• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare two Sci-fi films from different decades; 'The day the Earth stood still' (1951) and 'Independence Day' (1996)

Extracts from this document...


Compare two Sci-fi films from different decades; 'The day the Earth stood still' (1951) and 'Independence Day' (1996). Describe and account for the major differences and similarities between them. The Day the Earth stood still and Independence Day were both made by 20th century fox. This company used to be one of the main 5 in the 50's, and is a well - known conglomerate company, recognised for their Sci-fi genre. Star wars and X-files are two other of their best-known productions. The institution that made the films is one similarity; the main difference in the films is the historical context. 20th century fox made 'The Day the Earth stood still' in the 1950's, the decade in which sci-fi films were at their peak. It was post world war 2, where people first had to live with the reality of nuclear wars and the end of the world. This was also the time of the Cold War 'stand off' between the communists and the West. ...read more.


For example, the title sequences are very similar to each other, with spaceships coming to Earth, however Independence Day almost mocks the sci-fi genre. There is simple camera work and special effects in The day the Earth stood still, unlike the technological advances used in Independence day. Both films use the typical mis en scene of spaceships, aliens, and eerie music, however Independence Day does not need to use as much as the genre is already established and people find it easy to recognise. Independence Day uses the aliens as evil beings, whereas the aliens in The day the Earth stood still come in peace and are only forced to fight when the Americans use violence on them. Due to its historical context The day the Earth stood still uses stereotypical representations of gender, age and race, such as weak women, boisterous boys, the representation of the British, Indian and French characters. It is very male dominated with only one female character in the film, a mother. ...read more.


Independence day is a good example of Propps theory of basic situations and characters. The audience is similar in each film, they are both films aimed at men, sci-fi enthusiasts, cinema goers etc. The Day the earth stood still would have been made entirely for people to watch in the cinema meaning the audience would have been sat there watching it, however when 20th century fox made independence day they knew that the film would be watched on other formats such as DVD or video. This meant that they had to draw in the audience so that they would not turn over the channel or change the video. A good example if the way they have done this is by making the title sequence shorter and placing the credits at the end. 20th century fox have succeeded in recycling an old genre using modern methods and concepts, by altering the narrative to make two completely different stories, yet very similar movies. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sophie Curtis Media Studies Essay ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Films section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Films essays

  1. American History X - Concepts from Chapter 8

    His racial beliefs were reinforced when his father was murdered by a black man while in the line of duty. This extreme situation combined with the worsening of his community by people of minority fueled Derek with hatred. At that time he had only seen the good in the white man and the evil in minorities.

  2. What reasons are there for films to be remade?

    In comparison to the original where the money was being stolen directly from the authority figures, which changes the ideological focus of the film from straight forward stealing to revenge. This shows a change in society's attitudes towards stealing, and shows that it is now less tolerated and unacceptable than the historical period when the first 'Italian Job' was made.

  1. Discuss some of the similarities and differences between Independence Day and War of the ...

    This film is a lot more involved with the government rather than the family aspect, unlike War of the Worlds. However, there are elements of romance during Independence Day, as one couple gets married and the second couple who broke up before the film started, hold hands and we see

  2. Many violent films are box office hits. What is so good or bad about ...

    Whether the violence in films is presented as a good or a bad act, it is very rare, if ever that the film shows the consequences of the acts of violence. This theory suggests that inhibitions about violent behaviour are broken down due to the fact that it goes unpunished in films on the most part.

  1. Question: Compare how genre and narrative are established in 2 crime films

    It was huge in the USA and the UK and because of its critical response, Ocean's Twelve (2004) is in pre-production. We can make the assumption that this film too will be a high concept. The Bone Collector was originally released in the UK on 14th January 2000.

  2. Looking at two films studies, compare and contrast their representation of the future (Planet ...

    Mankind has destroyed itself, all the scientific and technological development has caused civilisation to go backwards, possibly as a result of it falling into the wrong hands. To show the common ethos of The Matrix and POTA, the two films should be compared to another couple of films from within

  1. Movie villains article.

    The initial success of the movie was based on the audience's terror of nightmares and insecurity, for we are never sure whether the characters are dreaming or not due to the fact that the line between nightmare and reality is blurred.

  2. Analysis of the Representation of Ethnic Minorities in "Training Day" and "Se7en"

    Despite this, in 1964 the first black actor Sidney Poitier won an Oscar for his performance in ?Lilies of the fields? and was not portrayed as one of the five preset characters. He is a ?Jack of all trades? and helps a group of nuns.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work