• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the presentation of Muslim people in the two media texts you have studied; Carol Sarler's article (Sunday People) Casualty,

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss the presentation of Muslim people in the two media texts you have studied; Carol Sarler's article (Sunday People) Casualty, "Everlasting Love" I have recently studied two different media texts. I did this in an effort to find out how Muslim people are sometimes treated and presented in the British media. The first piece that I studied was an article written by Carol Sarler in the "Sunday People". The article's headline was "It's time we stood up to these Muslim bullies". The second piece that I studied was an episode of Casualty. This was called "Everlasting Love" and was written by Barbara Machin. Casualty is one of the BBC's flagship shows and is shown on a Saturday night at 8 o'clock. The episode concerned was, in the public's/audience's view, the best ever. When it was shown, it received an audience of around 15 million, it's biggest ever. First of all, I would like to discuss the audiences of both pieces. Carol Sarler's article, having been on page 33 of the Sunday People would not have had a very big audience. However small the audience though, it was definitely aimed at the white community. I can see this just by looking at the headline. The word "we" is used as if she thinks there is only one culture in Britain, the white community. I also think that this article is potentially very dangerous. If its target audience (the white community) ...read more.

Middle

Although this language can potentially split the audience and make a lot of people angry, she is very successful in using it. I know this because when I first began to read the article, she had me believing that her statements and that her points were truthful. This was until I realised just how racist this article really was. These statements would most definitely offend the minority audience, the Muslim community. They would be offended straight away, just after reading the headline! "It's time we stood up to these Muslim bullies" is bound to cause anger throughout the Muslim people straight away. But I also think that the headline is an intriguing one and so intrigues the reader to read on. This makes it a successful headline (in terms of gaining an audience). The Muslim reader, however, would not like the fact that Carol Sarler is separating them from the rest of the country in just her first sentence! S/he would most definitely be angered by what they are reading. This however is what Carol Sarler intends for in this article; an emotional response. The division in the audience is that the white community starts to separate itself from the Muslim community. The Muslim community is angered and feels discriminated against. This is the exact intention of the writer. The second technique that Carol Sarler uses is the use of assertions. Assertions are opinions given by the writer with no evidence to back them up. ...read more.

Conclusion

I especially did not like Carol Sarler's article. In my opinion, it is an extremely racist and corrupt article. The techniques that she uses turn audiences against each other. Carol Sarler's article is very successful in what it aims for, to corrupt and cause a reaction, but in terms of facts, it is a very weakly written piece of work. In fact, both pieces are very weakly written in the sense that they don't use facts. Carol Sarler gives opinions and presents them as facts, i.e. when she explains that Mosques preach to Muslims and tell them to annihilate the white community. This is obviously not true, but she presents it in a way that makes the reader believe it. Casualty is also poorly written by Barbara Machin. She too cannot get her facts right about the Muslim people. The sister of the "bad-guy" in Casualty is called Lamisha. This name, as a matter of fact, is not even a Muslim name! The Muslim people in my class have never even heard the name or even associated the name with Islam. It's ironic isn't it? That this writer can write a whole story on a Muslim family's problems, but then can't even get a name correct?! I do think, overall, that these texts are very poorly and very weakly written. I think that it is quite dangerous to write about and criticise a culture when the writer doesn't even know the facts. The two pieces can create a lot of fear in the Muslim community because they both turn the majority against them. Alex Armstead ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. Written Speech on Islam.

    I try my best to fit in with both worlds. But I know that I am (look to left of audience, expressively), that us Muslims are, losing touch (look to right of audience of our religious, and cultural beliefs. The Salwar Kameez is not a religious type of clothing, as

  2. The stimulus we were given to look at was the play 'Too Much Punch ...

    I think we could have improved on our ideas by flowing from one flashback to another with ease; there was a sort of stop and start as we ended one flashback and moved onto another. Our group worked very well together on this task, we sat down and discussed our ideas and then got to work developing them straight away.

  1. "The paradox of Artaud lies in the fact that it is impossible to carry ...

    of this is when a male member of our class screamed it seemed to be a cry of frustration and anger so I had an image of quite a large man screaming at someone quite smaller than themselves but when a female in our class screamed it was considerably higher

  2. Free essay

    G.C.S.E media essay : bladerunner

    when we view Los Angeles we get flick shots of an eye. These shots make the audience anticipate when it is next going to happen. This suggests that the director is trying to make the viewers feel unsure as they cannot guess when the next flick shot will be.

  1. How does the programme Blackadder describe the lives, fears and feelings of the men ...

    But their thoughts to Haig are very unhappy as he doesn't really care about men in the War. Haig's office is very bright and colourful and when this is compared to a dark and dingy trench, this shows the audience a lot such as, the trenches were very dark and extremely dingy and with no colour at all besides brown.

  2. By the bog of cats

    she feels wrong and betrayed and vows to take from Carthage Kilbride whatever she can. She burns down the home that he and Caroline are to share, she torches his livestock, and to spare their daughter from the misery of a childhood without her mother, Hester Swane herself takes their

  1. Compare the presentation of heroes and villains in 'Shrek' by DreamWorks and other traditional ...

    The donkey, in Shrek, makes a mockery of this stereotype, which is done to add comedy to the film. We also notice that Donkey actually has an important role throughout the film as he also takes part in saving the princess.

  2. My task for the controlled condition test was to construct a 15-minute presentation centred ...

    From Ghost dances, we assembled much of the basis of our theme for the presentation and this was spirits. We used the exact routine taught to us in previous projects within our presentation to portray to the audience that one of our characters was a ghost.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work