• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse the case study with reference to Michael Porter's Theory of Competitive Advantage and answer the following question: Does America have competitive advantage in the textile and garment industry?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Analyse the case study with reference to Michael Porter's Theory of Competitive Advantage and answer the following question: Does America have competitive advantage in the textile and garment industry? You answer must include the following elements: 1. A clear outline of Porter's theory with supporting references. 20% 2. An analysis of the case study with reference to the 4 main elements of Porter's Diamond. (N.B. You will not be able to comment on company structure, as the case study does not include information on this. You should, however, refer to factor conditions, demand conditions, firm rivalry and related and supporting industries.) 40% 3. An analysis of the case study with reference to Porter's secondary points of chance and government actions. 20% 4. Your conclusion. 10 % The remaining 10 % will be for grammar, style, clarity, using the correct system of referencing (the Harvard System) etc. Literature: Michael E. Porter. The Competitive Advantage of Nations. Does America have competitive advantage in the textile and garment industry? For a country to have a competitive advantage, it is necessary to understand Michael Porter's Theory of National Competitive Advantage. Michael Porter introduced a model that allows analysing why some nations are more competitive than others are, and why some industries within nations are more competitive than others are, in his book The Competitive Advantage of Nations. This model of determining factors of national advantage has become known as Porters Diamond. ...read more.

Middle

Therefore in this area, it does not have competitive advantage over the Chinese in textile making. Despite globalization, the America has top fashion houses, with brand names. As cost is not a factor in high fashion sector and there are skilled workforce in this area, America has factor conditions to withstand challenge in this area at least. Another factor condition is the pool of knowledge, whether it is scientific, technical and marketing. The case study mentions that the American garment makers offer electronic ordering, automated distribution centers and inventory management systems tied to those of their customers. The best manufactures have learned how to deliver orders at a few days' notice that the overseas competitors cannot match. The country is able to upgrade and remain competitive though innovation. As Porter mentions that factor conditions are not natural or inherited but created and this is an example of it. Last factor condition is the quality of infrastructure, such as transport and communication. This is in plentiful supply and China has a long way in catching up. ------------------------------------------------------------------ Porter argues that strong local demand is essential for increasing a nations competitive advantage. For a nation to be competitive it must possess strong local demand. Local demand: * lets the producer know what the buyer wants; allows then to respond faster to this than producers in other countries This is evident in the case study and for this reason Levi and Gap are already experimenting with scan so that the customer gets what it wants. ...read more.

Conclusion

Porter suggests that countries advance through 4 stages and should look to the stage they are in to get competitive advantage. Summary The American textile industry possesses certain characteristics which suggest it has a competitive advantage in the textile industry. In concern to factor conditions the USA is the second largest grower of cotton after china this is its natural resource. It has a skill;ed workforce to make textiles it also has capital intensive looms which poorer countries can't afford. America has a competitive advantage in textile making. Obviously it does not have a competive advantage in clothes making as china has lower labour cost as the cost advantage is not there. Factories making garments are closing howver this has not affected fashion house as they have established a brand name and people buy their goods and do not worry about the cost. Howver for companys lioke gap it makes sense to locate production in china as price is unbeatable. Cotton is grown in north Carolina and Mississippi they supply cotton textile weaving companies they inturn supply their companies making the clothes. The case study does not deal with the clustering firms . it only talks about production of textile movement to mexico where clothes are made. The essay talks about rivalry between levis and gap. The competition is forcing the companies to innovate and they are working on scanner tio stay ahead of competiton. Competiton has resulted in improving ordering, distribution and inventory management. Opening up the market is causing factory closures the Nafta agreement was reached and this moved [roduction to mexico. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Case Studies and Analysis section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Case Studies and Analysis essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Wace Burgess Case Study

    4 star(s)

    Quality also reduces costs, they will be able to minimise the mistakes being made if quality was high this will mean more time spent on quality with less time being spent on fixing mistakes which will in turn cause less confusion and irritation to M&S.

  2. Proctor & Gamble, Inc. (Scope Case)

    This can be done through effective target market research. Our advertisements will focus on the effectiveness of using Scope on a daily basis. If we get the 45% of users that use around 4/week to use 5/week we can increase our units sold by 49,500 units.

  1. Microsoft Case Study. Objectives, structure and marketing.

    This can be said as it within a small period of around 10 years of console and second release of console the Xbox 360 gained 39 million sales worldwide which surpassed the original consoles market of Playstations which had a massive customer base for years.

  2. Case study of The Jollibee Foods Corporation

    survey by Euromoney Magazine Recognized by Forbes Asia Magazine as one of the 200 "Best Under a Billion" companies in Asia in year 2005. Tony Tan Caktiong, CEO & President of Jollibee Food Corporation, was awarded 2004 World Entrepreneur of the Year by Earnst & Young The Most admired corporation

  1. PEST is a planning tool which is used by a business to evaluate and ...

    Ginsters will be meeting their stakeholder's needs as they are making sure that they have standards in place to ensure the health and safety off all employees and people who are affected by the business. This means that there employees will be feel as if Ginsters has taken their needs

  2. NHS change management

    Hence we suggest that NHS implements reviewing and monitoring as a vital aspect of its implementation plan, through which they should aim at standardizing small wins and celebrating them to raise the low motivation and commitment levels. Writing about the strategic change and drawing the strategic plans for managing the change is not so difficult.

  1. Unit 9: Marketing Strategy

    My subsequent marketing warfare strategy will be that of Guerrilla, I will rely on the element of surprise to announce Fabulous Frostings as a market challenger. Despite this strategy having the promise work well when attacking immediate competitors such as Gray and Goodliffe, I will not realistically be able to attack large competitors such as Tesco.

  2. I will be identifying the legal criteria for offer and acceptance in a valid ...

    Angus and Daniel: Later on Saturday, Daniel asked Angus to keep the offer open till Monday and he gave him 50 pounds to wait for him until then and not sell the computer. By giving him the 50 pounds, Daniel has already gone into contract with Angus as there has been an advanced payment for the good.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work