• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Were the Rebecca Riots a justifiable expression of rural discontent?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Were the Rebecca Riots a justifiable expression of rural discontent? The Rebecca Riots were a justifiable expression of rural discontent made by the farmers. This included the smashing of tollgates and tollhouses across West Wales by angered farmers between 1839 - 1843. I believe that the riots were a justifiable expression of rural discontent to a large extent due to the status of the farmers and the huge difference between rich and poor at the time. The most important reason that contributed to the Rebecca Riots was the living conditions and working conditions of the farmers. The living conditions are described as terrible. "I entered several farm labourers' cottages.....and found them mud hovels, the floors of mud and full of holes, without chairs or tables, generally half filled with peat packed in every corner. Beds were none. In the most miserable part of St. Giles, in no part of England did I ever witness such abject poverty." T.C Foster, The Times October 1843. This source can be judged as reliable on the grounds that, it is a primary source article, written by and educated Englishman unlikely to be biased towards the Welsh. The Times, who employs T.C Foster is unlikely to support lies or biased opinions in their articles as they are a reputable broadsheet newspaper. We also get a comparison to known poor areas. ...read more.

Middle

This source is reliable even though it was told by a farmers wife, it was told under oath and recorded so wouldn't have been changed. Mary Thomas was obviously looking out for her own interest, but the source was given under oath so she is unlikely to lie. The farmers desperately tried to stay financially okay as the only financial relief they could get was to go into the workhouse. This was under the poor law amendment act 1834. This was despised as families were split up, people were treated harshly with disrespect and made to complete pointless tasks such as braking stones. "Agricultural labourers arrive at starvation point rather than apply for poor relief, knowing that if they do so they will be dragged into the union workhouse." The Times 1843. The depression in agriculture made the times even more unbearable for the farmers. In 1830s there was a poor harvest which was part of the agricultural depression. There was a fall for the demand of agricultural produce which caused a decrease in price. At this time there was an agricultural revolution in England, which did not arrive in Wales. The Welsh farmers who could not communicate with the English because of the language difference were too poor to afford the machinery and methods of farming. ...read more.

Conclusion

A: "No, I do not think they are" This source gives the impression that the Welsh are fussing over nothing, and that they have the same conditions as the English. But the poverty of the Welsh was not taken into account. Bullin has given the image that nothing was wrong because of his bias so this source is not reliable. The Commission of enquiry found that, "The chief grounds of complaint were the mismanagement of funds, the frequency and the amount of tolls and in some cases the conduct of the toll collectors." D. Egan also says, "The report also criticised the ignorance of the Welsh language." The commission made "Firm recommendations for reforming the turnpike trusts including the introduction of equal tolls and the setting up of Road Boards to take control of the roads." These recommendations became law in August 1844. Through this essay I have concluded that there are a number of factors that caused the farmers to riot. These included poverty, agricultural depression, the farmers' relationship with the land owners and the tollgates. No one would listen to the farmers' pleas so they were forced to take the law into their own hands. The riots stopped after the Commission when the farmers could voice their opinions. This proves that the "Rebeccaites" were justified in their actions and that the Rebecca Riots were a justifiable expression of rural discontent. James Middleton 11SW 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Production - Location & Change section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Production - Location & Change essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The Scott Report and the Making of the Modern Countryside - 'How penetrating was ...

    5 star(s)

    "The result was the impoverishment of many farmers."ii To meet low prices farmers endeavoured by one means or another to reduce their costs. "It was, therefore, only natural that in seeking to reduce costs one of the first steps that farmers took was to reduce their wages bill by cutting

  2. The Role and Importance of Agriculture In the Carribean. Organisations involved in its ...

    Physical forms of fertilizers * Salts * Pellets * Liquid Soluble forms of fertilizers * Quick release - very soluble form * Slow release - Fertilizer grade Commercial fertilizers are manufactured to contain a precise quantity. The is shown on the container by number which show the grade e.g. 14-28-14.

  1. Case Study of Rural Rebranding by the Forestry Commission in Wales Coed-Y-Brenin Forest, Snowdonia

    The stakeholders are: 1. Legal Shareholders 2. Environment Agency 3. CCW (Countryside Council for Wales) 4. Water Boards 5. National Park 6. County Council 7. Local Council 8. Timber Traders 9. Visitors 10.

  2. Industrial Revolution.

    The resources had run out, only one coal-mine remained working and the many small works in the valleys had closed down, causing huge social problems. The new works were integrated steel works, which imported their raw materials from abroad. These aimed to make the industry more efficient and competitive in a growing world market.

  1. Industrial Change in South Wales The Reasons for the Original Location of the Iron ...

    it is the transfer of control of the steel industry in the UK (British Steel), from the government to the private sector. In the past the steel industry has been supported by state subsidies from the government, which have helped towards keeping the steel manufacturing plants open.

  2. The historical rural development of China.

    Unfortunately, it was not until the communist uprising under Mao Zedong in the 1940's that a nation crippled by wars, revolution, and natural disasters was unified and rural economic growth finally flourished. Why did it take China until the 19th Century to achieve economic growth, while Japan experience economic growth

  1. Is Biological Pest Control Better Than Chemical Control?

    This is the tendency with most chemical pesticides: they have a tendency to become less effective, and are also harmful for other wildlife, especially humans. The manufacturers need to recover the costs of developing the pesticide quickly as the pesticide only remains effective for a limited amount of time until the pests develop genetic resistance to them.

  2. How are Africa's problems of poverty, hunger, debt and environmental deterioration inter-related?

    These questions as well as the others that the average man in the street could ask have been and are still been asked in massively important global circles and committees. There are answers available, this is not the dispute, but what is the best answer, and is the process of implementation that is so problematic.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work