• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far do the sources support the view that the Bolsheviks won the Civil War because they had more 'popular support?' (Mawdsley "The Civil War in Russia" 1987)

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How far do the sources support the view that the Bolsheviks won the Civil War because they had more 'popular support?' (Mawdsley "The Civil War in Russia" 1987) These sources have differing views on whether the Bolsheviks won the civil war on 'popular support'. Two and five are really the only sources that agree with the statement made by Mawdsley. Source five, written by a White colonel, implies that the Whites thought the peasants supported the Reds. Therefore, they destroyed the villages which could have turned the peasants against them, causing the peasantry to be more sympathetic to the Reds. The Russian writer, Kukushkin claims that 'Hundreds of thousands of workers and peasants' were 'utterly devoted to the cause of the Revolution'. It suggests the Bolsheviks had mass support from both groups, which is strongly contradicted in sources one and eight. Source one strongly disagrees with Mawdsley and source two. ...read more.

Middle

I also think source three, Trotsky's order on desertion, disagrees with Mawdsley's statement. It implies the Bolsheviks didn't have as much support as source two indicates. Trotsky's measure of 'every soldier... who voluntarily deserts... will be shot' suggests it was a serious problem at the time. However, the sources need to be evaluated. Source two was written by a Russian historian at a time when communists were still ruling the Soviet Union. If the source wasn't a communist view, it wouldn't have been published, this makes it less reliable, as it is likely to be sympathetic towards the Bolsheviks. Also, we don't know what access he had to primary sources, to back up his opinion. The only source that agrees with source two is five, written by a White officer. Therefore he would probably have been unsympathetic towards the Bolsheviks, intentional or not. This makes the source less reliable, he is only writing about what happened at one place and there were thousands of peasant villages in Russia. ...read more.

Conclusion

He could have been exiled for being anti-Stalin, or left of his own accord. It doesn't directly state anything about the Bolsheviks winning due to support. The final source was written by a western historian, which could mean he wasn't sympathetic towards the Reds. It was written after the fall of communism in Russia, so the author wouldn't be worried about putting the Bolsheviks in a bad light. The source was written long after the civil war and we don't know what primary sources he used. This all makes the source less reliable. After reading, evaluating and weighing up all the sources, I have come to the conclusion that, overall, they tend to disagree with the Mawdsley's statement. All but two sources, disagreed with it and they weren't as reliable as I initially thought. Overall the sources that disagreed were weightier. Overall, the sources didn't give an adequate range of reasons for the Reds' victory, only source one gave other reasons for the Bolsheviks winning the civil war. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Stalins Russia, 1924-53 revision guide

    Most experienced officers had been removed or executed. * Industrial and agricultural changes had yet to take full effect; production would not reach full capacity for several years. Stalinism * Stalinism was Stalin's version of Lenin's Marxist philosophy. Some historians argue that Stalinism differed little from Lenin. They point to War Communism as an earlier version of total state control.

  2. Why Did the Bolsheviks Win the Russian Civil War?

    went against what the Bolsheviks had promised which was peace, bread and land. In protest the peasants only grew enough for themselves, however this just meant that the crops were taken and they would starve. All private trade was banned, however this introduced problems as the state trading organization was extremely chaotic and there were not enough consumer goods.

  1. How far do you agree that the Bolsheviks won the Civil War of 1918-1921 ...

    Not only were there different ideologies between the nationalities and the Whites but also within the white army itself. The White army was disunited with many different groups within it fighting the Bolsheviks for different reasons. These included, Tsarists, Social Revolutionaries and liberals.

  2. Why Did The Bolsheviks Win The Civil War?

    And continuing their drive southward, in early 1920 the Bolsheviks overran Rostov (at the Black Sea). In 1920, the Red Army pushed into the Ukraine, undoing losses agreed to at Brest-Litovsk. Poland's new leaders wished to re-establish their old empire, and they sent armies into the Ukraine -- using war

  1. Vietnam war

    On the communist side, even before the Geneva Accords were signed, H� Ch� Minh had prepared to attack South Vietnam in case unification failed to take place through elections. His preparations included communication with thousands of covert communist agents in the south and the hiding of numerous weapons caches.

  2. The Bolsheviks won the civil war due to the mistakes of their opponents How ...

    The whites were made up of different political groups who all had different aims and intentions. This created tension in the white camp and also led to the whites becoming disunited. They were a coalition of different enemies of the Bolsheviks who all hated each other.

  1. Russian Revolution Sources Questions

    To get rid of the Left Opposition, Stalin had joined forces with the rightists this time over the disputes of NEP (Lenin's New Economic Policy). In early 1928 Stalin had changed his theory to end NEP in order to get rid of the Rightists.

  2. How far do you agree that the Communists won the Civil War because of ...

    Their forces were scattered with higher distances between each another, thereby preventing any kind of joint action taking place. This made it relatively easy for the Red forces to defeat them one by one. Any military success they did have were not followed up.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work