• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the way the poets write about love and relationships in "Sonnet" by Elizabeth Barrett Browning and "Sonnet 138" by William Shakespeare

Extracts from this document...


Compare the way the poets write about love and relationships in "Sonnet" by Elizabeth Barrett Browning and "Sonnet 138" by William Shakespeare A sonnet is traditionally a love poem, with 14 lines and generally ending with a couplet. The two sonnets I am comparing discuss the nature of love, but portray two completely different relationships between lovers. While Browning's poem is an ode to a pure, simple and almost childlike love, Shakespeare's is a critique of his relationship, in which both sides play a game of double-bluff. This poem mocks the idea of true love. We sense simply from the titles that, while Browning's "Sonnet" is an expression of heartfelt emotions, Shakespeare's "Sonnet 138" is just another meaningless work out of many, perhaps like his mistresses. Browning's work is extremely feminine and is almost certainly about her husband, as she was married, as opposed to the masculine view of women in Shakespeare's era that mistresses were disposable. ...read more.


He cannot be angry with her for lying to him because he reciprocates in the matter. He is happy in the situation, and believes that his lover thinks he is na�ve and "unlearned in the world's false subtleties". He seems to fear being alone and not being able to obtain another mistress. This is in sharp contrast to Browning's sense of security with her lover, and feeling of openness and honesty. There is a quality of immortality to her love that is suggested in the phrase, "I shall but love thee better after death". The nature of the two relationships differ a great deal ; we sense that , while Browning conveys a love that is very spiritual and uncomplicated, Shakespeare's relationship is more sexual without much actual love.Religious words and imagery, such as "Grace", "Praise", "Faith", "Candlelight" and "God" are used to reinforce the feeling of purity in "Sonnet". ...read more.


She could therefore see her husband as a father figure as he protects her and gives her stability. On the other hand, language is used to the opposite effect in Shakespeare's "Sonnet 138". The childhood aspect of this poem is related to gullibility. He makes use of negative words such as "lies", "unjust", "untutor'd" and "false" to show that he does not believe in love. Using these words in rhyming couplets - "lies" and "subtleties" - even more pronounces the negative imagery. The sonnet out of the two that I prefer is "Sonnet 138" by Shakespeare. This is because he has made a break from the traditional style of sonnets, which usually exhault the ideal of love and describe it in all it's beauty. He takes the idea of love and almost mocks it, satirising the orthodox style of other sonnets. More complex language is used within the sonnet, unlike Browning's simple prose. The impact of both of the poems is that they make us think about love in very different ways. Zo� Molyneux Form 116 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sonnets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sonnets essays

  1. The Sonnet

    "How do I love thee? Let me count the ways. I love thee to the depth and breadth and height My soul can reach, when feeling out of sight For the ends of Being and ideal Grace." The sonnet starts very powerfully by repeating the words 'I love thee' in

  2. The History of the Sonnet

    'them' representing the higher classes, and [uz] represent the people below them. Looking at both sonnets, it is possible to see that both have similar structures. You can immediately see that Harrison has not used the traditional fourteen line structure for his sonnets, but instead has changed it, creating sixteen line sonnets.

  1. Compare how the conventions of the sonnet

    The personification of the sun in this way is also extremely effective in enhancing the romantic meaning of the sonnet. However, by calling it the 'eye of heaven' the speaker is also using the sun to represent death. The speaker appears to change his theme and say, metaphorically, that like summer his beloved will eventually end.

  2. Are there any ways in which you consider that experiences conveyed by the sonnets, ...

    The tone also inflicts the idea that the statement cannot be contradicted, and the two lines give the sonnet a balance when read. The repetition of the words 'So long' in both lines emphasise the point made; the beauty is always present.

  1. What is love? Compare and contrast Shakespeare's presentation of it's paradox in sonnets 116 ...

    proved" (116, 13), because Shakespeare did write it, "I never writ" (116, 14), and men have "loved" (116, 14). Sonnet 147 is a sustained analogy of love as disease. The sonnet begins with a simile "My love is as a fever" (147, 1), it then continues to explore the comparison

  2. Compare how love is portrayed in Sonnet 18,

    This is a more optimistic and romantic view of the poem than the interpretation discussed previously. I personally am not entirely sure whether I agree with this interpretation but I definitely think there is a large amount of content in it which is faithful to Shakespeare's poem.

  1. Explore aspects of the sonnet tradition through reference to a range of material you ...

    At such a young age, John Keats was truly an inspirational poet who could have ranked amongst the best if he had been given longer to live. In the last line of his sonnet he describes how he is feeling, sanding alone with his fame and love fading and with nothing to do but wait for death to sacrum him.

  2. Consider the sonnet as a verse form. With examples compare the Petrarchan and ...

    The theme of love and time is typically Petrarchan, and there is also a natural turn of thought after the octave. However, it is divided into three quatrains and a rhyming couplet and some of the lines, such as "Whose worths unknowne, although his higth be taken," have eleven syllables, instead of the traditional ten.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work