• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyze the view that US military intervention in Vietnam was more a necessity than a tragic error.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Gabby Tolkin-Rosen Analyze the view that US military intervention in Vietnam was ?more a necessity than a tragic error?. The view that US military intervention in Vietnam was ?more a necessity than a tragic error? is an orthodox standpoint, the view that US military intervention was necessary may have been perceived by the Americans at that time to be correct because of America?s policy of ?containment? and in addition to this, the prestige America invested into the war in Vietnam. However, the lack of benefit Vietnam offered America, America?s blurring of Russian communism and Vietnamese ?nationalism? as well as the extremely taxing effects of the war allow for the conclusion that military intervention in Vietnam was in fact, a tragic error. During the Vietnam War, America?s initial policy of ?limitation? proved unsuccessful, thus America?s role and consequently their military involvement increased dramatically in the area. The fact that this policy of limitation was adopted in the first place shows that Vietnam was at first not considered a necessity, however as America became more and more involved in the war, so did the importance of military intervention in Vietnam. The American?s perceived military intervention in Vietnam as necessary due to the American policy of ?containment?. ...read more.

Middle

In addition to this, Vietnam was seen as a test of America?s reliability as well as a chance to uphold its promise to protect all ?Free nations? of the world. Military intervention in Vietnam was further seen as necessary in fixing America?s reputation after its loss of China, this was seen as an opportunity for America not to make the same mistakes as they did in China, and therefore take a hardline approach in its dealings with Vietnam to assure they could not be blamed (due to lack of military involvement) for losing another Asian state to communism. Military involvement was further seen as necessary to the Americans as they underestimated the power of the Vietminh, due to this America held the belief that they would win the war because of their superiority in air and firepower, this confidence expressed in the speech that highlighted the belief that America was winning the war in Vietnam, through their approach of ?calculation? ,nspired the continuation of military involvement in Vietnam. In addition to this, military intervention was necessary because the Americans did not trust the South Vietnamese to do the job of safeguarding capitalist policy in Vietnam. ...read more.

Conclusion

The impotency of American military intervention affirms that military intervention was in fact a mistake; this is due to America?s misunderstanding of the context of the war and of the Vietcong and Vietminh. The blurring of Soviet communism with Asian nationalism by the Americans not only caused them to act in extremities but also disallowed them to take into consideration that the Vietminh were undeterred by all their efforts(such as their bombing raid) as they were fighting for a cause. The war and the military devotion of the Americans was deemed as an error because of its ultimate insignificance towards the outcome of the war as they did not know how to approach guerrilla warfare, and instead treated it as a conventional warfare case. Therefore, the US military intervention in Vietnam may have been seen by the Americans to be necessary in the containment of communism as well as in affirming Americas reputation as a leading power, however, US military intervention in Vietnam seem as a tragic error due to the extreme losses America suffered both economically and in casualties for a cause that held no true benefit for the Americans (natural recourse-wise). Furthermore, intervention was seen as an error due the lack of morale inspired in American soldiers and America?s misunderstanding of Vietnamese context. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. America In Vietnam, 1953-73

    Muste's group, now called the National Mobilisation Against the War. On the West Coast, organisers planned a "Stop the Draft" week, focusing on the Oakland draft board. Both events involved direct confrontation with the police reminiscent of the Southern civil rights battles.

  2. The Role and Importance of the Media in Vietnam

    However, as I mentioned before, neither the television nor the written press were able to offer the American public battles they could identify with, a sense of purpose to the struggle. In the protracted war the VC were fighting, all television could present was a series of "continuous and seemingly

  1. Free essay

    Do you consider military intervention in Africa as successful? Focus on the policies in ...

    The idea that colonial territories were entitled to become independent, following an election in which rivals for the control of its post-independence government competed for support from indigenous voters, has formed the bedrock for the creation of the African state system and, in most cases, its implementation has been completely unproblematic.

  2. Assess the reasons why American military intervention in Vietnam increased from 1954

    Between 1953 and 1957 over $1 billion of US economic and military aid poured into South Vietnam but Diem failed to achieve the hoped for stability. Much of the problem rested with Diem himself, a vain and corrupt leader whose rule was characterised by nepotism, persecution of religious sects, bribery, corruption and a lack of reform.

  1. US Policy towards Vietnam 1960-73

    He then was surrounded by a group of Buddhist monks and nuns who poured petrol over his head and then set fire to him. While this elderly monk was burning to death, the monks and nuns gave out leaflets calling for Diem's government to show "charity and compassion " to all religions.

  2. To what extent can it be argued that the use of guerilla warfare tactics ...

    There is a theory called the 'domino theory', which has often been regarded as one of the most prominent reasons for America's involvement. The basic idea of the domino theory is that if one country in a close grouping like South Asia 'fell' to communism then the surrounding countries would follow suit.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work