• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The arts deal in the particular, the individual and the personal while the sciences deal in the general, the universal and the collective." To what extent does this statement obscure the nature of both areas of knowledge?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Anna Tichonova AIS Vienna 01.07.2004 Word count: ..... 8. "The arts deal in the particular, the individual and the personal while the sciences deal in the general, the universal and the collective." To what extent does this statement obscure the nature of both areas of knowledge? "All men by nature desire knowledge".1 Metaphysics talks about the fact that the basis of knowledge comes from human manner to enjoy its senses. Feeling is the form of knowledge, which is given to us by nature, since it also exists in animals.2 However, in animals it is linked to direct benefit, while in humans it can simply be related to pleasure, which can be named "aesthetic". Aesthetic delight, which is reached through sensation, is no longer animal instinct, but primal knowledge, which contains the roots of both art and science. Both artistic and scientific knowledge come from accumulation and generalization of experience, which result from memory, a collection of impressions. Aristotle was also able to show that any art as well as science much contain at least a small portion of knowledge obtained through experimentation. In the beginning art and science arouse out of the same group, but as the European culture began to give a special position to the artists, art and science began to separate and stated having very different social functions. ...read more.

Middle

There are many examples when artists were interested in science and technology, while scientists were inspired by arts. There have been remarkable parallels between the movements in art and the development in science. An example of such is the unity of space and time in relativity and the Cubist series of temporal views across space. At the same time, Albert Einstein was inspired by Fyodor Dostoevsky, claming that "Dostoevsky gives [him] more than any scientist, more than Gauss".3 In philosophy, the relationship between science and art is examined within the theory of knowledge called: gnosiology. In the past century, there was constant fight between the two theories: scientism and anti-scientism.4 From the scientism point of view, science has the highest cultural value. Anti-scientism points out that science limit us in the solution of human problems. It shows science as the antagonistic force that takes away from the freedom of will and creative individuality. One cannot observe the world merely through science, since the truth is also intuitive. Thus, in the opinion of Italian philosopher B. Croce5, science and art are the two stages of knowledge. The First stage is intuitive knowledge, which is achieved through imagination. An example of this is art. The second stage is the knowledge achieved through logic; the initial tool for which is intellect. ...read more.

Conclusion

However, when considering art as a whole, a universal picture of the world is created. The difference is merely between the methods in which we receive the knowledge. While observing art, one gains knowledge from emotional experience, while in science, logical is used to explain an occurrence. Even though art is often individually oriented, the creations of art have an enormous value for humanity as a whole. Art is universal and general, even though the aesthetical concept of beauty depends on time and place. Art is able to accumulating experience which was collected for centuries. Scientific knowledge, on the other hand, is usually obtained through scientific methods, which are seen as authentic. However, science on its own is not able explain the world, since it often fails to consider human factors. Art represents the intuitive stage of knowledge, while science consists of logical thinking. The intuitive method can also be used in science, while an art masterpiece can be a result of scientific research, such as Leonardo Da Vinci's Human Proportions-Vitruvian Man.7 Knowledge which is obtained with the help of science, and knowledge, obtained with the help of art is fundamentally different and fulfills different tasks and goal, yet the combination of art and science provides complete human knowledge and can, therefore, be considered universal. B. Croce, states that art and science are closely related and function together. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Art & Design section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Art & Design essays

  1. Personal study for art

    world, transforming the flow of moments into something visual, or textual, or musical. Art creates a kind of commentary. I think what I'm trying to do is create moments of recognition. To try to detonate some kind of feeling or understanding of lived experience.

  2. To what extent may the subjective nature of perception be regarded as an advantage ...

    revealed by comments such as, "Very low-something wrong," and, "This is almost exactly right." Throughout, Milikan appears to have been driven partly by a desire to get results that were self-consistent, broadly in agreement with other methods, and consistent with his personal view that the electron is Page 2 the fundamental and indivisible unit of electric charge.

  1. Personal Study - Journeys.

    However this contrasts to the artists that I am studying, as their photographs are static records of a journey. I have chosen three artists who are primarily sculptors who create installations out of nature. They travel, recording their findings/ creations or journeys using photography.

  2. Graffiti art is an art form.

    Third, graffiti art even has been recognized by the art world. A fourth criterion is that the public response to graffiti art indicates that it is art. Whether or not all of the public agrees that graffiti art is good, bad, or extremely valuable is a different discussion about evaluation and not whether or not graffiti art is art.

  1. Free essay

    Art History & Philosophy 1) In a democracy, ought members of a persistent ...

    to both the evidence that smoking is bad for your health and the lack of places to smoke. Despite attempts to overturn the ban in certain places (such as mental hospitals & prisons) they have been largely unsuccessful in doing so.

  2. There are various political and economic elements affected an ongoing growth of the arts.

    Northern European paintings had to consist of secular subjects such as portraits, landscapes and scenes from everyday life to attract the Protestant customers. Thus, numerous painters were deeply in great debts and die of poverty, they have to sell their works at the market places.

  1. Discuss the extent to which the international art market is a regulator in the ...

    In this instance, how best the international art market can be organized, what is the best way to balance the supply of art and what is the market's purpose through the dissociation of good art from junk art. The market must restrict the supply of art and antiques selecting the

  2. Virginia Woolf Lecture 1 - aesthete or feminist revolutionary?

    116:II, middle. The artist's responsibility, then, is to enter sympathetically into these various ways of seeing the world, and bring them into a harmony in the work of art. That harmony is not final or absolute, but a necessary fiction, see final para of novel.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work