• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9

A comparison of a pre-twentieth century and a twentieth century novel.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A comparison of a pre-twentieth century and a twentieth century novel Throughout this essay I am going to compare chapter seven of Jane Eyre with chapter eleven of To Kill A Mockingbird, bringing out any similarities of character, theme and narrative technique. Although these two novels were both written in different countries and were published nearly one hundred years apart they do share the following in common; they both have contemptible characters, admirable characters, common themes of child rearing and prejudice, and similar narrative techniques. Firstly, both chapters contain characters whom we admire and whom we condemn. In Jane Eyre, characters we admire are Jane herself, Miss Temple and Helen Burns. Jane Eyre is the eponymous hero of the novel, because of her feisty attitude and her spirited defiance. She answers back to Mrs Reed and stands up to Mr Brocklehurst in an earlier chapter and here in chapter 7 Charlotte Bronte writes: "in an impulse of fury against Reed....bounded in my pulses at the conviction." However to a Victorian audience this would have been shocking as women were viewed as the weaker gender and it was unheard of for children to be defiant. Miss Temple is another character that we admire in Jane Eyre. She is caring and concerned. This is seen when she gives the children bread and cheese instead of burnt porridge. This is somewhat admirable and brave because Miss Temple is risking her job when she does this. Also, she stands up for the rights of others, which shows courage. For example when Mr Brocklehurst shows his prejudice towards girls with curly hair she answers him directly: "Julia's hair curls naturally." Therefore we see the courage coming from Miss Temple to object to Mr Brocklehurst's unfair demands. In addition, Miss Temple's kind nature is seen furthermore when she whispers words of courage to Jane when she whispers the comforting words: "Don't be afraid Jane, I saw it was an accident, you shall not be punished." ...read more.

Middle

by allowing admired characters to see them as unjust. On the other hand Helen's punishments are unjust because she could not possibly wash her hand because the water was frozen. The punishments in Jane Eyre are seen as unjust because we see them from Jane's point of view. She is the heroin of the novel so we tend to side with her. Also Miss Temple sees the punishments as irrational and the reader's side with her because she is admired for reasons I have previously mentioned. The novel Jane Eyre therefore gives us an important message on how to bring up children. It suggests that to bring up children you must do it with compassion, kindness and respect. This will gain obedience, trust and respect in return. I have come to this conclusion as Mr Brocklehurst treats the children harshly and brutally, consequently the children resent him. To Kill a Mockingbird also deals with the theme of child rearing. In Mockingbird we see a contrast in the approaches between Atticus and Uncle Jack. We see Atticus as a good listener, and fair minded. However we see Uncle Jack as unfair and quick to jump to conclusions, when Scout says: "Uncle Jack said if I talked he'd lick me again." Therefore we get two different perspectives on punishing and child rearing methods. We also see another similarity between chapter seven of Jane Eyre and chapter eleven of To kill a Mockingbird. We realise that Mr Brocklehurst's quick temper is like that of Uncle Jack's. In To Kill a MockingbirdMockingbird, Scout and Jem are punished by having to make amends for cutting the tops of Mrs Dubose's camellias. They are punished so that they learn from their mistake. Scout and Jem are treated with dignity (Atticus never hits them, although he allows Calpurnia to) we see how Atticus desires for his children to acquire awareness of their faults: "There's no point in saying you were sorry if you aren't...... then you'll do it for a month." ...read more.

Conclusion

The opportunity for irony gives us a double perspective (going back once again to the reference about the confederate army relic...) This line therefore creates a different view point between the reader and the narrator. Finally, I have now come to the conclusion that these two novels do indeed share many things in common. They have characters we admire and condemn. These characters are all similar to one another. For instance Atticus is caring and loving, just like Miss Temple of Jane Eyre. Mrs Dubose is prejudiced and hypocritical, like Mr Brocklehurst. Although Jane Eyre was set in 19th century England, and Mockingbird in the 1930s, they both contain humour; pathos and suspense. First person narrative is used and they both deal with the theme of prejudice. Also they convey similar messages of how to raise children (with respect, firmness, dignity and care) Both novels say something revolutionary about the times they were set in. Jane Eyre speaks out for women's rights and To Kill a Mockingbird challenges the policy of racial segregation and caste systems in the south of America, at the time. Therefore Both novels are significant to their contemporaries as well as readers today. Personally the most important theme for me in Jane Eyre is that of stoicism. It made me realise that hardship is not necessarily a bad thing, but should be endured or embraced so that it can be a form of preparation for life in the future. (just how Jane was prepared to reject love without marriage and marriage without love) I think that racial prejudice is an important theme in To Kill a Mockingbird because it highlights the sad views on races and cast systems and how far society has come today. For example, black people have overall the same rights as whites do today. Mockingbird acts a a reminder of how prejudice can be painful to every walk of life (even Scout and Jem are affected by racial prejudice, even though they are white!) It conveys the message that prejudice in any shape or form is a bad path to take. By Anjuli Modaley ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Charlotte Bronte section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Charlotte Bronte essays

  1. Jane Eyre - How has the character changed throughout the novel?

    Brocklehurst, she might not have set herself against them, but as it is, she has felt immediately that he must not have the right of it. The second main stage of Jane's life is her time at Thornfield as a governess.

  2. EXAMINE THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JANE EYRE'S RELATIONSHIP WITH HELEN BURNS

    In contrast to this, Jane's reaction to Miss Scratcherd's behaviour is a disgusted motion. Jane strongly disagrees with Helen's response to the teacher's unfair punishment and personally I think that Jane is puzzled at why Helen accepts this sort of manipulation.

  1. Discuss the treatment of women in society with reference to Charlotte Bronte's 'Jane Eyre' ...

    Evidence of this was her embarrassment in her teens when her mother rallied for women's rights, and the fact that she had a secret affair with Luke, paying for hotel rooms to meet him, before their relationship became open and they got married.

  2. Explore the Theme of Education in Jane Eyre.

    Jane shows immense determination at many times throughout the narrative: leaving Lowood for an unknown environment takes great courage, as does leaving Mr Rochester. Nevertheless, Jane decides to attempt to better her situation, and knows what she needs to do in order to do so.

  1. Show clearly through reference to the novel, the development of Jane's character in Charlotte ...

    Mr Lloyd was the apothecary. Sending the apothecary, not the doctor, shows how social class was evident. Mrs Reed thought Jane was not good enough for a doctor, however, Jane was very much aware of her class, even at ten years old, '...Abbot says I have less right to be here at Gateshead Hall, than a servant'.

  2. How are ideas about religion examined through the characters of Mr Brocklehurst, Eliza Reed ...

    He makes Jane learn Hindustani, the language of the place where he will go to spend the rest of his life, preaching God's word. St Jane does manage to control Jane to a certain extent, as she explains 'when he said 'go', I went; 'come', I came; 'do this', I

  1. Compare chapter 7 from 'Jane Eyre' with the extract from chapter 1 of 'Roll ...

    me that she must be a really kind person because she shares her 'morsel', which means a piece or a scrap of bread, she also describes the bread as 'precious' this is really sad because it shows how much she needed the bread, but Jane shares her bread so that the other girls wouldn't starve.

  2. What is your opinion of Mr. Brocklehurst?

    Upon hearing that Miss Temple ordered a lunch of bread and cheese for the girls because they were unable to eat breakfast, he tells her that "should any accidental disappointment of the appetite occur....

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work