• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Hamlet’s dilemma.

Extracts from this document...


Hamlet's dilemma "To be, or to be, that is the question/Whether' tis nobler in the mind to suffer/the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune/Or to take arms against a sea of troubles/And by opposing end them all." This speech is the most discussed in Shakespeare, and the most misinterpreted. It is the question that plagues Hamlet through the entire play. On the one hand, this is a speech about self-murder and quite simply Hamlet is questioning if it is worth living in such misery. However, critics argue whether Hamlet is discussing his individual dilemma or whether the whole course of his argument is general, not personal. The question is not whether Hamlet should pursue revenge against the king, but whether he should follow his scheme, which he has already set in motion. At this stage Hamlet is suicidal and risks himself being estranged from religious principles. Both suicide and murdering King Claudius would make him feel guilt at having violated religious coda, thus representing estrangement at the level of his religious consciousness. As Hamlet has the duty to avenge his father's death by killing His father's murderer, the King, Hamlet risks separation at the religious level. ...read more.


What would the people think of their prince if he were to murder the king? What kind of effect would it have on his beloved mother? Hamlet considers questions of this type, which in effect hasten his decision. After all, once his mother is dead and her feelings out of the picture, Hamlet is quick and aggressive in forcing poison into Claudius's mouth. Some critics believe that Hamlet simply thinks too much. He wants the murder of the King to be perfect. Claudius has to go to hell. The people have to know about the murderer Claudius. Hamlet spends too much time planning and not enough time doing; thus, making the King's murder more complicated than other murders he has orchestrated. Also, he has to be careful around Claudius after the play because it revealed his sanity to the King as it revealed the guilt of Claudius to Hamlet. After the play within a play, Hamlet has proof and still cannot act. Not until everybody is dying, including himself, does he realize that he should not have waited so long. He understands the consequences of his delay all of his pent-up rage explodes, and he murders the King; getting the revenge he was after from the beginning. ...read more.


Hamlet establishes a need for revenge when he encounters a ghost in the appearance of his father. His "supposed" father is in purgatory. His father requests that Hamlet should take the life of the person who murdered him, or else he will forever remain in purgatory. During the players play, however, Hamlet establishes that Claudius was guilty of his father's murder. Hamlet needs to look at how he is to take revenge upon Claudius, ensuring he does not "o'erflow the measure" and upset his mother. Hamlet's sentiments are no more than expected of a revenger, in literature, if not life, and they are consistent in other plays, but although Hamlet's sentiments are those proper to a revenger and must be accepted at face value. The dilemma ultimately arises as, the revenger with his passion at its climax following proof of his enemies' guilt, is presented with his victim, defenceless and alone; and yet it is revenge itself that provides an incontestable reason why this seemingly perfect opportunity is one impossible to take; Hamlet does not want to go to hell. The revenger's horrifying sentiments contribute to the overall presentation of the play as a whole and by the end of the play, Hamlet's dilemma, if anything has been made worse and nothing more than a frenzied killing ends his downfall. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Hamlet essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the presentation of revenge in 'Hamlet'.

    4 star(s)

    Hamlet refuses to recognise the impossible situation his friends were placed in, and resents them for abandoning him when he needs them most, even though it is his feud with Claudius that has forced them to into it. Feeling betrayed, he has no compunctions in using them to further his own gains.

  2. Critical review of 'Hamlet'

    It is not such a cowardly and procrastinating personality that forbids him action but thoughtful and bitter, that he wants true suffering. Therefore I would argue he isn't suicidal. By the same admission I would say Hamlet is perfectly sane because he deals with deaths, murders, a new family, loss

  1. Scene by Scene - Hamlet.

    Now Polonius tells a lie. He emphasizes that he had no knowledge of Hamlet's romantic interest in Ophelia until she told him and gave him the love letter. Polonius then truthfully tells how he forbade Ophelia to see or accept messages from Hamlet.

  2. Is Hamlet mad? How does Shakespeare make his audience think about this question and ...

    Gertrude is very scared about how he is acting and thinks that for some reason he is going to murder her, so she calls 'help, help, ho!' Polonius answers from behind the wall hanging. Hamlet probably thinks that Polonius is the King who has been spying on him, so he

  1. Is Hamlet a man of inaction?

    Now put yourself in hamlets situation you are a seventeenth century prince, a scholar based in a sheltered world, a world where you are oblivious to the fact that people lie, that people can be two faced and it is unbeknown to you that people are selfish and will put

  2. Discussing Hamlet.

    The bleak, grim words of the soliloquy, such as "stale...unprofitable" express of his depression and distaste of life. Hamlet in my opinion is also very unhappy with the state of Denmark, metaphorically representing it as an "unweeded garden", that is a diseased and corrupted pit: "rank and gross".

  1. Discuss the atmosphere created at the beginning of the play. What is its relevance ...

    They believe that the ghost can in fact be an evil spirit which is embodied in another dead person's body, in other words King Hamlet's body for the sentries claim that the ghost that they have seen bears the same figure as Hamlet's father, "In the same figure like the King that's dead"3.

  2. Criticism on Hamlet

    apprehension is in ourselves, the mystery has been too commonly explained by the very easy process of setting it down as in fact inexplicable, and by resolving the phenomenon into a misgrowth or lusus of the capricious and irregular genius of Shakspere.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work