• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Care versus Control: make a critical analysis of the debate, locating it in terms of policy and professional practice fo Approved Mental Health Professionals.

Extracts from this document...


?Care versus Control?: make a critical analysis of the debate, locating it in terms of policy and professional practice. This essay is going to reflect upon the tensions of care versus control and related dilemmas of rights versus risks that mental health social workers, particularly those who are Approved Mental Health Professionals (AMHP), face in practice. These issues shall be considered predominantly in relation to ?applications for compulsory admission to hospital for assessment or for treatment under Part 2 of the [Mental Health Act 1983] (s13)? (Brown, 2009, p. 63). First the role of AMHP, the MHA and policy guidance will be outlined. Due to limited words, issues associated with questions over capacity and the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) will not be discussed, nor will Community Treatment Orders despite their great relevance to this discussion. The term ?patient? will be used for consistency with the language of the legislation. Approved Mental Health Professional, Mental Health Act and Code of Practice Rapaport and Manthorpe (2008) explain that social work recognised the potential for oppression and discrimination in mental health services and that the role of Approved Social Worker (ASW) came about to safeguard against the power of medical professionals, bringing an alternative perspective. The Mental Health Act 1983 (MHA) was revised by Mental Health Act 2007 where the role and powers of ASW was replaced by AMHP, which means that some nurses, occupational therapists and psychologists, as well as social workers, can undertake training to become ?approved?. This was a controversial with some social workers asking whether these professions, given differing value bases, could ?stand up for service users suffering an acute mental health crisis? and if they would ?inevitably succumb to the medical rather than the social model of care? (Hunter, 2009:online) AMHP have several roles and responsibilities, sanctioned under the MHAs (1983 & 2007) and Code of Practice (2008) (COP) which place the social worker in a powerful position in relation to the patient; they contribute to decisions which may jeopardise an individual?s liberty and rights or care. ...read more.


treatment should only be where the patient has ?significantly impaired decision-making capacity? and the use of compulsory powers must have a therapeutic benefit for the patient. They argue that The purpose of mental health legislation should not be to detain people with mental health problems for whom no beneficial treatment can be found, and where no health benefit may result. It is also important to note the point that Yanni (2009:342) makes within his conclusions that care and control are not always opposed in the role of an AMHP, ?the former is sometimes only facilitated by use of the latter.? It is widely recognised that there are situations where there is necessity for detainment. Compulsory treatment (which can have severe ?side? effects) may be seen as more controversial, but even so there remains wide spread support or perceived ?need? for this also demonstrated by the relatively high numbers of Community Treatment Orders (The NHS Information Centre, 2010). ?The dilemma for social work ? is to determine the point at which the balance should swing from self-determination to protective intervention? (Braye, 1992:55). This is done through risk assessment, which leads us to a central part of this debate. Risk (versus rights) As mentioned above when looking at the MHA and COP, compulsory admission is largely based on assessment of risk - to self, others and perhaps even the risk services (including admission) poses; AMHPs complete risk assessments in the context of the values of the profession, social and political views and pressures and legislation. It is widely recognised that over the past decade society has generally become more sensitive to risk, with risk assessments, risk management, minimisation et cetera becoming common place. Golightley (2004:23) notes, ?Even though the risk of a stranger who is mentally ill killing you is very small, some press coverage suggests that it is a common occurrence?; portrayals in the media of relatively rare tragedies as something that we may all have to fear, contributes to culture of precaution and attempts to eliminate risk. ...read more.


