. 6 Volti, Rudi. Society and Technological change. New York: St Martin's Press, 1988. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Electronic Media Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Electronic Media Studies essays

  1. Cultural and Technological Determinism Advantages and disadvantages as a tool for analysis of development ...

    is the social context, not the technology that determines the content of communication forms". Finally, he draws a conclusion: The technological determinists tend to see the influence of media technology on content as overwhelming; by contrast, cultural determinist view is empowering and gives us the power to evaluate media technologies

  2. History of the Internet.

    a means to provide a large pool of managed storage with a unified name space for all contributions to the OpenVideo library and an "intelligent download" facility for efficient access to the collection by a widely distributed community of researchers.

  1. Information technology and its impact on Portugese society

    It reduces technology to another form of cultural expression alongside the arts, literature and music. Any ethical difficulties with the introduction of technologies are thus seen as a cultural problem. The technology itself is not considered, nor is the idea that technology can influence culture.

  2. Marshall McLuhan's theories of technology as an extension of the body.

    The phonetic alphabet as an extension of both our bodies and minds, set off a whole chain reaction of changes in human societies. The phonetic alphabet distressed out tribal sensorium, fragmenting us and turning us into psychically indigent "individuals", or "units."

  1. Moral and ethical uses in Information Technology.

    It is unethical for a majority of reasons, such as bringing down the servers, and also taking advantage of innocent and unsuspecting customers. If someone wish to receive such e-mail, then that is there right, but the general public should not have to be subjected to fraudulent and immoral material.

  2. The main ethical issues relating to Information Technology.

    In the public sphere, individuals have an almost absolute right of free speech, which rarely harms others, and the liberal point of view generally acknowledges that private consenting adults have a moral and legal right to indulge in a wide variety of sexual acts.

  1. Discuss the nature of technological determinism.

    Our western societies still seem to cling to the old ideas of Modernism in many ways. Progress it would seem is now more than ever related to computer technologies. Progress itself is seen to lie within these multimedia domains. Of course technology can change our ways of living.

  2. Account for the association of technology with masculine culture. How is this culture affected ...

    Those interested on a scientific level in technology enjoy tinkering around with electronic equipment and gadgets to try and make their ideas for new technology work. In the modern day all this research and development is done in laboratories and research departments of big technology companies, but in the past

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work