• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Some writers have argued that each discipline has 'essential characteristics'. To what extent do you agree with this type of argument? Critically discuss, making use of one or more of the set texts on this course.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Some writers have argued that each discipline has 'essential characteristics'. To what extent do you agree with this type of argument? Critically discuss, making use of one or more of the set texts on this course. 'Will no-one stand up to assert the consciousness of having an aesthetic conscience of his own and bring some spontaneous echo of his inner being, some genuinely individual contributory to the furnishing of his own home.'1 This essay aims to unravel the possible 'essential characteristics' of each discipline in order to determine the credibility of such a universal statement. I will seek to identify the essential characteristic of disciplines in an attempt to support this statement. I will be focusing upon modernism in art, and more specifically, Cubism and Futurism. The last two movements will be shown to offer identifiabble essential characteristics. These will be discussed in relation to their place within modernism, and alongside the essential characteristic of Modernism. It will then be possible too determine if each discipline is characterised by essential traits or if in fact modern art, and subsequently art as a subject, possesses generic essential characteristics. I will discuss whether or not each discipline merely adopts these generic traits in the creation of new movements or whether each discipline is in fact entitled to claim an identity from individual essential characteristics. When art was deemed independent from the service or religion of the state artists were given more scope to express themselves in their work. Expressionism was a movement dominated by Germany in 1905-1925. It included everything expressive and unlike trying to be an exact replica of the subject being portrayed it had abstract qualities. Expressionism was intended to represent the feelings and emotions pf the artist, 'the artist expresses only what he has within himself, not what he sees with his eyes.'2 Colour, abstraction, line, noise, movement, rotation and shape are all expressive and therefore form the essential characteristics of Expressionism, 'the entire arrangement of my pictures is expressive: the place ...read more.

Middle

Futurism not only influenced Italy but had profound effects in Russia, Germany and Britain. Futurism also has close links to Vorticism in that Vorticism was connected with Nazism and the power to rebel, however it is more Illusionist than Futurist. The essential characteristics of the Futurist movement where; colour, movement, dynamism, and reflecting the machine age. The subject and content were very important and where similar to Cubism in that the shapes of some of the artworks where angular in form and the use of collage was also used in Futurism, which was a revolutionary concept of Cubism. It also had similarities to Expressionism in that through the use of text and the strong messages of war, the Futurist's conveyed a form of their expression. What separates it from the other disciplines is that it is of the machine age, and it looks towards the future and not to the past. This was the essential characteristic to Futurism. Without it, it would not have that distinct feature that would separate it from Cubism, and Expressionism. Art works, such as 'Patriotic Celebration', where almost statements of the Twentieth Century living and expresses new technology within the pieces themselves. For example, the introduction of the motor car and the noise associated with industry. The use of cars and speed in the art pieces allows a certain amount of movement. Carra's 'The Red Horseman' (1913) shows movement in that the horse is seen to be running with the use of more than 4 legs being shown on the piece, a kind of mapping of the horses movement. The primary goal of the Futurist was to 'transport the spectator to the centre of the canvas, to involve him in the action of the painting and thus to awaken in him a response with the painters vision, a vision of the "inner core being".'9 The spectator would be drawn to the centre of the array of technical forms, but would then become a participant in the action taking place. ...read more.

Conclusion

Instead of painting the gardens and scenery that the scene could include, whistler concentrates on the sparks and fireworks and the abstract effect that they create. It could be said, therefore that whistler's pieces did have the essential characteristics of traditional representational art, but with the introduction of the scene being painted in darkness the forms change so it represents something quite different. How do you define a work of art without specific characteristics to look for? It is difficult to define modern art in a way that includes all of 20th century western art Using the idea of Picasso's in that art is not evolutionary and that it changes within itself, leaves the suggestion that all art work has essential characteristics but each discipline holds within it a core set of essential characteristics that do not differ from one another, but share certain aspects, in some form or another. This would include the illusion of space, use of colour, whether it be dull greys or fushia pinks, structure and form, identity and towards the twentieth century a degree of flatness within the art works themselves. With this in mind, in answer to whether or not I believe that each discipline has essential characteristics I would say yes, but they are not nessicarily different to each other. Art is a collective term for many disciplines and throughout it's history it has gone through changes but has kept certain recognisable traits that would make it into a work of art. 1 Henry Van de Velde, 'Memours: 1891 - 1901' 2 Alexej von Jawlensky (1864 - 1941) Russian painter of Der Blaue Reiter, das kunstwerk 11, 1948. 3 Henri Matisse 'Notes of a Painter' 4 Herschel B Chipp, Theories of Modern Art, p271 5 6 Pablo Picasso (1881 - 1973) 'Picasso Speaks' Art in Theory 7 Futurism - The Museum of Modern Art, New York, p9 8 Futurism - The Museum of Modern Art, New York, p9 9 Futurism: Politics, Painting and Performance, p22 10 11 12 Pablo Picasso, Conversation, 1935 - Theories of Modern Art, Herschel B Chipp 13 14 15 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. discuss the use of imagery of light and dark in Of Mice and Men

    The barn is growing soft implies that Curley's wife fades away. Her life is end just like the light in the barn. Also the change of light shows the change of time which can help readers better understand the timeline of what happened.

  2. "The Renaissance Is An Important Landmark In The History Of Art, But In Other ...

    The Reformation was a result of the Renaissance but not the result. Another dimension of the Renaissance era, as before mentioned, was the effect it had on commerce in Italy and in the rest of Europe. As Charles Burney, the historian of music put it, "All the arts seem to

  1. Art History Surrealism Project.

    Using automatism the artist produced spontaneous paintings or drawings by suppressing conscious control over the movements of the hand and allowing the subconscious mind to take over. Once an interesting image or form had been achieved by chance it was then developed by consciousness.

  2. Artists express their personal experiences, social values and cultural beliefs through a number of ...

    Leah King-Smith in "Patterns of Connection" has used a non-traditional media and method, which challenges the viewers perceptions of Aboriginal people within her art making. The postmodern frame can be used to analyze this painting, as the work is asking the viewer to look again at history and consider white/Aboriginal relations.

  1. Describe the development of the impressionist movement from Van Gogh to Kandinsky and Klee.

    The geometrical shapes can represent whatever you want it to. Kandinsky's geometrical style is more obvious in 'Several Circles' (Figure 17). There are just simply few circles but he managed to create harmony in the painting and there is balance of light and colour too.

  2. Gender Issues in Art

    'Dora and the Other Women' (1988) is perhaps Siopis' best example of art that explores gender issues. The painting depicts a women standing on a box, trying to cover her naked body with white sheet, one of her breasts exposed. The white of the sheet signifies purity and virginity.

  1. Using explorative strategies to help understand the 'Coca-Cola Advert' lyrics and Picasso's Guernica.

    Now, in isolation, this word is small, short and abbreviated. Yet, according to the poem, the ultimate meaning is far from empty. "Coke" is linked to all the remedies longed for by the world and holds the key to happiness and love.

  2. Since my first encounter with Kandinsky's art I was amazed by their complexity and ...

    a chance to witness at first hand in a very intimate setting the power of Kandinsky's paintings.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work