• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Prison makes bad people worse". Critically evaluate this statement in the light of rising prison numbers.

Extracts from this document...


PENOLOGY 4. "Prison makes bad people worse". Critically evaluate this statement in the light of rising prison numbers. In the year 2002, there were just over 68,000 persons in prison in England and Wales, 6,000 in Scotland and 1,200 in Northern Ireland. In the case of England and Wales, this is a few thousand more than in 1999, but at this time the plateau stood in marked comparison to the trend up to 1997-8 and it was by no means certain that this could be maintained, (Morgan, 2002). These findings serve to highlight the progressive increase in rising prison numbers in the UK the causes of which are continually in debate and begs the question; What happens when there is no more room left in our prisons? For the purpose of this essay, this author assumes that the statement "prison makes bad people worse" infers that an offender who serves a custodial sentence, is more likely to re-offend upon release. Before evaluating this statement and reaching a conclusion, this author will introduce a brief history of the prison system in an attempt to offer an understanding of how imprisonment has become the most severe penalty imposed on offenders in the UK today. Prisons all over the world have existed for many years for the purpose of confining those in society who have committed a crime serious enough to warrant such a sentence. ...read more.


This may hinder their attempts to live lawful lives for example; problems getting a job and even psychological effects, which may become apparent in their behaviour, (Cavadino & Dignan, 1997). This evidence could be used to support the argument that prison does make people worse. Rehabilitation theory suggests that some forms of punishment can actually reduce the likelihood of re-offending and alter an offender's behaviour and attitude. Together the prison service and the probation service are heavily involved with rehabilitation as well as the treatment and training of offenders, (Wilson et al, 2003). As a main aim of the prison service to assist in the rehabilitation of offenders, the provision of accredited programmes such as PASRO (Prisons Addressing Substance Related Offending) and ETS (Enhanced Thinking Skills) attempt to address prisoners' offending behaviour whilst in prison. However, a report by the Social Exclusion Unit found that the prison experience causes such damage to an offenders' rehabilitation that it outweighs the effectiveness of the programmes, (Solomon, 2003). Another criticism of the penal system is that many offenders are sentenced to such short periods of custody that they are unable to gain access to any rehabilitative interventions. This evidence could also suggest that prison can make bad people worse. The theory of incapacitation implies more emphasis on public protection rather than the behaviour of offenders which coincidently is another main remit of the probation service. ...read more.


This evidence would appear to suggest that people who have served custodial sentences have been made worse by the experience and that imprisonment is not an effective punishment. Contributing to this argument is the theory that these statistics are only obtained from recorded crime suggesting that the figures may in reality be significantly higher as many crimes are not recorded. In conclusion it would appear that there is much evidence to support the claim that prison makes bad people worse such as the statistical evidence revealing reconviction rates. On the other hand, there are also arguments for prison as an effective punishment such as the justifications for imprisonment including rehabilitation and deterrence theories. It would appear that prison does indeed have an influence on some prisoners re-offending but it would be difficult to assume that this is the case for all offenders who have served a custodial sentence. This would suggest that for some offenders prison is effective and for others it is not. Having said this, it is important to recognise that prison does ensure public safety from offenders who pose danger to society, but only for the period they are in custody unless they emerge from prison rehabilitated. For those offenders who could be dealt with in another manner, community penalties offer the versatility in sentencing options necessary to provide effective punishment without contributing to the growing problem of increasing prison numbers. It is therefore vital that the most appropriate punishment is imposed individually taking the crime and the offenders' circumstances into account when sentencing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Crime: Social construction or reality?

    The public's safety must be protected through crime control. The Conservative party of the 1980's shifted to the right. The Conservatives proposed harsher sentences, increasing police protection and generally getting tougher on offenders. Crime is real and is proved real by victims and witnesses.

  2. Describe law and order in London in the late nineteenth century.

    the murderer, it had never been done before and they had no idea where to begin. They did not know which methods were successful and which methods were not. Photographing had just recently been introduced, there was no forensic evidence at the time and the only clues they found were around district and on the deceased bodies.

  1. Punishment and Prisons. This essay shall describe the changes in the methods of punishment ...

    device where prisoners had to turn a crank that merely pushed paddles through sand in a drum), and the 'treadmill'. The idea behind hard labour was to make prison more of a deterrent to committing crime, and also because it helped to keep prisoners 'in line'; tired, exhausted prisoners were

  2. anti-social behaviour

    impinge on their privacy and that the information they provided would be kept confidential. Each respondent was also assured that only honest opinions were wanted and that all results would remain anonymous. 3.6 The questionnaires provided them with a brief introduction detailing the reasons and aims of the investigation.

  1. Describe competing criminological theories

    The amount of activity in the ANS is taken by measuring the conductivity of the skin (electro dermal reactivity) and the amount of cardiac reactivity. Hare and Jutari (1983) discovered that when a psychopathic person is resting their electro dermal reactivity, it is very low.

  2. subcultural theory

    Similarly, Merton has also been criticized by Valier (2001) for his stress on common goals in society. Valier argues that there are in fact, a variety of goals that people strive to attain at any one time. This evidence suggests that the overemphasis upon attaining cultural goals by legitimate means creates a tendency towards anomie.

  1. The purpose of this report is to evaluate and reflect upon my experience of ...

    If we look at Belbins characteristics on completer finisher; this was an allowable weakness for their role. I feel our group could have benefitted from a wider skills mix, and maybe this did contribute to us having a few weaknesses within our group.

  2. Where and how did the Yakuza come to be? What has allowed the yakuza ...

    The second and the most preferred theory by present day yakuza themselves is that their ancestors were the machi yakko, servents of the town. Although little evidence shows the tie between the two, these were folk heroes that were regular peasants who put matters into their own hands to take

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work