• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the view that sociology can and should model itself on the natural sciences

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Sociology is defined as a social science, however the status as a science is questionable when compared to natural sciences such as physics and chemistry. If sociology should and can be a science depends pretty much on the definition of science and how it links together. Many sociologists disagree and take a different point of view of how sociology should be seen. So in this essay I am going to assess the view that sociology can and should be model itself on the natural sciences. The question arose as part of the "Englightment Project" in the 18th century, as the belief in science over religion became more important. Science was seen as a provider of true and objective knowledge about the world, which could be used for progress . So the early modernist sociologists thought the same scientific principles could be applied to the understanding and betterment of society. Positivists believe that it is possible and desirable to apply the logic and methods of the natural sciences to the study of society. Society, is like the nature, an objective factual reality ; it is a "real" thing made up of social facts that exists "out there", independently of individuals. They seek to discover the causes of patterns they observe to produce general statements or scientific laws, like natural scientists do. ...read more.


To illustrate sociology as a science, Emile Durkheim conducted a study on suicide. He believed if he could show this highly individual act had social causes, it would establish sociology's status as a distinct and genuinely scientific discipline. Durkheim observed patterns in the suicide rate, by using statistics. For instance, he stated that the suicide rate in Protestant countries like Germany is higher than in Catholic countries like Italy and Spain. He explained it with Catholicism being more successful in integrating individuals. Thus Durkheim claimed to have discovered a real law, that different levels of integration produce different suicide rates. However, Jack Douglas rejects the positivist idea of external social facts determining our behaviour and therefore the view of sociology as being a science. For Douglas the suicide verdicts and the statistics based on them are the product of interactions and negotiations. He argues, we need to use qualitative methods to build up a typology of suicidal meanings. Atkinson even argues that we can never know the real rate of suicide, as all we can study is how the living come to classify a death as a suicide. Although the interpretivists reject the positivist view that sociology is a science, they tend to agree with positivists about the definition of science. Natural science is the inductive reasoning or verificationism applied to the study of observable patterns. ...read more.


So on Kuhn's definition sociology can only become a science if such basic disagreements were resolved. A third view about sociology and science comes from the realist approach. Realists such as Russel Keat and John Urry define science in terms of the degree of control. They distinguish between closed and open systems. In a closed system all variables can be measured and controlled, whereas in an open system the researcher cannot measure all relevant variables, e.g. a meteorologist cannot normally predict the weather with 100% accuracy. Sociology would fit in to the open system, as it is way too complex to have an influence on every factor. In general they say , science studies unobservable as well as observable facts. So to some extent they see sociology as a science, as sometimes we can only observe the effects, e.g. like scientist have never seen a black hole, sociologist can only study the effects of social class. In conclusion, each of these views has implications for whether or not we regard sociology as a science. While positivists adopting natural sciences as a model, interpretivists reject the view that sociology can be scientific. The division is based in the disagreement of the nature of sociology and subject matter. So in fact, if sociology is a science or not depends on the definition of science, the methods being use and the conclusion the researcher states, as you cannot just ignore a whole perspective with valid aspects. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Can and should sociology be a science?

    Furthermore, findings of natural science are reliable. Unlike natural matter, humans do not react in a causal like way to external forces as claimed by positivists. This is because physical matter such as rocks and chemicals give the exact same results to exact stimuli.

  2. Can and should sociology be science?

    To phenomenologist, human beings make sense of the world by imposing meanings and classifications upon it, in the sense that interpretations of facts are dependent on subjective judgment. For instance, a fact to a person does not necessarily be a fact to another.

  1. Emile Durkheim - suicide

    This kind of suicide is commonly seen in some pre-modern society and before western civilization. In anomic suicide, people are naturally selfish. They put their own needs and interests first. It is resulted from low social moral regulation and it is related to economic and domestic conditions and usually occurs from sudden changes on the society.

  2. Sociology independent project - mormons

    Why is Mormonism classified as a religion? Yes it is, under the substantive definition of religion Mormonism is a religion. Mormons believe in: * A supernatural power - they believe God is the power among us in the world just like Christians but they see the traditional church not doing there job properly and have lost the authority of god.

  1. Sociological theories and Healthcare.

    These are still major issues of governments today. For example you'll notice in a government election each candidate from all of the major parties will mention at least 5 of these aspects in their speeches. New Right Margaret Thatcher introduced the New Right theory because she believed that the welfare of the vulnerable should not be underpinned on the government.

  2. Key Perspectives in Sociology

    Quantitative Sociologists often use quantitative methods such as social surveys to investigate a social process or present patterns in social relationships. They will collect information using questionnaires, where people are given a set of written questions to fill in, or structured interviews, where people are asked a specific set of questions and the researcher fills in the answers.

  1. Major Theories in Sociology

    They use aggressive methods to bring on such supremacy. And argue men and women should lead separate lives. Marxist Feminism believes that women have no means of income so they suffer in society. The first feminist was Marry Wollstonecraft, was born in London in 1759.

  2. Assess the view that sociology can and should not model itself on the natural ...

    Positivists thus employ methods to allow maximum objectivity and thus use quantitative methods. These methods also produce reliable data that can be checked by other researchers repeating the experiment. To show that sociology was a science with its own distinctive subject matter Durkheim chose to study suicide.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work