Welfare State - Healthcare Provisions

Authors Avatar

Barry Fotheringham – December 2008  

This essay will explore the changing attitudes of society, within a healthcare context, towards the poor and people with disabilities.  It will examine the impact of progressive legislation and how welfare provision has changed from 1971 to the present date.  The effect of these changes on how the poor and disabled are viewed and treated will also be analysed.

Healthcare is defined as “The prevention, treatment, and management of illness and the preservation of mental and physical well-being through the services offered by the medical and allied health professions.” (medical-dictionary, 2008).  This essay will closely examine the key changes, through both social advancement and legislative modifications, from the specific perspective of the impact on those with low incomes or disabilities.

Before looking at these key changes from 1971, it will be appropriate to provide context in the form of a brief overview of how the healthcare arena looked in earlier years and how the poor and disabled were treated.  Prior to the creation of the National Health Service in 1948, low-paid working men had to pay each week for a ‘panel’ doctor and this deal did not provide hospital care, with hospitals charging all users for access to services.  Women and children had to pay to see a doctor, usually laying the money on the desk as they walked in (dh, 2008).

The National Health Service signalled a revolution in healthcare provision.  People were able to access medical assistance as a basic right rather than by the previous criteria of affordability.  The establishment of antibiotics, the development of anaesthetics and increased surgical expertise all contributed to much more effective treatment of previously serious conditions.

Those in poverty in the mid to late nineteenth century were regarded as being the architects of their own misfortune.  They were considered lacking in morals and possessing a lack of Christian discipline, leading to drinking, gambling and promiscuity (Horner, 2007).  Furthermore, Charity Organisation leaders believed that deterrent Poor Laws were the answer and that financial provision by the state should be resisted.  For the first half of the twentieth century, older people had very limited options for financial stability and working class elders usually lived in extreme poverty.  They were often placed in workhouses and, if too infirm to work, were left unoccupied day after day in bleak conditions.

Disabled people around the time of the Industrial Revolution, in the early nineteenth century, were regarded as a social and educational problem.  They were increasingly segregated in institutions such as asylums, workhouses and special schools (Oliver, 1990).  Legislation such as the 1808 Lunacy Act and the 1845 Lunatics Act increased the focus on institutionalisation (Horner, 2007) and the language of the time, with the common use of terms such as ‘idiot’, ‘feeble-minded’ and ‘unproductive’, is highly indicative of the attitudes that prevailed.

Against this historical backdrop, an analysis can be made of how welfare provision has changed.  Particular focus will be given to the period from 1971 until the present time and relevant milestone legislation will be covered.  Social practices and attitudes also change as a result of factors outside of legislation and this too will be examined.

Join now!

Healthcare provision in the 1970s was subject to many positive developments.  General Practitioners began to move to group practices that included nurses and support staff (dh, 2008).  This improved access to health services in the community, particularly benefiting those who struggled with travel costs associated with visiting hospitals that were often some distance away.  It also provided more local provision for those with disabilities, with home visits becoming more readily available.  

Family planning services were introduced and the contraceptive pill became widely available, regardless of marital status.  This gave more options, and professional advice, to women who ...

This is a preview of the whole essay