• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The world appears designed, so God exists - Discuss

Extracts from this document...


?The world appears designed, so God exists? Discuss. The claim that God exists, based on how the world seems to be designed, is known as the Design Argument. There are two main types of arguments from design, also known as the ?argument to design? so as to not assume that the world has already been designed, in the premises of the argument. They are known as the ?arguments from analogy? and the ?arguments to the best explanation?. Arguments from analogy compare certain features of the universe with similar features of designed objects. They find similarities or analogies between these designed objects and the world around us, leading to the intermediate conclusion that the world has also been designed. This then leads to the conclusion that God is the designer. However, there is also another type of argument from design which tries to follow another path to reach the conclusion that the world has been designed. These proofs begin by noticing certain, extraordinary features of the universe, such as its apparent order and purpose. Then they attempt to show that naturalistic explanations for these properties are insufficient, and that the best explanation of these features is through the existence of supernatural designer. Thomas Aquinas offers five ways in which God?s existence can be demonstrated, in his book the Summa Theologica. ...read more.


Anything which exhibits these features must design. Therefore the watch was has been designed by a designer. The universe is like the watch in that it possesses the same features, except on a far greater scale. Therefore the universe, like the watch, has also been designed, except by a ?wondrous universe maker? ? God. However, there are some criticisms to Paley?s argument, and Paley even comes up with some problems the argument may face. One criticism he comes up with is that some parts of the watch may appear to have no purpose. When Paley comes across the stone, he dismisses the stone as having no purpose straight away. Similarly if he came across a part of the watch that had no purpose, then this raises questions about the designer. Why would the designer include parts that have no evident purpose? This is comparable to the world where there are objects that seem to have no purpose such as random stones for example, and this raises questions about the ?wondrous creator?. The conclusion that the world has been designed is weakened because after all, a designer wouldn?t include pointless parts. In addition, philosopher David Hume also critiques arguments from analogy, writing thirty years before Paley. One of the main criticisms he makes is that we have no experience of world making. ...read more.


Therefore Darwin?s theory is seen as a big threat to the teleological argument, as it provides a naturalistic explanation for the existence of telos, without any reference to the concept of diving design. In conclusion, although Aquinas and Paley make a fairly good argument with the arguments from analogy, there are quite a few weaknesses to it, some of which are even pointed out by Paley. For example, from his analogy, there may be some parts of the watch that are pointless and have no purpose. Similarly there are objects in this world that appear to have no purpose, like stones, and this casts doubts on whether a being like God designed the world, because it raises the question as to why he would design and create pointless objects. Furthermore, criticisms to the analogy from design are made by philosopher David Hume. One of his main criticisms was that since we have no experience of world making, then we can?t come to the conclusion that the world was designed by God. He claims that in order to suggest something has been designed; we need to experience it being designed or manufactured, either directly or indirectly, or at least be able to compare it to something similar to it. However, in the case of the universe this is simply not possible therefore we cannot come to the conclusion that it has been designed by God, and hence God exists. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Conscience is the voice of God - discuss

    A contemporary of Mill, Catholic Cardinal John Henry Newman believed that to follow conscience is to follow a divine law as it is a messenger from God. Like Mill, he saw responsibility to God as a focal part of the function of the conscience.

  2. `I know God exists, because I have an idea of perfection Discuss whether knowledge ...

    Nevertheless, Locke's response would probably challenge this, as his bold claim, was that if you cannot trace something back to sense data, it is essentially meaningless. In this case, Locke would claim that, the presence of this 'rational intuition' cannot be traced back to an original sense impression, and must therefore be deemed meaningless.

  1. The idea of miracles is a major obstacle to faith in the modern world ...

    A favorite explanation for the dramatic parting of the red sea, which has formed a major focus for Jewish and Israelite self-understanding, is that it was the result of a huge volcanic explosion on an Island called San Terini, near Crete.

  2. Science Solves All The Problems About Where We Come From Discuss

    He was a bishop of Oxford and also led the attack against Darwin's theory, six months after he published it. He claimed, in an article in the Quarterly Review, that the theory of evolution showed a "tendency to limit God's glory in creation".

  1. How, and with what success, does Hume deal with the apparent anomaly of the ...

    The ideas can be divided into ideas of sensation (touch, smell, sight, etc.) and ideas of reflection (fear, happiness, sadness, etc.), which can then be separated further into simple and complex ideas, where complex ideas are derived from simple ones.

  2. How to create a completely peaceful world. To create a fully peaceful world, ...

    However, nowadays technology has made the geographic barrier almost be vanished. Information transfers within the world in a few seconds. People can travel to anywhere in a couple of days. The world becomes a "small village". In this "small village", every nation is competing with others for gain, safety, and reputations.

  1. Assess whether 'God exists' is a testable hypothesis.

    Essentially, Paley's view is that due to the complexity and order of the universe, it is a requirement that a supremely intelligent being must exist. That being is supposedly God. Critics would say that this is far from the truth, and that we have not empirically witnessed the presence of

  2. Is the activity of an intelligent designer the best explanation of our universe as ...

    Aquinas also argued from purpose, using the example of an arrow, stating,?..for an arrow to reach its destination it must be directed first of all by the archer..? (Wilkinson.M, 2009) arguing that everything in the universe needs to be directed in order to fulfill its purpose, indicating an intelligent designer directing the universe to sustain human life.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work