• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast Hester Prynne (The scarlet letter) and Elizabeth Proctor (The Crucible).

Extracts from this document...


Hester Prynne was the main character in The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Although Hester Prynne was the main character, the book was not so much a consideration of her expected character as it was an examination of the forces that shaped her and the transformations that forced consequences. Elizabeth Proctor was one of the main characters in The Crucible by Arthur Miller. She shared along with her husband John a similarly strict obedience to justice and moral principles. Hester and Elizabeth both share similar motivations and characteristics but also have different inspirations and uniqueness that make them distinguishing as a person. Hester Prynne is introduced in the beginning of the book as a sinner: one who commits adultery. In the book she became intrigued and began to speculate on human nature, social organizations and larger moral questions. Her tribulations lead her to become impassive and a freethinker. She forgot what people thought about her and called her, and she began to help others by sewing. Elizabeth Proctor is first introduced in the book as a woman who had great confidence in her own morality and in the ability of a person to maintain a sense of righteousness both internal and external, even when this principle conflicts with strict Christian doctrine. ...read more.


Hester was self-determining to her environment. She wanted to keep peace, never saying too much and never saying too little. She knew her place in society. Elizabeth's Husband had an affair with one of their slaves Abigail Williams, which caused her to have to throw her out of their house. When Elizabeth Proctor's husband tried to tell the courts that the witch trials were all a hoax, he admitted that he had an affair with Abigail. If his wife would testify that he did have an affair, then the testimony would be proof that the witch trials were all a hoax. When Elizabeth was brought into court they asked her why she threw Abigail William out of the house. She lied and said because she was not pleased. The only reason why she lied was because she knew during this time a woman should keep her place. Usually if a woman told her husbands business it brought reproving to his character and the whole family. So if she told the truth about the relationship it wouldn't just signify a cast down of her husband but a demoralizing of the whole family. ...read more.


She was definitely faithful to her husband's ideals and morals, never telling a soul what he did. Both characters Hester of The Scarlet Letter and Elizabeth of The Crucible had many things in common including their loyalty towards others and their motivations to better themselves in their environments. The organization of both books went from lighthearted to determination and finally to fulfillment and achievements. In the beginning of both books the environment was lighthearted. In The Scarlet Letter, they were scorning Hester for being adulterous. In The Crucible the town blamed everyone about being a witch. They pick up anyone who was mentioned in court. Then both books moved to determination. Hester began to want to better herself in society, so she started helping others by sewing. Elizabeth's determination was shown when she was condemned as a witch. In that scene everyone was yelling but she stayed calm and she quieted everyone down. She knew she was not a witch so she was determined that she was not going to be killed. Then the organization turned into fulfillment and achievement. Hester was then accepted in society again and many realized that sins should not be damned upon. Elizabeth did not die because she was pregnant. She achieved her determination not to die. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. Discuss the Relationship between John and Elizabeth Proctor and its Presentation. In What Ways ...

    The presentation of their relationship further in this act becomes much more different, as they begin to argue, the lexis however is still very formal. John says, "Women I'll not have your suspicion any more." John addressing his wife with the word "woman" is very cruel, and degrading, almost as if they are not married.

  2. Argue that the theory of common sense structures provides an important and hitherto unappreciated ...

    two notions of aggregate or assembly on the one hand and stuff in the strict sense on the other. 4. Surfaces, Limits, Boundaries, Media A systematic ontology of surfaces has been put forward in Stroll's classic (1988), where he also investigates the role that is played by surfaces from the point of view of epistemology.

  1. The Crucible: How is tension created and maintained between John and Elizabeth, and how ...

    They start by setting the scene "The common room of Proctor's house, eight days later". This already tells us that John is withholding his information as it is eight days since he heard Abigail tell him her actions were nothing to do with witchcraft.

  2. The Crucible - How does Miller effectively create a sense of tension and conflict ...

    It is ironic that John complimented her on the seasoning on the rabbit, since he seasoned it himself; this in particular highlights the conflict between them. At first glance the proctor household appears homely, welcoming and peaceful.

  1. By comparing the two acts in which the relationship of John and Elizabeth Proctor ...

    audience that if the couple's relationship does not improve then he'll take extreme actions. Miller also helps to portray the lack of trust present in the relationship through Elizabeth's reactions when Proctor kisses her, she coldly receives the kiss. The fact that she does not get up and warmly hug

  2. how doe arthur miller create tension in the crucible

    The setting of the scene makes the audience question Johns commitment to Elizabeth , the scene is set eight days after Abigail told John that her actions are nothing to do with revealing that in fact there are no witches in the village and they where just dancing sinfully.

  1. How does Arthur Miller present the relationship of John and Elizabeth Proctor in The ...

    Well during the play the relationship changes quite a lot. In the beginning the relationship is very dreadful, during the middle it's getting better and in the end the relationship is quite good but can be better. In the beginning of the play we can see that it wasn't a

  2. How Does the Dialogue Between John and Elizabeth Proctor in Pages 41 - 46 ...

    Elizabeth Proctor is a very kind, intelligent, but unhappy woman that has been deeply hurt by her husband. Whenever she is around her husband she tries to please him, as if she is inadequate for him, and replies to his questions quickly and pleasantly.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work