• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Political Power

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'A gets B to do something that he or she would not otherwise do'. Does this sum up the essence of political power? "Political analysis can be defined quite simply as the analysis of the nature, exercise and distribution of power."1 This argument is criticised of being too broad, excluding almost nothing, nevertheless it is reasonable to argue that power is the central theme which lies throughout the study of politics. Therefore defining the concept of power is one of the crucial things in the study of politics consequently it is often contested and can never be agreed among the scholars. This essay will focus on so-called the 'faces of power' controversy in the post war period. First of all, the idea which consists of the first and basic part in interpreting power will be introduced. Then what its critiques argue and their flaws will also be discussed to draw the conclusion how far the argument 'A gets B to do something that he or she would not otherwise do' reflects the essence of power. The 'faces of power' debate was raised from different theoretical traditions and approaches to political analysis. Basically the argument is about whether the concept of power is simple and quantifiable or it is rather complicated and intuitive concept which cannot be measured. Lukes2 acknowledges that this concept can never be settled. ...read more.

Middle

Moreover, it does not take the potential power into account. In this manner, the power which is not exerted cannot be regarded as power. For instance, some business groups would not be concerned with the welfare issues until they realise the increased burden for welfare tax. Then it might be possible for them to begin exercising their power which has not been exercised without any explicit need for it. Also as assumed from its name, it only uncovers 'one face of power' ignoring other circumstances "in which decisions are prevented from happening, the area of non-decision-making."4 This gave a rise to the second face of power argument by Bachrach and Baratz. According to their view, power should be understood as agenda-setting which is the two dimensional approach. "Power might be manifested not only in doing things but also in ensuring that things do not get done."5 What they basically insist is that power is exercised in choosing what should be involved in formal discussion and what should not be. In other words, who holds the power needs to be understood in agenda-setting process before the actual decision-making process. In this way, they have broadened the boundary in the concept of power. This kind of approach is well shown in the liberal democratic system where parties are seen as the medium of representing a particular preference on issues. ...read more.

Conclusion

'real' need, without a standard of truth against which to judge them."9 In this sense this debate become meaningless since there is no scientific method which to prove and make an absolute judgement over this. Furthermore it is contested that nobody is capable of distinguishing the autonomous decision based on real interests and the one based on felt interests being manipulated from powerful. To conclude, the debate over the concept of power has been developed from the shallow one dimensional understanding to a more intuitive and complex three dimensional one. It cannot be said that the effort of developing it into more sophisticated form has always been successful. However through this process, it is true to say that the concept of power has been understood from various approaches which enabled better understanding. Nevertheless the important point to note is that the latter has never attempted to replace or deny the former approach since no single argument can define the political concept of power by its own. Rather, it has its root in the former argument and tries to make it more convincing. From this point of view, power is definitely something which enables 'A gets B to do something that he or she would not otherwise do'. Therefore on one hand, it is possible to say that the essence of power lies in this argument to a certain extent but there can be plural ways depending on approaches in doing so. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. The Productivity of Colonial Power

    The contact zone was the crucible of hybridity. The disintegrating 'civilised/uncivilised' binary was just one example of how the material arrangements of the colonies were challenging the 'latent' binaries which underwrote so much of the ideology. In India, the assimilation of certain educated native castes into the colonial apparatus was a movement from 'other' into 'self.'

  2. The study of international or rather global politics, seeks to provide an account of ...

    State sovereignty and domestic security (i) Thomas Hobbes In Thomas Hobbes' work, The Leviathan (1652), he presents a strong case for the necessity of a powerful centralised political authority. Hinsley (1986:141) claims that Hobbes' work was the first clear formulation of the concept of sovereignty in English political thought.

  1. Legacies of the totalitarian system and the political transformation of Romanian society after 1989.

    In the Leninist analysis, representative democracy as seen in the West is a "joke" because the real reins of power are held by the rich class, who would simply ignore the results if an unacceptably radical leader was ever elected.

  2. Ideology Of Political Facism

    Fascists modify conventional history to create a vision of an ideal past. These mythical histories claim that former national greatness has been destroyed by such developments as the rise of powerful business groups, the mixing of races, and a loss of a shared national sense.

  1. How have political sociologist understood globalization? Globalization is perhaps the central concept of ...

    resistance to the centrifugal force of capitalist globalization. This more robust view of the 'power of identity' is one to which anyone surveying the dramatic rise of social movements based around identity positions (gender, sexuality, religion, ethnicity, nationality) might easily subscribe.

  2. Europe post WW1

    The coal and iron lost was because the treaty also gave France the right to coal-mine in the Saar region. The Secret Treaty of London, signed in 1915, in which Italy was promised land for joining the Entente Powers, though Italy never received it.

  1. Photomontage in Berlin, A critical study of the capitals inter-war artwork

    The image has three clear composites, taking up a specific area of the picture. Previous photomontages by Heartfield were much more erratic and Dada like, with lots of objects in a muddle together. This showed the potential for Photomontage in politics.

  2. The relationship between censorship and student publications by specifically drawing on the Rabelais case

    Judicially-considered concepts underpinning political communication6 is often subject to the maintenance and protection of the system of representative government.7 By strict adherence to this generalization, virtually all political dissent and civil disobedience is then liable to interfere with the maintenance and protection of the government system.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work