• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent can Ramsay MacDonald be considered a Traitor to the Labour Party?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent can Ramsay MacDonald be considered a Traitor to the Labour Party? There is no doubt that MacDonald was a traitor to his party but he wasn't a traitor to the nation. He wanted to make what he considered the best decision in the long term for the good of the nation as a whole, the debate is more about why MacDonald betrayed his party than whether or not he did. There are two opposing theories on how MacDonald should be remembered, one that suggests that MacDonald was not a traitor due to his long standing devotion to the labour party. The differences he has made to it and it's profile over the years that he was leader, and that the policy that divided the labour party was 'the best solution in the circumstances', and the necessity for him to put nation over party left him little choice the view shared by Robert Pearce, Austen Morgan, Marquand and Kenneth O. Morgan. MacDonald had a bad end even though he did a lot for the labour party, he was unlucky to be involved at the time. Other historians such as AJP Taylor, dismiss his decision to follow the idea of unemployment benefit cuts as a betrayal of Socialist ideals, and believe he should have gone down fighting for Socialism, MacDonald put country over party leading to a rift within labour thus he betrayed them. ...read more.


They felt that if the policy of unemployment benefit was necessary then it should be introduced by other parties, otherwise they would be betraying 'their people', the unemployed. The labour party didn't want to put their name to a policy that went against the people that they were representing. In their eyes he should not do anything to harm the base of their party even if it means loosing office. They were the people who supported them in the election so they shouldn't be the ones burdened when trying to save the economy. If Labour did make cuts in Unemployment benefit it would mean that the Trade Unions would also stop supporting labour, something that MacDonald had wanted from sometime. "His decision to make the Labour Party a national rather than a Trade Union or class party" MacDonald had made it common knowledge in the past that he wanted Labour to become independent from the trades unions allowing them to follow policy that they believed was in their interests and not that of the unions. The issue that is prompted by this argument, is that if MacDonald had had an ulterior motive he gained little from the outcome, "If indeed he betrayed the labour party, his rewards were singularly few" Written by AJP Taylor in his book, "British Prime Ministers and other Essays", Taylor is likely to be critical of the Labour party in general due to his past involvement with them. ...read more.


nation and party, conscience and popularity, right and wrong in his mind, he chose the nation and to do the correct thing in his mind, thus betraying the party that he had devoted so much to. He was unlucky to be in the situation that he was in, he stood by what he believed was right and didn't give in. The rest of the Labour Party also saw that they could not resolve the problems of the country they were a relatively young party, and many had little experience in office. Although few believed that MacDonald was wrong in what he wanted it was on principle that the cabinet voted against him. Believing that if the Labour Party were to act, which they had to, they should go down fighting for socialism. Overall, MacDonald was a founder of the labour Party and thus cannot be considered as a traitor. He couldn't find an alternative and felt that the only opportunity that there was, was to implement the benefit cuts. He did betray the socialist ideas but he did what he felt he had to do therefore he was a traitor to the Labour party as a whole yet he was such an important factor in the success of the party that to some extent he can be forgiven for his judgement of the situation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

3 Stars - This essay demonstrates strong command of the subject, wider reading and good critical vocabulary. A fair and appropriate conclusion is implicitly reached following ongoing evaluation throughout the essay.
The weaknesses in the essay are in it's structure and organisation - there is little evidence of a logical plan: points do not logically follow on from each other, there is considerable repetition of general points and at times it lapses into narrative above analysis. Also the layout of the essay is confusing and the footnotes are not applied to the main body of the piece. The essay would be clearer with a definition of key terms and setting of historical context, a paragraph on the extent to which MacDonald cannot be considered a traitor, the counter-argument and an evaluation of both sides before a conclusion is reached.

Marked by teacher Dan Carter 17/09/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Impact of government policies

    3 star(s)

    Sometimes these meetings are held outdoors and involve a march or demonstration to show the government or local authority the depth of public feeling against a decision. An example of this might be the 2009 G20 protests in London which required a police and paramedic presence as so many individuals were involved.

  2. To What Extent is conservatism an ideology?

    Traditional Conservatives have seemed to avoid creating any fixed principles and have opposed political parties and movements that have done so. Conservatism has often been described as pragmatic in that it changes its appearance and stance according to the dominant political opinion at that time.

  1. Is Britain an elective dictatorship?

    Firstly after acts like the 1911 House of Lords Act when the lord's influence over finance was ended has slowly diminished and restricted the power of the lords. Britain's membership with the EU has meant vital decisions affecting Britain being made away from parliament.

  2. The comparison of the US President and the British Prime Minister appears from the ...

    would face much more intense scrutiny than the President, as he has to face the Commons in debates and at Question Time. This may be true in theory, and has support from Adonis, but in practice debates have little influence on government policy, usually made to a sparsely attended chamber

  1. Conservatism is more a state of mind than a political ideology

    Conservatives' also believe that without this interconnecting society the individual is left with a weakening of values and normative rules associated with feelings of loneliness and meaninglessness, this is the opposite to the liberal view of a mechanistic society. Conservatives also have a strong belief in tradition.

  2. Some differences and similarities between the Australian and United States federal legislatures

    Representatives are elected from districts. Senators are elected by all the voters in a state. Some Similarities Members in the House of Representatives represent electorates or districts. Each electorate elects one person. Each electorate has approximately the same number of voters (except Tasmania in Australia).

  1. Assess how successful the Ulster Unionist Party has been in challenging the dominance of ...

    The Orange Order formally cut its links with the Ulster Unionist Party, ending 100 years of historical ties. There was also the reform of the Party?s Youth wing, where they tried to appeal to younger voters. This is called the Ulster Young Unionists and it is where Arlene Foster started out ? although she has since defected to the DUP.

  2. From what extent does the UK suffer from a participation crisis?

    Young people, in particular, are attracted to this type of participation, many buying products such as ?fair trade? coffee and boycott the ?Deepwater Horizon oil spill? in 2011. Other indicators of political activity, such as attending a political demonstration, the potential for protest has definitely grown in importance.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work