At a more structural level social work as a profession must bring its values and experience, and continue to engage in critique of mental health legislation and policy. Braye, S. a.-S. (2010). Practising Sociak Work Law (3rd ed.). Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillian. Brown, R. (2009). The Approved Mental Health Professional's Guide to Mental Health Law. Exeter: Learning Matters. Butler, P (2009) Children going into care: the Baby P effect in numbers. The Guardian [online] Friday 8th May 2009 [accessed 13th Jan 10] http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2009/may/08/baby-p-childprotection Cantor, C. (1999). Compulsory admission and suicide. Psychiatric Bulletin, 23, 303. Department of Health (2008) Mental Health Act 1983: Code of Practice, TSO General Social Care Council (2002) Codes of Practice for social care workers. [leaflet] Gilbert, P. (2003). Social Work and Mental Health: The Value of Everything. Dorset: Russell House. Hale, B. (2003). Editorial. Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 25(4), iii-iv. The Health and Social Care Information Centre (2010) In-patients formally detained in hospitals under the Mental Health Act 1983 and patients subject to supervised community treatment, Annual figures, England 2009/10 [online] [accessed 15 Jan 10] http://www.ic.nhs.uk /webfiles/publications/05_Mental_Health/inpatientdetmha0910/KP90_final_report.pdf Hunter, M (2009) New Mental Health Professionals. Community Care. [Online] 15th June [Accessed 9th January 2011] http://www.communitycare.co.uk/Articles/2009/06/16/111823/New-approved-mental-health-professionals-discuss-the.htm McLaughlin, K. (2006). Scare in the Community . Spiked. [online] [accessed 13th January 2010] http://www.spiked-online.com/index.php/site/article/2212/ McLaughlin, K. (2007). Regulation and Risk in Social Work. British Journal of Social Work (2007), 37, 1263?1277. Mental Health Alliance (no date) Alliance policies: Conditions for Compulsion [online] [accessed 14th Jan 10] http://www.mentalhealthalliance.org.uk/policy/conditions.html Peay, J. (2003). Decisions and Dilemmas, Working with Mental Health Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing. Rapaport, J. a. (2008). Family Matters: Developments Concerning the Role of the Nearest Relative and Social Worker under Mental Health Law in England and Wales. British Journal of Social Work, 38(6), 1115-1131. Thompson, P. (2003). Devils and deep blue seas: the social worker in-between. Journal of Social Work Practice, 17(1), 35 ? 48. Webber, M. (2008). Evidence-based Policy and Practice in Mental Health Social Work. Exeter: Learning Matters. Yianni, C. (2009). Aces High: My Control Trumps Your Care. Ethics and Social Welfare, 3(3), 337 ?343. The Health and Social Care Information ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The problem for unpaid carers is that they have few rights and resources but ...

    4 star(s)

    A recent study (Carers Speak out Project, 31) highlighted that 73% of the carers who participated knew about the support and services available to them. The Government believes that ?local support services for carers are best run by the voluntary sector?? and that all cares should have access to the support services they require (Carers Speak out Project: 31).

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Unit 10 care practice and provision

    3 star(s)

    drop in clinic for refugees and older people. One of the most successful health strategies that the WPCT has been involved with is the non-smoking campaign, which helped people within Wokingham by providing clinics that could support and help smokers try and reduced there daily intake and then by totally giving up.

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Social work assessments are an art and a science.

    3 star(s)

    One of Mrs P's main concerns were her depression and isolation however she is slowly overcoming this by attending day care, meeting people and joining I activities. Mrs P's granddaughter previously mentioned that Mrs P had a tendency to cry at home due to loneliness.

  2. Health and Social Care practitioners in the UK must work within a legal and ...

    Monitoring should be repeated throughout care so adaptations can be implemented to suit any changes in condition. A variety of sources of information can be used to monitor, for example: service user interview, service user records, observation of service user, their care, and environment.

  1. The importance of therapeutic relationships in the delivery of care.

    Total comfort cannot be achieved without first ensuring safety, safety in hospital has many facets. The initial assessment is a vital part of developing the relationship and ensuring patient safety, it will ensure that comfort and hygiene needs are met, dietary requirements are adequate and assistance provided where necessary.

  2. This essay will focus on inter-professional working in health and social care delivery.

    Robinson and Cottrell (2005) investigated interprofessional working and discovered that joint working between health and social care can cause conflict and barriers to effective joint working. Collaboration between both professions could be negatively affected by the medical profession using the medical model and the social care profession using the social model resulting in barriers created by different attitudes to practice.

  1. Write an essay which analyses the case study in terms of the sociological and ...

    He also added from research interviews that several themes arose including working out how to deal with the diagnosis and ensuring that it didn't interfere with daily life, and how such diagnosis' impacted greatly on men and their wives. Strategies also needed to be employed to keep the relationships ever

  2. The Individual Accessing Health & Social Care. This assignment discusses learning disabilities and ...

    these changes have been accompanied by changes in individual behaviour, in lifestyle and in patterns of consumption, associated with changes in the pattern of health and disease. The degree individuals and groups are affected depend on the extent to which they take risks with their health, and whether they adopt healthy or unhealthy habits.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work