• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“How significant was Bismarck in securing the unification of Germany 1862 – 1871?”

Extracts from this document...


Year 12 AS Coursework Bismarck and the Unification of Germany c. 1848 - 71 Question 2 (50 marks) "How significant was Bismarck in securing the unification of Germany 1862 - 1871?" To credit Otto von Bismarck with uniting Germany throughout the period of 1862 to 1871 seems absurd, given his "contempt for nationalism and liberalism"(i). However, there are several perspectives on which a historian can view the events leading up to the eventual unification of Germany, all with differing attitudes towards exactly how attributable Bismarck was for the unification of the German states. The focus of this essay is, bearing all of these viewpoints in mind, to analyse Bismarck's motives and intentions behind his decisions from 1862 to 1871 as well as other factors, and to present them from the differing viewpoints with the intention of assessing the importance of his contribution to the eventual unification of Germany. The Bismarckian interpretation is one mostly advocated by modern historians such as Gall and Craig, Bismarck in his memoirs of 1890, and also by statements made by ministers of the time: Disraeli was told by Bismarck of his plans to "attack Denmark in order to get Schleswig-Holstein; he will put Austria out of the confederation." ...read more.


The manoeuvre to aid Russia in the Polish revolt was more self-preservation than anything else; practically speaking, Bismarck sealed off the borders with Poland to prevent the riots spreading to Prussia and its lot in Poland. It is quite possible that Bismarck was first and foremost a pragmatist, with the aim of expanding Prussian territory as much as possible but with events leading, quite accidentally, to the unification of Germany - similar in many ways to Cavour in Italy. His decisions in Schleswig-Holstein again could be interpreted as a move to prevent it's independence, as this would prove a formidable barrier to annexation. While it is difficult to argue Bismarck did not in some way pre-plan this - many decisions made by Bismarck indicate he was antagonising Austria into war - the logical reason for his doing so is more in line with his own 'realpolitik' ideals than the romanticist notions he ridiculed. As Michael John states in The Unification of Germany, "Bismarck's only clear policy was his determination to prevent any attempt by the Austrians to reassert their leadership of the German States. Bismarck certainly entertained the idea of a united 'Kleinduschland' under Prussian domination, but he was not committed to fighting a war to make this possible." ...read more.


His statesmanship and ability to manipulate the political and international situation of the time are undeniable, but the factors he was not able to foresee and prepare for are evidence that Bismarck had not masterminded the entire series of events, and could not be credited for them except if to congratulate his 'strategy of alternatives'. It could be argued that his significance in unifying Germany stretched only as far as his ability to facilitate current events to successfully secure the next - for example, had Austria had won the war against Prussia, there would have been little hope for the creation of a North German Confederation and France would never have intervened. Bismarck was ostensibly the most important factor in the unification of Germany in 1871 - of course, Prussia was gaining strength and the international situation was ripe for a change in the balance of power, but it took the Prussian minister-president to utilise these individual factors for the eventual formation of a united Germany, whether it was his original intention or not. (i) Whitfield, Germany 1848 - 1914 (ii) Michael John, The Unification of Germany (iii) Breuilly, The First German Unification, 1847-71 (iv) Smith, Bismarck's planning of German Unification (v) Breuilly, The First German Unification, 1847-71 (vi) AJP Taylor, The Struggle for Mastery in Europe (vii) Whitfield, Germany 1848 - 1914 (viii) Michael John, Early Modern History ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Why did Prussia rather than Austria lead the unification of Germany?

    John Merriman explains Realpolitik to be the 'pursuit of a nation's self-interest based on a realistic assessment of the costs and consequences of an action'.8 Inherent within this idea is an absence of moral or ethical considerations, and this is precisely what Bismarck used to ruthlessly exploit and engineer his rival's weaknesses to Prussian advantage.

  2. What were the obstacles to German Unification immediatly before the 1848 Revolutions

    foolish to come into conflict with the Habsburgs, so while Austria was oppose to unification was impossible. Another obstacle to German Unification in the beginning of 1848 was the power of Austria and Prussia, I have already said why they were so powerful, these two states worked in a state

  1. Asses the importance of Bismarck to German unification

    They had a quick victory and Bismarck signed a settlement that let Prussia govern Schleswig, and Austria Holstein. The end result of this was that Prussia looked like the defender of Germany and Austria like a greedy land grabber. As time went on Austria and Prussia began to argue over occupation rights.

  2. To what extent was German Unification driven by primarily economic forces?

    government to fund the army reforms; economics enables the unification of Germany. A strong economy also enables the purchase of better weapons and new technologies for the state. For example the Prussians were able to afford the new 'Needle Gun' designed in 1841 and they could also afford cutting edge artillery produced by the Krupp's steel works in Essen.

  1. To what extent was Bismarck responsible for German unification?

    He held off Italy, which Bismarck planned, defeated Austria. In the treaty were the terms that Austria was to take no further part in German affairs which Bismarck needed in his unification plans step towards another major step towards the formation of the northern German confederation in the treaty.

  2. Stalins leadership was the most significant reason for the Soviet victory over Germany in ...

    The five year plans introduced after 1929 were designed to strengthen the Russian economy and the third five year plan introduced in 1938 running only for three years prepared Russia for war. As war approached, more resources were put into developing armaments, tanks and weapons, as well as constructing additional military factories east of the Ural Mountains.

  1. 'Stalin's leadership was the most significant reason for Soviet victory over Germany in the ...

    Also by the end of the war there were many different nationalities about. The ones seen as traitors were deported to places such as Kazakhstan and Siberia. Also many Cossacks were executed in 1945 as they were seen to support Germany.

  2. How far do you agree that Cavour made the most significant contribution to Italian ...

    His conquests of Sicily and Naples were a worrying development for Cavour who was deeply suspicious of Garibaldi?s republican and democratic views. Garibaldi?s intervention in the south forced Cavour to complete the unification process. Cavour now took the view that if Italy was going to be unified it would be

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work