• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18

Cost effectiveness of mainstream bench cleaners against generic supermarket cleaners on the number of bacterial colonies killed

Extracts from this document...


COST EFFECTIVENESS OF MAINSTREAM BENCH CLEANERS AGAINST GENERIC SUPERMARKET CLEANERS ON THE NUMBER OF BACTERIAL COLONIES KILLED. Hypothesis: - THE MAINSTREAM BRANDED CLEANERS WILL SHOW A GREATER PERCENTAGE DECREASE IN NUMBER OF BACTERIAL COLONIES KILLED THAN THE CHEAPER SUPERMARKET CLEANERS. Null Hypothesis: - NEITHER CLEANER WILL PERFORM BETTER THAN THE OTHERS AND THEREFORE SHOW THE SAME PERCENTAGE DECREASE IN NUMBER OF COLONIES KILLED. EXTRACT The purpose of the investigation is to examine and compare a range of household work surface cleaners of different costs, in terms of their effectiveness at killing colonies of harmful bacteria on work surfaces. And whether or not you get a better cleaner for a greater financial expense. Bacteria are extracted from the surfaces in the investigations and examined against the total number of bacteria still present on the surface after one of the cleaner has been used on it. The 3 most expensive cleaners killed over 10% more bacteria than those at the cheaper end of the scale and showed almost twice the percentage decrease per penny. The reasoning behind a cleaner's ability to kill bacteria tends to favour its composing chemicals, although the cleaners tended to be closely related to each other in terms of their ingredients. The 3 best performing cleaners contained alcohols, Benzalkonium Chloride and Tetrasodium EDTA compounds. This would suggest that these are the most favourable chemicals for an effective cleaning product in the household. The worst performing cleaner was based around sodium compounds and water, along with Alkyldimethyl Amine Oxide. Putting further evidence to the ingredients and chemical make up of a cleaning being key to its performance. RATIONALE Food poisoning is a major problem at the minute and is leading to rising numbers of hospital deaths. Deaths caused by MRSA (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) and C difficile are continually increasing at alarming rates. C difficile is transmitted through poor surface hygiene and improper cleaning. ...read more.


The structure of wood also leaves it open to withholding water, providing the moisture that bacteria need to multiple. The cleaning products I have selected to use in the investigation are designed for kitchen cleaning, so I will use them where they were designed to be used, and on the kitchen apparatus which takes the most abuse and it's the one thing which is most often blamed for the transmission of bacteria into food, the kitchen chopping board. Swabbing: Mean % decrease = 66.7% Standard deviation = 33 - VERY HIGH (Higher possibility of anomalies) Contact Plates: Mean % decrease = 97% Standard deviation = 4.24 - LOW Swabbing appears to be a more viable option from the trial results obtained. This may be because that contact plates simply cannot pick up the bacteria from the surface on their own. Whereas, with swabbing, the saline may provide moisture to bring the bacteria away from the surface and the swab itself penetrates better into the texture of the surface to pick up a great number of bacterial colonies, on average swabbing pick up more colonies than using contact plates. Contact plates picked up 47 colonies initially, whereas swabbing picked up over 60. This is probably because I can swab a larger area and be more thorough in doing it than when I am using contact agar plates. From experience, a greater number of bacteria picked up initially will mean a smaller percentage error. Because of this, in my main experimental phase I will pipette saline directly onto the area being studied before I swab as the areas appear to be dry and this may be causing fewer bacteria to be picked up initially. MAIN METHOD 1. Using a removable marker or pencil, mark 10 study areas out on the chopping board. I chose to mark out 10 areas because, if I use the same areas for before and after a cleaner is applied, the initial swab may remove a large proportion of the bacteria in the area. ...read more.


