• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the techniques used in the opening sequences of Roman Polanski's film of 'Macbeth' and the film of Trevor Nunn's RSC production of 'Macbeth'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the techniques used in the opening sequences of Roman Polanski's film of 'Macbeth' and the film of Trevor Nunn's RSC production of 'Macbeth' Act 1 scene 1 of Shakespeare's play 'Macbeth' opens with the three unnatural beings of the play, the witches. The opening of Shakespeare's play is set on a baron heath quiet and deserted the perfect place for weird happenings especially with the claps of thunder in the background. This omits an eerie atmosphere and leaves you in no doubt about the nature of the play. It's going to contain 'toil and trouble' murder and pain as blood is a key symbol in this play. Roman Polanski and Trevor Nunn set their plays in very different ways and though each of the openings contains the same speech the characterisation differs. The establishing shots for each film are at a variance. Polanski's is a desolate beach at sunrise, the blood red sky reflecting off the rippled sand peacefully. The red sky signifies the bloodshed in the play. After the red sky has dissolved, the day broadens. Calm falls upon the vast expanse of land, this false sense of security is short - lived. The next cut is an extreme close up (ECU)of the stick drawing the circle in the sand . Polanski focuses upon their actions more than the witches themselves . I think this is because it shows their deadly and destructive side , and their unnatural behaviour when burying the hand . In comparison Nunn's starts with all the characters standing linked together in a circle, with light cascading over them . It is all lit with stage lightening which differs from Polanski's who was in natural light At first it is difficult to distinguish who these people are , but in time all becomes clear . The camera pans,(moving the camera from right to left or left to right )from one character to another . ...read more.

Middle

Some of the characters are desaturated in green light and others in white like Duncan . This is because he is seen as godly. This is because in Shakespeare's era people believed that kings were chosen by god himself so anything disloyal against the king was treacherous against god. This is why Duncan is seen praying in Nunn's production. After this the witches are shown in dimmed light . There is a large period of time in which the camera's are focussed on the witches(close up shot) . This shows their uncontrollable behaviour and a stereotypical portrait of witches , as it shows them being possessed by something bigger than themselves the ,devil. This makes the audience anxious about what maybe about to happen and they should be. Circles play a big part in both productions;. Circles are a symbol of magic, but they also signify unity a never ending evil. Both the films are set in different places Polanski's set on location , a beach, and Nunn's set on a stage this means the music and sound affects differ . Romans film has the least amount of sound out of the two films however uses the sounds in the natural surroundings . The beach makes its own music, the waves gently lapping onto the shore , the seagulls squawking whilst flying through the air the whistle of the wind sweeping across the vast landscape . Nunn's uses music instead of natural sound he makes dramatic impact with a church organ . This creates an eerie atmosphere . This music changes between each character , when on Duncan a lighter tune is head when focusing on the witches a deep and dramatic sound is produced. In both films the famous words are spoken 'fair is foul and foul is fair'. After this he witches loose control, an ear piercing scream protrudes out of their mouths . ...read more.

Conclusion

Polanski creates the same atmosphere, but does this in the opposite way, with the abstinence of the uncontrolled behaviour. Trevor Nunn's characters are uncontrollable and act more possessed. They are dependent on one another; they seem to rely on their partners and would maybe be lost without them. They are scruffy as you would expect but to a further extent. They have ridiculous costumes which are very stereotypical for witches. On the other hand Polanski's witches are more controlled and less dependent on each other. They are poorly dressed as you would expect but are dressed as you would not expect. They appear calm and collected whilst chanting and after the evil ends they leave on separate paths waiting till they meet again for more evil happenings. Both of the openings are set and directed in different ways. They are both very effective for different reasons. Roman Polanski's is very effective as its use of simple ness and less are more attitudes creating an uneasy sense of calm to the audience. Also how he focuses on the actions of his subjects more than on themselves. This is unusual and how they are calm and normal, unlike the stereotypical view of witches. Trevor Nunn's are the total opposite an uncontrollable group which create an atmosphere of panic and fear. They are extremely stereotypical, scraggy hags which are full of evil greater than themselves and dependent on each other. I prefer Roman's use of sound in his production as it is understated yet powerful, however find Trevor's use of lighting and colour the more striking out of the two. There are similarities in the vision of the two directors they both wish to create an air of mystery and fear but the ways in which they do this are different. There are many key differences like setting, one if filmed on location the other on the stage, another is the type of characters, and one controlled the other the opposite. I prefer Polanski's version even though is far from the way that Shakespeare intended. Mica schneider 11B ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Compare and contrast Roman Polanski's and Orson Welles' film adaptation of the opening scene ...

    He also refers to the original text by presenting the witches as dirty and unclean. It is easy to speculate that one of the older witches is blind, as her eyes are closed throughout the scene. As well as this, another seems to be deaf and the youngest seems to be dumb.

  2. A Comparison of Roman Polanski's film version of Macbeth and the BBC Shakespeare production ...

    It is the calm before the storm and Polankis successfully captures the attention of the audience with the opening scene. When you put the two versions together you can see the difference between the two directors because Sutton takes everything from the book and not one line is changed but

  1. Study and compare two different film interpretations of Act 4 Scene 1 of Shakespeare's ...

    In the opening scene, the colouring would be sepia. The children's voices are replaced with chanting, which creeps up slowly, and the camera follows the sound and is drawn into the Hall of Mirrors. The witches are a vital element of the play as they are the instruments that lead Macbeth towards his path of destruction.

  2. What is Shakespeare's purpose for the witches in Macbeth?

    The witches get away with it. In the play the witches speak differently from the rest of the cast because Shakespeare wants to tell the audience when the witches are on and to create a sense of fear in the audience and to keep the audience focused on the play. The witches sometimes speak in riddles.

  1. What part do the witches play in Shakespeare's Macbeth?

    I would also have their voices coming from all around as I think that all this contributes to keeping the audience's attention and drawing them in. I would stay quite loyal to the script in how the apparitions would look.

  2. Review of Macbeth Production

    Macduff's house, and Macbeth's castle). There was little music used in the production, but the little that there was, was used at the right times to add atmosphere to the scenes. When the witches started singing at the beginning, it was creepy as well as beautiful, which is how the witches were represented throughout the play.

  1. Study three dramatised interpretations of Macbeth

    It is fairly recent compared to the rest as it was produced in 1998. This interpretation is set in a warehouse, away from the public view. The first image we see is of the three witches sitting around a pentacle as the dominant witch lays out tarot cards.

  2. Compare & contrast the opening scene of Shakespeare's Macbeth as portrayed by Roman Polanski ...

    The first witch draws a circle in the sand and the second and third continue to dig it out representing a cauldron. Their appearance is, as you would expect is stereotypical, with old withered faces, gnarled hands, wearing rags. One of the witches has blonde hair underlining the modern aspect of the play.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work