• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine how the women in two stories are treated by the men in their lives.

Extracts from this document...


March 2002 Keri Roberts Examine how the women in two stories are treated by the men in their lives Two short fiction stories which show how women are treated by the men in their lives are The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion and Weekend. The first story is a pre-1914 story called 'The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion' and it is written by Thomas Hardy. The story is set in 1801 and it was published in 1891.The other story is a more modern story as it is set in the late twentieth century and was published in 1981. It is called 'Weekend' and it is written by a feminist writer called Fay Weldon. The main theme of The Melancholy of the German Legion is how a woman is treated with little independence and how the main female character, Phyllis Grove, tries to find her own freedom by forming a strong friendship with a German soldier that escalates into a relationship. Phyllis is a shy, young character who lives in a secluded manor house with her father, Dr Grove, who was a professional and well-respected gentleman. There now appears to be a lack of money in the Grove household. ...read more.


He treated Phyllis as though she were equal to him and there was no hint of a divide between them due to her being female. He respected her fully and never let her down, unlike Humphrey Gould who broke off the engagement. He may have treated her with more respect and freedom than the other main men in her life as he was German and in his country they may have been more hospitable towards women. Martin is the male in focus in Weekend and his is a very obnoxious character. He is married to Martha and he is a freelance designer and there are clues in the story which suggest that he is in his forties, for example 'he watches the BBC2 news,' which is typical of a middle-aged person. Martin treats Martha as more of a servant than a wife and he puts all of the responsibilities onto her. He seems to think that he is too good to be doing housework and odd-jobs and Martha is left to do long lists of chores, 'prepare tea and sandwiches for the family: then she would strip four beds,' the chores seem endless. ...read more.


There are many non-sentences, such as 'Katy versus Janet,' which do not contain a verb and are more of a thought .There are many compound sentences that use words such as then, but, and, so, which helps Martha to express how many jobs she has to do. This use of language is well suited to the date in which the story was set. The role and rights of women changed quite a lot in the period of time between when the two books were written. In 1801, nobody had the chance to vote and your right to a say depended on your position in society. Men with homes got the vote in 1867, all men got the vote in 1916 and women didn't get the vote until 1926. This meant that for along time women were seen as being lower than men and were provided for by their husbands. Other turning points for women in this time span were that they were able to get jobs and were protected by The Sex Discrimination Act,1975. This explains why Martha had a job and Phyllis didn't, but there is still no explanation to support why Martha was treated so badly in modern day Britain. My conclusion is that Fay Weldon was trying to get across that some traditions never change. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. Compare two short stories where the characters face difficult situations

    At the very end she goes into what seems to be a mental breakdown, 'I knew you'd come back, I knew you'd come back to me', although the daughter has not come home. In 'Flight', I think the author is trying to say that if you hold something too tight

  2. A comparison between to Modern poems, "Warning" by Jenny Joseph, and "Old Man, Old ...

    Both "Old Man, Old Man" by U.A. Fanthorpe and "Warning" by Jenny Joseph contain different interpretations of old age from different perspectives.

  1. Speaking out for those without a voice

    smallest things can convey status and yet keep the character so real. We were split in half and asked to respond to any one or all of the stimuli we had worked on. We were then given a drama strategy to include in the piece of work and we were asked to mark the moment.

  2. This essay will be analyzing and discussing the story "Flight" by Dorris Lessing and ...

    Her daughter has run away, she is worried. But you can see how she thinks about a lot of little things to do with her daughter, she is very inquisitive, she asks questions which she knows no-one will answer which shows she is a good mother but she is unconfident and doesn't believe she is a good mother.

  1. As a part of our GCSE Drama assessment we have explored the topic of ...

    In the 1918 image we showed the audience the reason that people would come back from war as completely different people through physical expression. As an example we showed me standing over the Lieutenant (played by Georgia) with absolutely no sympathy, whilst she was mourning.

  2. The statue of Ni-ka-re, His Wife and Their Daughter is one of the best ...

    It should also be mentioned that in each statue the dominant figure of the family is made much larger than all the other family members. It was a usual practice for Egyptian sculptors to do so in order to point out the person's importance and preserve it for his afterlife (Strouhal, 1992).

  1. We had to create a tableaux image of the four strong words in the ...

    The newspapers bordering the past and present section means that whatever is printed in the newspapers is always in the past, you can look back at it by reading the newspapers but you cannot visit it. Whereas the newspapers with only a headline and no other text represents the present

  2. In the short story, "Good Country People," Flannery O'Connor tells us that everyone's lives ...

    These two characters are stuck in unhappy situations. They both rely on the things they have rather than on themselves. Mrs. Hopewell would say that, "Glynese and Carramae are both fine girls" (O'Connor 136). She would also say that she admired them for their common sense and that not many girls had what they had (O'Connor 137).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work