• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Act 3 scene 5 "Romeo and Juliet". Compare and contrast two film versions of this scene, saying which you prefer. Consider how effectively Shakespeare's play has been interpreted.

Extracts from this document...


Act 3 scene 5 "Romeo and Juliet". Compare and contrast two film versions of this scene, saying which you prefer. Consider how effectively Shakespeare's play has been interpreted. The two versions I have studied are Franco Zeffirelli's paramount film and Alvin Rakoff's BBC version. Both films were produced in the 1960s. The BBC film is aimed at students studying the play but Zeffirelli's version is aimed at a much wider cinema audience. I think that it is the much larger budget and involvement of a world famous director that makes the paramount film much more successful. Zeffirelli's version is well acted and the performance of Olivia Hussey and Leonard Whiting make the film seem more realistic. The scene opens at dawn and the two lovers are in bed. The camera gives a close up of their faces, which is very effective, because it emphasizes how young they are and how peaceful and contented they seem to be together. There is a warm atmosphere in the room I think this is because there is pink filter on the camera lens, which also makes it look very romantic. ...read more.


Her expression, mannerisms and tone of voice match her words: "Some grief shows much of love But much of grief shows still some want of wit". Lady Capulet does not comfort Juliet or seem like the motherly type, which I think, is an interpretation of Shakespeare's character. Some people might say that Olivia Hussey over acts when she is told about her arranged marriage, but I do not agree. I think it just shows how upset she is about Romeo being banished to Mantua, how much in love she is and the shock because she had not been expecting this news at all. When Lady Capulet goes to her husband one thing I noticed was the similarity of costume, which is obviously a deliberate decision. He is dressed in black also wearing a chain that looks very heavy around his neck. When Lady Capulet tells him that Juliet does not want to marry Paris he gets very angry. As he is marching up the stairs to Juliet's room, it allows his anger time to build up as his voice raise and starts to echo. He finally bursts through Juliet's bedroom door, and his rage looks very believable, when Capulet throws Juliet to the ground, the nurse is ...read more.


Capulet is wearing similar style of costume to Lady Capulet's and I think this seems to set them apart from Juliet as if to show that they do not have a close relationship with her. During Capulet's angry outburst, it does not come across that the nurse and Juliet are as close as they should be. The nurse just stands passively whereas in the paramount film she tries to protect her. Perhaps the director wants to emphasize Capulet's power and show the nurse to be afraid of him but I do not think this works well. Overall Zeffirelli's film in my opinion is far superior. It is acted better and is more realistic. The speech is slower and with quite a lot of the original script cut it would be easy even for someone who is not familiar with the play to understand it. The costumes are of a better design compared to the BBC's costumes. Zeffirelli's film is an Academy award winner for best cinematography and best costume design. I think the BBC's film is also quite good but less talented actors and the speech is spoken very quickly to get all the lines in, which is not as effective. The BBC film would be good to help students understand the play but the paramount film would appeal to a wider audience. Mandy Armstrong ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Comparing two versions of Romeo & Juliet (Zefferelli and Baz Luhram).

    It seems that the nurse uses very simple and common language, which maybe shows her status in the household compared to Lady and Lord Capulet. In Act 2 Scene 5, drama is created by a certain dramatic trait, the use of suspense, which is mixed with dramatic irony when Juliet returns to the nurse with Romeo�s plans for marriage.

  2. How effectively do Baz Luhrmann and Franco Zeffirelli interpret Act I Scene VI when ...

    calm Tybalt down, he is not bothered that the Montague's are at his party, he seems only interested in having a good time. When Tybalt does not back down and leave the subject alone Lord Capulet tells him that he will put up with the Montague's being there because it is his party and he doesn't want any trouble.

  1. Concentrating on act 3 scene 1 of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, how effective do ...

    This theme of prophecy ties in with the universal theme of Fate. The first noticeable change of tone in the original text comes with Tybalt's confrontation of Mercutio. However, the original text is ambiguous in that the wordplay between Mercutio and Tybalt at that point suggests that there is no real aggression involved in the fight.

  2. In this essay I shall be discussing the differences and similarities between two film ...

    An old grudge is still, Where locals fight each other, From the parents of the two hates, The two lovers commit suicide, Unfortunate pitiful disappointment, When they die their parent's grudge is removed, The scary time of their death brought love.

  1. Romeo and Juliet Act 3, scene 1 is a pivotal scene in the play. ...

    Shakespeare includes pun to show off his wit and craft to amuse his audience. I would have Romeo entering and smiling, acting as if he wants to have a good time, maybe having him running in enthusiastically and smiling, in order to show how happy he is.

  2. Comparison between the two versions of Romeo and Juliet

    Arranged love was also experienced a lot in this time too. The family thought not of love, but of wealth and the family status. Juliet's mother and father were married this way and Shakespeare shows that they had a bad marriage.

  1. The Generation Gap:comparing the starts of two film versions of Romeo and Juliet

    While the setting was updated, Baz Luhrmann seemed to follow more closely the original dialogue and meaning of Romeo and Juliet. Like Zeffirelli, Baz Luhrmann also used young actors to portray Romeo and Juliet. Young, good-looking, and increasingly popular Leonardo Di Caprio played Romeo.

  2. Compare two film versions of Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet.

    This whole scene is symbolic as Tybalt is the main character that 'adds fuel to the feud' and this scene takes place in a petrol station. But in Zeffirelli's version the families meet in a busy open market. It's all hustle and bustle.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work