• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Outline and assess the view that the way schools and teaching are organised is more important than external influences, such as the home, in explaining working-class underachievement.

Extracts from this document...


Kirstine Duncan A2 Sociology Outline and assess the view that the way schools and teaching are organised is more important than external influences, such as the home, in explaining working-class underachievement. Working class pupils' underachievement at school may be due to the way school life is structured and the information is delivered. Teachers will use methods of communication that are unfamiliar to working class children which puts them at an immediate disadvantage as the education system is automatically biased against them. Bernstein found differences in the way middle class and working class people communicate. He referred to these as 'codes,' stating that working class people are largely limited to using the 'restricted code' and the middle class the 'elaborated code.' The restricted code is a type of shorthand speech, which is often used between family and friends when the other party in the conversation shares the same common assumptions. In restricted speech sentences are often short or unfinished, information is taken for granted, there is little detail and explanations are not given. The elaborated code is rich in detail and explanation, is very specific and understood by everyone. ...read more.


Although the Rosenthal and Jacobson study is highly valued, their methodology is often seen as sub-standard as the IQ tests were unreliable and poorly administered. Some have suggested that labelling was of little or no significance after attempts to replicate their study produced mixed results. However, many sociologists believe that labelling is significant, and the self-fulfilling prophecy can help explain class differences in educational achievement. Later research shows that there are more factors to be considered. Hargreaves argues that what matters is if the label is accepted by the pupil or 'sticks.' What determines this is; how often the pupil is labelled, whether they value that teacher's opinion, the extent to which others support the label and whether the labelling occurs in public or private. Bird found that pupils more readily accepted academic labels than behavioural ones. Working class children, particularly boys, are often judged to have an attitude problem according to recent research by Troyna. Labelling theory suggests that working class pupils often see these negative labels as a master status, gaining the pupil attention and admiration from their peers that have adopted an anti-learning/ school attitude, evidence of this is found in Willis's study of working class boys. ...read more.


Working class children are more likely to be brought up in an environment where there is less emphasis put on the importance of education and there is an attitude of instant gratification, whilst their middle class counterparts will be taught to defer their gratification. Deferring gratification is a value that coincides with the education system. From an interpretive approach, class differences in attainment are socially constructed and result from the assessment of pupils in terms of teachers' perceptions of social class, ability and conduct. Personally, I think that the values the child inherits or learns from their parents are the most important factor in how much they achieve in education. However, there are so many factors influencing a child that it will often depend upon the individual personality of the pupil as to how much they achieve. To make a generalisation, the working classes do seem to be at an immediate disadvantage as the education system is geared towards the middle class knowledge and values. Whether they are superior or not, it is the middle class attitude that fairs the best in our education system. I think there are many exceptions to broad generalisations such as this, but I think that the working classes are pre-disposed to do less well in education due to their values learned outside of the education system. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Work & Leisure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Work & Leisure essays

  1. a) With reference to the Items and elsewhere, assess the view that the introduction ...

    The different funding levels are unfair concern over proposals to allow grant maintained schools to introduce selection. These schools show the weakening control of the local authority because it had no influence or any business to do with grant maintained schools.

  2. Religion can both be a conservative force and an initiator of social change. To ...

    Calvinist Protestantism originated in the beliefs of John Calvin in the 17th Century. Calvin believed that there was a distinct group - the elect (those chosen to go to heaven) and their fate has been pre-determined by God. Those were not amongst the elect could never go to heaven, regardless of how well they behaved on earth.

  1. Assess the strengths and limitations of participant observation for the study of labelling in ...

    This occurred for Hammersley who found himself writing his notes on the back of a newspaper because he was observing a classroom covertly. Secondly, Students are seen as very vulnerable and this limits the researcher from carrying out a covert study, where the most accurate results are produced.

  2. Sociological explanations of under achievement.

    placed on them by men and their aim is to bring equality between male and female also they believe education as an un equality made by male moreover they argue that women underachieve because education is made by males for males they believe that "Educational system as a reproducing gender

  1. 'Education is a tool of the ruling class'- Discuss.

    Finally, it is criticised for being 'race-blind' and too economistic. The Functionalist perspective is essentially the direct alternative to the statement that 'education is a tool of the working class.' Functionalism sees society as a set of social institutions, which are interdependent upon one another and perform specific tasks that help to produce stability, order and solidarity.

  2. Assess the View that Working Class Children Underachieve Because they are Culturally Deprived

    This can effect a pupils attitude because it can lead to fatalism and an idea that qualifications do not mean much, however in the long run those who are culturally socialised end up with a significantly higher rate of success in all elements of life.

  1. Assess The View That Material Deprivation Is The Most Important Barrier To Educational Attainment.

    The theory of cultural deprivation is that working class groups deprived of certain important factors before school accounts for low educational attainment or underachievement at school. Equality of opportunity can then only become a reality by compensating for the deprivations through education.

  2. Multi-agency working

    * Confronting young offenders with the consequences of their offending and helping them to develop a sense of personal responsibility. * Intervention which tackles the risks associated with offending; personal, family, social, education and health. * Punishment proportionate to seriousness and persistence with a range of penalties open to the courts.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work