• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

From the religion you have studied, discuss the view that religious ethics must be either deontological or teleological but cannot be both.

Extracts from this document...


2. From the religion you have studied, discuss the view that religious ethics must be either deontological or teleological but cannot be both. Deontological ethics rely on the concept of Duty. They are based only on actions themselves and not on the outcome that will result from the action. Teleological ethics, from the Greek Teleos, meaning "end", are based on the consequences resultant from a given action. Ethical choices must be made according to what is believed to be the most beneficial outcome. Deontological ethics also tend to be absolutist. This means that they rely on a set of given rules that must be applied in all circumstances. Two examples of this are Aquinas' Natural Law theory and Kantian Ethics. Kant argues that moral duty is the only reliable argument for the existence of God. As all humans feel an obligation to fulfil their moral duty, it is this and only this that will bring them closer to God. ...read more.


Actions are intrinsically good or bad. Aquinas has a similar theory, that of Natural Law. Natural Law is also a Deontological Absolutist theory. Natural Law follows five primary precepts, from which all secondary precepts must be drawn. The five precepts are; 1. Preservation of the innocent 2. Continuation of the Species 3. Education 4. Worship God 5. Live together peacefully From these precepts, other answers can be drawn, such as do not murder, which leads onto; for example, do not abort an unborn child. Natural Law follows a set of given rules that cannot be changed despite what the consequences of these rules may be. Situation Ethics is a teleological ethical theory. This means that situation ethics, put forward by Joseph Fletcher in the 20th century, is based on the outcome of any given action. Fletcher argues that Christians should follow Jesus' theory of "Love thy Neighbour" and therefore situation ethics is based on the principle of Agape love. ...read more.


The only theory that appears to contradict this statement would be the theory of Rule Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is based on the greatest good for the greatest number principle and is therefore teleological as it relies on outcomes of situations, therefore the word "Rule" seems to be misplaced by the side of utilitarianism, yet rule utilitarianism appears to join together deontological and teleological ethics. Rule utilitarianism establishes rules, that when they are followed by the whole community will offer the best result. Rules should be followed by everyone even if they are not personally beneficial to an individual person as they will result in the best outcome for the whole society. The element of teleology in this theory is that it still considers the consequences of actions, yet it is partially deontological as there are given rules that apply in every situation despite the individual consequences of these rules. Overall it appears impossible to join deontological and teleological ethics as they are opposing ideas. However, Rule utilitarianism attempts to join the two and it is debatable as to whether this is successful or not. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Utilitarianism VS Kantian Deontological Ethics

    Even if it was, the calculation that would need to be made would take far too long to be achievable in time to make a decision. If Utilitarianism was to be implimented in normative circumstances without any calculations, then people would need to carry out the action that they believe

  2. Kant's theory of Ethics

    If this was applied in reality then there would be no more cases of sexual abuse for example or even slavery. This notion of treating people as ends in themselves can be seen in much of modern ethics, in particular, as part of the Human Rights Act.

  1. “Without real freedom there would be no ethical decisions to make,” Discuss.

    If we are capable of justifying them to ourselves and making them seem reasonable in our own mind, then surely we can accept the responsibility others place upon us. Peter Geach summed up a similar concept by commenting that, "If my "mortal mind" thinks I am miserable then I am

  2. Business Ethics

    These codes do not usually have legal authority. They are merely guidelines formulated over a long period. They reflect the honest desire of public officials to serve their respective communities with dignity and integrity. According to Hanekom and Thorn hill (1987:163), an ethical code has at least four main objectives:

  1. "It is impossible to reconcile any kind of determinism with the concept of freewill." ...

    A Scottish philosopher called David Hume said "By liberty, then, we can only mean a power of acting or not acting, according to the determinations of the will: that is, if we choose to remain at rest; we may; if we chose to move, we also may."

  2. A) Clarify the key features of a deontological theory of ethics

    One must also as in a way that you always treat everybody as an end in themselves and not as a means to an end, you have no right to exploit or enslave anyone for any purpose. The final maxim is 'Act as if you were through your maxims a

  1. Evaluate Korsgaard's discussion of the Universalizability Argument. In what ways does she conform with ...

    Korsgaard was able to re-pose the normative question and review our literature to answer the question. She values the notion of moral law raised by Pufendorf and Hobbes. Pufendorf and Hobbes thought that the content of morality is given by reason independently of the legislative will and that no one

  2. Examine and comment on the view that religious and/or moral principles provide essential guidelines ...

    However Dr Bernard Nathanson, joint founder of NARAL in the US admitted ?We aroused enough sympathy to sell our program of permissive abortion by fabricating the number of illegal abortions done annually in the US. The actual figure was approaching 100,000 but the figure we gave to the media repeatedly

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work