Romeo and Juliet - "Compare and contrast act 2 scene 2 and act 5 scene 3 of the play with Luhrmann's treatment of these scenes in the film "Romeo and Juliet."

Authors Avatar

Compare and contrast act 2 scene 2 and act 5 scene 3 of the play with Luhrmann’s treatment of these scenes in the film “Romeo and Juliet.

“Romeo and Juliet” is both a film about love and tragedy, and the war and peace between the two rival families, the Montagues and the Capulets. All of this love, tension and emotion are shown through Shakespeare’s play with words and emotive language to truly bring their feelings alive. From his extended metaphors of water, light, religion and heaven, Shakespeare really shows their passion and devotion for each other; this is what Luhrmann really picks up on and utilises as his inspiration for his film version of this well known play and is why Shakespeare’s language is so important to the overall feel, character and artistic visual of the film; from the symbols to the seemingly unplanned movement of characters in a scene.

        In Act 2 Scene 2 of the play Shakespeare used the theme of light to show the bright and fiery love Romeo sees in her. “Oh speak again Bright Angel”, Romeo describes Juliet as he talks to her in the “light through yonder window breaks?” Throughout this scene Shakespeare uses many metaphors to show this brightness and love Romeo sees in Juliet; “Juliet is the sun”, “Arise fair sun and kill the envious moon”; both quotes show the love Romeo sees in her, but talking about her as so bright, and such a  marvelous and great thing as the sun. I also think this metaphor tells us something about Romeo’s character; the sun is what gives life to almost all living things, and in this case, it is Juliet that brings Romeo to life; after all goes from being miserable, moaning about his unrequited love for Rosaline, of when “he jests at scars that never felt a wound”, but when he sees and meets Juliet, his whole attitude towards love, and what love is changes. It is as though someone had the turned the light on for him or switched true love “on”. This sudden change in Romeo is like a new life for him, as though Juliet, “the sun”, gave him it.

        In the film “Romeo + Juliet”, Luhrmann interprets this in many different ways. When we first see Juliet in the Capulet mansion’s garden, Juliet appears first from the bright light of her bedroom window; a quite literal interpretation of “What light through yonder window breaks?” But the metaphor of Juliet as the sun is carried throughout the scene. At all times in this scene, Juliet’s face is lit up “fair” even when talking to Romeo at eye level; from the bright lights beneath the pool and the glimmering moonlight bouncing off the reflective water. I feel the brightness upon her face really shows how Luhrmann interpreted Shakespeare’s words. Furthermore, like the sun which sets and rises, Juliet also does the same at the start and the end of the play. In the night, when the sun has set, Juliet comes down from her bedroom window via the brightly lit elevator. This shows that Juliet, the sun, has set; and this is emphasised by the strong light from within. The sun has set. In contrast, to the end of the play, when “’tis almost morning”, Juliet immediately rises back up the long stair case, like the sun rising for the new day. Also, this idea of the sun setting and rising could be, in my opinion, an enemy to their love. Romeo and Juliet’s relationship can not be found out, because of the hazardous consequences of the rival families. On the other hand the sun is like the light which could find them out, the reason they must meet in the dark; Juliet’s position in the Capulet household, one of importance, means if Romeo is seen, he is a dead man for sure.

Join now!

        Shakespeare’s language mentions a lot about water; of Romeo’s willingness to sail the greatest seas to find her “I am no pilot, yet were thou as far as that vast shore washed with the farthest sea, I should adventure”. Juliet responds to this by describing her love as “boundless and deep as the sea”. These references to water in the play are all metaphors; they describe their love, and what they will do for their love, but Luhrmann interprets this use of water in a different more creative and interesting route, turning into a different metaphor, for purity and purification.

...

This is a preview of the whole essay