• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Long and the Short and the Tall Assignment

Extracts from this document...


The Long and the Short and the Tall Assignment The play is set in an abandoned mining hut in the Malayan jungle in 1942 during the Second World War. The Japanese are advancing upon British controlled Singapore. This play focuses on a small British patrol group who were sent north into the jungle to check for signs of Japanese advance. The patrol consists of seven soldiers from different parts of Britain. Leading them are Sergeant Mitchem and Corporal Johnstone. These two highly experienced and well trained soldiers have very different views on war and its workings. The other soldiers in the group are not as capable or well trained as Mitchem or Johnstone; they have not experienced the cruel, harsh reality of war. The group consists of Evans, Macliesh, Whitaker, Mitchem, Bamforth, Smith and Johnstone. Evans is a straightforward, simple Welshman who loves and misses his homeland; he looks up to and admires Bamforth for his quick wit and self confidence. Macleish is a kind, caring Scotsman who worries about his brother Donald that has been sent north. Macleish takes life quite seriously and can be strict when he has to be. ...read more.


The way Hall creates humour and a light hearted mood at the beginning of the play sets the scene for the climatic ending. In act one the author is introducing the characters to us; we are able to see what kind of people each of them are and how they feel about each other, the relationships between the soldiers are obvious. The mood only changes when the Japanese soldier enters the play and the patrol become uneasy and tense. The Japanese soldier first enters the play when out of curiosity he approaches the hut that the soldiers are hiding in. He walks up to the window, looks in and sees that there is a radio on the table but does not realise what he sees so he continues on, suddenly he does a double take and realises that there is a the radio on the table. When he walks through the door, the soldiers ambush and are going to kill him but none of them are able to kill another human being in cold blood apart from Bamforth who offers to do it and compares it to 'carving up a pig'. ...read more.


They see that he is most likely a conscript like them who was sent out to fight for his country. As a member of the audience I pity the Japanese soldier because he is an ordinary man who is a victim of war. In conclusion I feel that the Japanese soldier, without meaning to, brings destruction and the end to all of their lives, though I do not feel that the prisoner is entirely responsible for their deaths because it was Whitaker's fault that the prisoner entered the play in the first place. If Whitaker had not left the radio set on the table the Japanese soldier may not have entered the hut, but even if he had it was Whitaker who panicked and shot the prisoner forcing them all to go out fight in the battle that killed them all. Another reason for them all dying was that they could not decide what to do with the prisoner. Bamforth sympathised with the prisoner as he realised that he is a 'man' whereas the rest of the patrol are following Mitchem's orders to kill the prisoner, it could be argued that it was Bamforth's fault that they all died. I do not feel that one individual can be blamed for what happened. James Collins 10Sw/Bg BWHS ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. The long and the short and the tall

    He dehumanises the prisoner by saying, 'It's only the same as carving up a pig'. This strong comparison shows that Bamforth considers the prisoner as no more than an animal. Bamforth is just about to kill the prisoner when Mitchem orders him to stop.

  2. Modern History:Individual Research Assignment : Nazism

    The Pope of the time was Pope Pius XIII, he didn't respond to the German bishops pleas until finally he attempted to confront Hitler himself, not after more than 5,000,000 Jewish people were slaughtered, many of which belonged to his own church.

  1. The Long and the Short and the Tall.

    debate about one of the topics, again helping to take their minds off things. This leads to a further discussion about families; we learn about the soldier's girlfriends, wives and children. It is noticed, however, that Bamforth mentions nothing at all about his personal life, revealing a nature that does not wish to share individual stories, or is possibly jealous.

  2. “The Long and the Short and the Tall” is a play that raises important, ...

    two windows there could be a desert scene and rubble if it was being adapted to be set during the current situation in Afghanistan. Of the entire set there is only one thing that I would keep and that is the wooden veranda outside the hut.

  1. The play 'The Long, The Short and the Tall', is set in the Malayan ...

    This shows that he is a bully because he verbally abuses Evans. Bamforth indicates that he is a racist character as he only abuses the other soldiers about where they are from, an example of this is when he calls Corporal Johnstone a, 'Scotch Get', Also when they capture the

  2. What is the Significance of the prisoner in'The Long The Short and The Tall?" ...

    He is the one who realises that the Japanese soldier is a human being, that he has a wife and children and he sees him as not just as an enemy P.O.W. At first Bamforth was totally the opposite. He was aggressive towards the Japanese prisoner and was willing to kill him along with Johnstone, using the bayonet.

  1. Discuss the role of the character Bamforth and how he changes in the play ...

    The prisoner was called "short arse", and was sadistically ordered around to amuse himself and uses the prisoner to demonstrate his ability to "talk the lingo natural". The prisoner was treated like a circus animal; to him, "it's only the same as carving up a pig".

  2. Discuss the ways in which Willis Hall conveys the effects of war in 'The ...

    Also he says "I wasn't meant to be a hero" This further shows how he dislikes war and the thought of fighting the Japanese. He starts bullying to Whitaker to take his mind off the war. When they hear the Japanese voice on the radio Whitaker freezes with fear showing

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work