It would be appropriate to test the effect of domestic soap combined with water as well as water in isolation on bacterial colonies, to clarify whether the concept of liquids kills bacteria. Many of the cleaners were almost identical in their contents and ingredients, making it difficult to draw scientific conclusions on which chemical complexes have better anti-bacterial properties. In future, it could be possible to use each of the chemical ingredients in isolation to get a true representation of the chemical differences between cleaners and their effect on their performance. Surface cleaners are aimed at killing bacteria that contaminate food and cause infections and food poisoning in humans at body temperature (34�c). I was unable to incubate at this temperature due to the college only having level 2 laboratory status throughout its science department, limiting their resources, including allowing them to culture ant incubate at temperatures up to 25�c. Some of the critical human infection causing bacteria may not grow and culture at these temperatures. They may still grow after the cleaners have been applied, meaning that my tests and experiment were not subjective to the substances being used. In future, I will need to try to acquire the ability to incubate bacteria at 34�c in order to get a truly subjective and real life test for the effectiveness of cleaners. Swabbing the surfaces may not have transferred all the bacteria from the swab onto the agar plate after it had been used to swab the bacteria up from the chopping board, having a detrimental effect on the results of the investigation, showing inaccuracies to the true value. To solve this problem next time I could swab the chopping board as normal, but then soak the swab in sterile saline to remove all the bacteria into the saline and then, after mixing up the solution for 5 minutes, pipette out and spread an amount of the saline/bacteria solution onto the agar plates. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Molecules & Cells section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Molecules & Cells essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "To Clone or Not to Clone- That is the Question".

    4 star(s)

    are studied by the governmental bioethics panel is apparently not enough to stop them. Since Dolly, the public has been holding their breath for some sign in the media of human cloning. Why is this? Why would one automatically assume that such a discovery is not far behind?

  2. Marked by a teacher

    An investigation to examine the effects of temperature on membrane stability in beetroot, by ...

    3 star(s)

    the amount of pigment that leaks out can be used to measure the permeability of the membrane. In order to find out, which situations would be best for this experiment, I carried out some preliminary work before starting the actual investigation: I needed to decide on: * Which liquid would

  1. Free essay

    Investigation into the antibacterial properties of mint and garlic.

    There is going to be some degree of error caused by the concentration of antibacterial matter on the filter paper discs; some may have absorbed more antibacterial matter than others which will provide a larger zone of inhibition. Results: Test number Diameter of zone of inhibition (mm)

  2. Investigation for the effect of disinfection on bacterial growth

    Aim: To find the optimum concentration needed to destroy E coli living on agar jelly. Prediction: As the concentration increases the number of colonies formed will decrease. I predict that as the concentration (x axis) goes up the Number of colonies counted (y axis)

  1. Catalyse Investigation

    As a precaution, I have limited my contact with the test tubes, as my body heat will raise the temperature, increasing the rate of reaction. I will also monitor the temperature using a thermometer so that I can ensure that it stays constant and does not disrupt the results of the experiment by affecting the activity of the sucrase.

  2. Before resistance to antibiotics was noticed, the use of antibiotics had to become wide ...

    The images below show Gram-stained cells of Bacillus cereus that had been cultured in the absence of penicillin (left-hand image) or in the presence of a low concentration of the penicillin derivative termed Ampicillin (right-hand image). By affecting the cross-linking of the bacterial cell wall, penicillin has caused the bacterium to grow as larger cells with less frequent cell divisions.

  1. Investigating the effect of sodium chloride on the action of antibiotics on bacteria growth

    Neutrophil and monocytes are types of white blood cells. Non specific immune response is a type of immune response that is directed at a specific pathogen. Lymphocyte is a type of white blood cell that helps defend the body against specific pathogens. The two types of lymphocyte (B cells and T cells) respond to antigen molecules on the pathogen.

  2. health and safety in the microbiology department

    Brucellosis followed work on the open bench with blood cultures from an unsuspected case. Work with Coxiella burneti, rickettsiae, Chlamydia psittaci and Francisella tularensis has long been recognized to entail a high risk of accidental infection, but no such cases were reported in the 1979-83 British survey.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work