• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparison of three songs of Brecht's "Mother Courage and her Children" with the parados and 3rd stasimon of Sophocles' "Antigone"

Extracts from this document...


The play, "Mother Courage and her Children" was written by Bertolt Brecht in 1939 as an anti World War II play. "Antigone", by Sophocles, was written somewhere between 400 and 500 B.C and talks about the debate between family laws and state laws in the form of a popular drama. Through analyzing the three songs "The Fraternisation Song" (scene 3), "The Song of the Wise and the Good" (scene 9) and "The Song of the Hours" (scene3), it will be seen that these songs can be contrasted with the parados and 3rd stasimon of the play "Antigone". "The Fraternisation Song" is a song of caution voiced by Yvette, the camp prostitute, to the gullible Kattrin. Yvette denounces the opportunistic fa´┐Żade of love and the foolishness of belief in the higher concepts of love. In the first stanza consisting of 12 lines, Yvette portrays her deflowering by the enemy. The three types of rhyming patterns are "abcb", "aabb" and "abba". In the second stanza of 12 lines, Yvette gives us a closer look at the idiocy when she gave herself up to the camp cook and saw other girls do the same. ...read more.


"The Song of the Hours" consists of 10 stanzas of 4 lines each. The song is presented by the hapless Chaplain which talks about Jesus Christ and the Crucification. The song describes how Jesus was condemned of murder in the 1st hour by Pilate the heathen and later taken to King Hesiod. In the 3rd hour, Jesus is flogged mercilessly and the mockery of a crown made of thorns was placed on his head and a robe flung over his body. The 6th hour recounts the Crucification and Jesus' plight and his continual mockery by bandits resigned to the same fate. The scene is so cruel that even daylight looks away. In the 9th hour, Jesus gives up his soul and miracles are seen. The most interesting aspects of the song are the last two stanzas which talk about Jesus' maltreatment by the heathens who laugh at 'this simple son of man' The song, in context of the play, reminds the readers of the imminent death of Swiss Cheese who is compared to Jesus in this regard. It tells us that war reveals all the blood and gore and the ugliness of society and any semblance towards beauty is mutilated. ...read more.


The concentration of the parados is on war itself whereas the songs examine lateral themes as a consequence of war. The other point to note is the fact that there is a sight of victory and virtues like forgetfulness are broached and seen with optimism. The songs shun notions of victory and virtue. The 3rd stasimon condemns the idea of love as an unpardonable emotion which drives men to recklessness. However the contrast is seen when love is feared and given a godlike stature whereas the songs treat any semblance to virtue like dirt. Love is, clearly, laughed at. Moreover the objects of criticism are not similar as love does not entirely constitute a virtue. There is an underlying similarity seen in the 3rd stasimon and "The Song of the Wise and the Good". Virtues and love drive men and women to commit recklessness which sentence their existence to the doldrums consequently. Yvette and Antigone are clear examples. In the 3rd stasimon, love as a flaw is the object of focus whereas in the songs the idiotic behaviour is brought to light. Both the 3rd stasimon and the songs look at criticism; however the songs view the object with ridicule whereas the 3rd stasimon criticizes with unconditional reverence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Music section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Music essays

  1. LDV reflection (3rd May 2004-16th May 2004).

    We were also enlightened about the possible consequences of her actions. In all, the activities we did this fortnight had make us more aware of the environmental issues and it is amazing that even tough we had been studying this issues for more that 3 months now, we are not bored and there still many things we do not know!

  2. Critical Evaluation part 1,2 & 3

    Editing began after filming. We decided that if we took more care with framing, the shots were far more effective, for example in the studio scene where it zooms out of clock to the inside the studio. Another thing was the mugging scene. It was supposed to be done during the day but ended up being filmed in the evening with poor lighting.

  1. Performance Appraisal on the three pieces I have studied - Running Over Town-Terry Popple, ...

    The links between my performance piece and the others that I have studied is that they all use rim clicks throughout the song to enhance the sound of the piece. This is also a performing technique that is required to give the desired effect while playing the piece.

  2. The Grimm Brothers "Snow White: A Tale of Terror".

    The step mother is looking out of the window as a thunder storm starts. A sign of a thunder storm starting gives the step mother a evil edge as the audience may think that she started it. When the pouch is placed on the table the camera focuses on the pouch.

  1. An Investigation Into The Linguistics Of Football Songs

    These two songs are non-regional, as they do not stem from one particular community, but are heard in the majority of football grounds. Northerners and Southerners have a long-lasting traditional rivalry against each other due to occupational background and the ideology that Southerners 'look down their nose' at Northerners.

  2. Comparing Disneys’® Beauty & the Beast and Mulan

    Shang Li and his men have only one rocket. We see him, Shang Li, then trying to fire the rocket into the Hun army whilst saying, "we'll take out as many as we can...".

  1. Festival Experiences It was the weekend my mother and father had been preparing for ...

    "Just relax and appreciate the beauty of the countryside. Take a breath in Keith" my mother says. The dog is leaning half way out of the window over my fathers shoulder. He doesn't look relaxed with Beauty out large German shepherd draped over him. "Why don't we all go for a walk with Beauty?"

  2. Mira Nair describes 'Monsoon Wedding' as

    involvement from the viewers, in scenes such as family discussions, which breaks down barriers for viewers who do not understand Hindi or Punjabi, the main spoken languages, despite subtitles. Contrasts once again between the two conflicting cultures are shown through Nair's use of colour, as well as lighting.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work