It could be argued that the effects of privation are reversible if good quality care is given?

Authors Avatar by lokoko (student)

Moshorof Ali

It could be argued that the effects of privation are reversible if good quality care is given?

Privation is when a child is never able to form attachments and bonds; it can have extreme negative effects on all areas of development both physical and mental.

The case of Genie would argue that the effects of privation is not reversible, a case of a girl kept isolated in her room until the age of thirteen with her only contact with humans being beatings whenever she would make noise. When she was found Genie had no grasp of language and walked with a stoop. Over time with the doctors and researchers Genie was able to develop basic vocabulary and general. She also began to show curiosity and the desire to improve her vocabulary, often pointing to objects and asking for their names and eventually was able to use her vocabulary to describe past events. However, when she was eventually taken into the care of a foster family Genie was abused and beaten for vomiting which resulted in regression to a former level of vocabulary and socialisation, rarely speaking.

Join now!

This case study would suggest problems with the development of severe privation, however it could be said that the age at which she was rehabilitated was also a major cause of her poor progress. There is also evidence that she was progressing until she was abused again which would suggest that it was the abuse and not the privation which caused her lack of development, also it was said that she could have been retarded at birth.

However the case study of two children in Czechoslovakia gives a vastly different set of results. Twin boys were locked in their basement ...

This is a preview of the whole essay