• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluating the Success and Failure of the Four Constitutions Canada Had Prior to Confederation

Extracts from this document...


FIFTH TIME'S A CHARM? Evaluating the Success and Failure of the Four Constitutions Canada Had Prior to Confederation Prior to the British North America Act of 1867, the British government made four failed attempts to govern their colonies in North America. Finally, in 1846, they got the point and gave in -- they ordered the Governors of all of their colonies to accept responsible party government. The British government no longer wanted the hassle, the cost, nor the responsibility of their colonies, because, simply put, they no longer had any use for the colonies. Britain was moving in the direction toward free trade, so the colonies would not have a favoured spot in the economy, as they did in the old mercantilist system.1 Twenty one years after the colonial secretary ordered the acceptance of responsible party government, Canada became a nation of its own -- finally, the Canadians did something the British had hoped they would do. The British North America Act was to be our constitution for over one hundred years: it lasted longer than all four of the other constitutional attempts put together. Each one of these acts, in one way or another, was intended to assimilate the French Canadiens and harmonize the colony, and each one, in turn, failed. The Royal Proclamation Act of 1763, passed shortly after the end of the Seven Years War, lasted eleven years until 1774, when the Quebec Act was passed. ...read more.


Regarding criminal cases, British law and language was still used, but regarding civil rights and property laws, Canadien law and the French language would be used. Carleton also received instructions to implement British commercial law, but he hid them and completely disregarded them.10 As a way for Carleton to buy the loyalties of the Canadiens so they would fight alongside the British in the coming Revolution, the Quebec Act failed. They stayed neutral in the fight, and as a result of this neutrality, after the revolution, Carleton became dictatorial: despite provisions in the Quebec Act that allowed the Canadiens to participate in government, they declined. Even though the Constitutional Act of 1791 has been called a "recipe for resentment and confrontation,"11 it lasted longer than the first two attempts combined: fifty years. The problem to be addressed by this act was the colonists' increasing demands for an elected representative assembly, and the problems raised by governing the two different cultures that were present: the Loyalists in the western part of the colony, and the French Canadiens in the east. There were three main components to this act. First, the colony was to be divided into two colonies: Upper Canada and Lower Canada. Second, each colony was given the right to an elected representative assembly. and third, these new assemblies were given very little real power -- in fact, they were little more than glorified debating clubs.12 One other part of the act that was quite important was the setting aside of the Crown and Clergy Reserve Lands. ...read more.


But, on the flip side of that, any problems or issues that are significant in our lives today -- such as that of the always-threatening Quebec Referendum -- can also be traced throughout our history; mistakes that we still haven't learned from, constantly injured feelings and a harbouring of a great deal of distrust. But, for better or for worse, working in the time periods they did, with the attitudes that were prevalent then, our past political leaders worked with what they had. Unfortunately, present-mindedness is difficult to escape, making the ability to maintain an objective point of view almost impossible. Hind sight is 20-20, and I think that despite the problems raised by these four acts, they should be viewed as part of the learning experiences of -- and growing pains felt by -- a young nation. ENDNOTES 1. Program 13, Canada to 1867: The Founding Societies (Toronto: CJRT-FM Open College, n.d.) 2. Program 6, Canada to 1867: The Founding Societies (Toronto: CJRT-FM Open College, n.d.) 3. Program 6 4. Program 6 5. Program 6 6. Program 6 7. Readings in Canadian History: Pre-Confederation, eds. R. Douglas Francis and Donald B. Smith, 5th ed. (Toronto: Harcourt Canada, 1998), 200. 8. Program 6 9. Program 6 10. Program 6 11. Graeme Wynn, "On the Margins of Empire (1760 - 1840)", The Illustrated History of Canada, ed. Craig Brown, new ed. (Toronto: Key Porter, 1997), 209 12. Program 9, Canada to 1867: The Founding Societies (Toronto: CJRT-FM Open College, n.d.) 13. Program 9 14. Program 9 15. Program 9 16. Program 9 17. Program 13 18. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The english legal system unit1 assignment3 three part question

    3 star(s)

    This is sometimes termed the soft plain meaning rule, where the statute is interpreted according to the ordinary meaning of the language, unless the result would be cruel or absurd as illustrated in Rector, Holy Trinity Church v. United States, (1892).

  2. Why was the Apprenticeship system brought to an end in 1838 in the British ...

    The fact that this Custos was given the responsibility of administration over the workhouse proved to be one of the problems of the apprenticeship system. This responsibility had mistakenly been awarded to him by Governor Sligo, and the other colonies had copied this procedure.

  1. Unmarried fathers and their children - has the law got it right?

    The act of registration is treated as an agreement between the parents, but the provision does not operate retrospectively and the court will have the power to remove parental responsibility. The Adoption and Children Act 2002 aligns adoption law with the relevant provisions of the of the Children Act 1989

  2. unit6 end of unit assignment civil litigation

    An affidavit (sworn statement) is required setting out the judgment debtor's interest in the property and the fitness of the proposed receiver. The receiver will receive the money when it becomes payable and prevent it getting into the hands of the judgment debtor * Bankruptcy and liquidation where the judgment

  1. Events leading to the American Revolution

    What the declaration is really saying, is that a society who has no or little rights should be destroyed, thus separating from England. A new society would follow, where the people of the society would have these rights necessary for self-autonomy.

  2. Changes to the Canadian Charter

    I believe "freedom of conscience" is a very vague term, and was almost removed by Prime Minister Jean Chr´┐Żtien when negotiating the Charter because of its difficulty in definition, as many of you may be also aware. I believe that one of the controversial issues present today is abortion.

  1. Advice on an incident concerning Land Registration.

    Thirdly, the welfare of any minor occupying the land subject to the trust as his home. It is likely that Ben's intention was to provide a future home for his daughter. If the property was sold the purpose of giving his daughter a home could still be met since she could still live in his new house.

  2. In English

    (b) of the Act. It could be argued that the courts have narrowed the definition of 'public authority' for the purposes of section 6 (3) (b) far beyond that which Parliament intended. In times of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation, a contracting state may take measures derogating from

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work